Isaac Blesses Jacob (Gen. 27:1-27) Doré’s English Bible. Date 1866
The Source of Jacob’s Two Blessings
Published: November 18, 2014
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
See, for example, Genesis Rabbah 67:12 as well as Lekach Tov, Sechel Tov, and R. Shimshon Rafael Hirsch’s commentary (ad loc.).
It appears that this interpretation was originally suggested by the Reform Rabbi and Bible scholar, Benno Jacob (1862-1945). It was expanded upon by R. Bernard Solomon (יששכר) Jacobson (1901-1972) in his Binah BeMikra on Parashat Toledot, in an essay titled, “Isaac Blesses his Sons: The Tragic Mistake.” It is also taken for granted throughout Yehudah Kiel’s commentary on this story (Da’at Mikra on Genesis, volume 2.)
Jacob was 130 when he migrated to Egypt (Gen. 47:9) at a time which Joseph was 39 years old (gen. 41:46) Which makes Jacob 91 when Joseph was born. Joseph was born either in the 14th or 20th year in Laban’s house. This would mean Jacob was 77or 71 when he was blessed. For a different calculation see Rashi 28:9
The name “El Shaddai” is a classic marker of a P text.
Not perfectly smoothly. Read in context, 28:5 seems superfluous; we already know that Isaac sent him to Paddan-Aram. Also, 28:6, where Esau hears what his father said, reads as if this is the first time we are hearing it as well. Thus, it seems possible that an older version of the story contained no blessing at all, and that 28:5 originally followed 27:46. However, even if this admittedly speculative suggestion is correct, the addition of the blessing would have been an internal P redaction, still not relevant to the story in J. (ZIF)
A number of scholars have argued that some of this story should be ascribed to E because of the doublets. However, the doublets could be redactional as well. The matter is complicated and beyond the scope of this tab.