Blood, Frogs, and Impurity

Three curious details in the plagues of blood and frogs show the hand of a post-priestly editor and his concern about purity laws.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Blood, Frogs, and Impurity." TheTorah.com, January 14, 2021. https://www.thetorah.com/article/blood-frogs-and-impurity.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Blood, Frogs, and Impurity" (2021, January 14). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/blood-frogs-and-impurity

Blood, Frogs, and Impurity

Passover Haggadah, Braginsky Collection B317, f.28, c. 1739. e-codices

Categories:

Va’era

Published: January 14, 2021

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. I am using the standard enumeration of the plagues, beginning with blood, though this enumeration is never explicit in the biblical text. Enigmatic details like the ones noted in this essay appear in other plagues as well, but I will here concentrate only on the first two plagues.

  2. See the discussion in Cornelis Houtman, Exodus, Historical Commentary on the Bible (Kok: Kampen, 1996), 2.35–37. Rabbinic midrash has its own twist on this literal approach, by translating the term עצים not as wood but as trees, and suggesting it refers to fruit juice (Mishnat Rabbi Eliezer, §19, p. 344):

    ...כל המים השאובים ששאבו אותן בכלים קודם לכאן נהפכו כולן ונעשו דם בתוך הכלים, שנא' הפך את מימיהם לדם. אף מימי כל ה[פ]ירות, כיון שהן נסחטין, מיד הן נעשין דם, שנא' ובעצים ובאבנים.
    …All of the drawn water that [the Egyptians] has drawn into vessels before [the plague] turned to blood inside the vessels, as it says (Ps 105:29), “he changed their waters to blood.” Even the liquid inside fruits, once they were squeezed, would immediately turn to blood, as it says “and on trees (eitzim) and in stones.”
  3. See also Deut 28:64; 29:16; 2Kgs 19:18; Isa 37:19; Ezek 20:32.

  4. The same interpretation appears in the 11th century Byzantine commentaries Leqaḥ Tov and Sekhel Tov (ad loc.), as well as in the midrashic anthologies Yalqut Shimoni (Exod §182) and Midrash HaGadol (ad loc.).

  5. Editors note: For a reading of the narrative which assumes many such subtle jabs at Egyptian religion, see Gary Rendsburg, “YHWH’s War against the Egyptian Sun-God Ra,” TheTorah (2016).

  6. A similar interpretation can be found in the commentary of Umberto, except that he believes the phrase refers to the water used by the Egyptian priests to bathe the wood and stone idols. See, Umberto Cassuto, A Commentary on the Book of Exodus, trans. Israel Abrahams (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1967), 99, trans. of פירוש על ספר שמות (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1942).

  7. The biblical category does not conform to any scientific division of animal types but includes reptiles, amphibians, small mammals, and bugs.

  8. The text does not tell us how long the first plague lasted, though some scholars suggest that it implies that the length of the first plague was seven days; see e.g., Rainer Albertz, Exodus 1–18, Zürcher Bibelkommentare Altes Testament 2.1 (Zürich: TVZ, 2012), 147.

  9. The correlation between impurity laws and this verse was noted in the Leqaḥ Tov commentary (ad loc.) of R. Tobiah ben Eliezer (ca. 1050–1108):

    וימלא שבעת ימים—למה שבעת ימים? לפי שמכת הדם היא טומאת האשה הנדה, מה טומאת הנדה שבעת ימים, אף מכת מצרים בדם שבעת ימים.
    “Seven days were fulfilled”—Why seven days? Because the plague of blood corresponds to the impurity of a menstrual woman. Just as the impurity of a menstrual woman lasts seven days, so too the plague of blood in Egypt was seven days.

    While R. Tobiah sees the plague lasting for this period, to my mind the correlation is really about the purification period.

  10. For comparison, see e.g., the stipulations in Lev 11:39–40; 15:24; Num 19:11, 14, 16.

  11. Since the suffixes are in the singular, reference is clearly made to Pharaoh’s ovens and kneading bowls, not to those of the Egyptians.

  12. While rabbinic midrash and Rashi’s commentary claim that all the plagues followed this pattern, medieval peshat commentators, such as Rashbam and ibn Ezra, already insisted that it only applied to the plague of blood.

  13. The additions appear both in the Priestly (Exod 7:19) and the non-Priestly (Exod 7:25, 28) strands.

  14. For a discussion of the Priestly vs. non-Priestly material, see e.g., Marc Zvi Brettler, “Source Criticism: It's in the (Plague of) Blood,” TheTorah (2015); Tzemah Yoreh, “The Three Redactional and Theological Layers of the Plagues,” TheTorah (2016). For my own view, see Christoph Berner, Die Exoduserzählung: Das literarische Werden einer Ursprungslegende Israels, Forschungen zum Alten Testament 73 (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2010).