Elisha Raising the Son of the Shunammite, 1881 (colorized), p.369, The life, letters and work of Frederic Leighton
Elisha’s Miracles: Holiness or Hubris?
With a miracle of an overflowing jar of oil, Elisha saves a widow’s sons from debt-slavery. He then grants the Shunammite woman a child and later resurrects that child from an untimely death. Both stories craft a portrait of a prophet exercising powers usually reserved for God. Is this prophetic hagiography or criticism of his encroachment on God’s domain?
Published: November 5, 2025
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
For an in-depth study of the Elisha cycle, see my book, Elisha: The Holy Man of God, trans. Lenn J. Schramm, VTSup 200 (Leiden: Brill, 2025).
See, e.g., Alexander Rofé, The Prophetical Stories: The Narratives About the Prophets in the Hebrew Bible, Their Literary Types and History (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1988), 13–26 on short legends and 27–33 on long legends.
Biblical translations follow NJPS, with modifications.
Cry for help addressed to God – Exod 8:8; 14:15; Num 12:13; Judg 10:12; Ps 77:2, etc. Cry to a foreign king – Gen 41:55; cry to an Israelite king – 1 Kgs 20:39; 2 Kgs 6:26; 8:3, 5. But cf. also the cry of the people of Israel to Moses (Num 11:2).
This parallel was noted by Rofé, The Prophetical Stories, 50.
This story seems to have been the target of most of the critical assessments of Elisha. See, e.g.: Rofé, The Prophetical Stories, 29–30; Mary E. Shields, “Subverting a Man of God, Elevating a Woman: Role and Power Reversals in 2 Kings 4,” JSOT 58 (1993): 59–69; Uriel Simon, Reading Prophetic Narratives, trans. Lenn J. Schramm (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1997), 227–262; Wesley J. Bergen, Elisha and the End of Prophetism, JSOTSup 286 (Sheffield: Sheffield Academic, 1999), 97–104; Yairah Amit, “A Prophet Tested: Elisha, the Great Woman of Shunem, and the Story’s Double Message,” Biblical Interpretation 11 (2003): 279–294.
See, for example, Bergen, Elisha and the End of Prophetism, 99, 101, 104; Amit, “A Prophet Tested,” 287.
See Amit, “A Prophet Tested,” who sees Elisha’s forcing the miracle upon God as an act of arrogance toward the divine.
This understanding of the miraculous birth in Shunem can be traced back to the Midrash (Deut. Rabbah 10:3). To support his statement that “everything that God does, the righteous do,” the homilist invokes several miracles performed by Elisha and Elijah, beginning with this one. The same view is evident in another midrash:
מדרש תהילים עח רבי אחא בשם רבי יונתן אמר שלש מפתחות הן.... ואין משליטן לבריה אלא לידו. של רחם מנין שנאמר (בראשית כט לא) וירא ה' וגו' ויפתח את רחמה.... וכשהוא רוצה מוסרן לצדיקים. של עקרה נתן לאלישע שנאמר (מלכים-ב ד טז-יז) כעת חיה את חובקת בן.
Midrash Tehillim 78 R. Aḥa stated in the name of R. Jonathan: There are three keys... which He [God] does not give over into the hands of an emissary: the key to the womb, for it is said, And the Lord saw…and opened her womb (Gen 29:31); …Nevertheless, when it pleased Him to do so, He gave the keys over to righteous men. The key to [the womb of] a barren women, God gave over to Elisha, for it is said, “In due time, you shall embrace a son” (2 Kgs 4:16).
Translation follows William G. Braude, trans. Midrash on Psalms (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1959), 2:25, with modifications.
Shields, “Subverting a Man of God, Elevating a Woman,” 63; Bergen, Elisha and the End of Prophetism, 97; Amit, “A Prophet Tested,” 282. The Zohar later identifies the boy as Habakkuk:
ספר הזהר, הקדמה יב דָּחִיל רִבִּי שִׁמְעוֹן וּבְכָה אָמַר (חבקוק ג:ב) יְיָ שָׁמַעְתִּי שִׁמְעֲךָ יָרֵאתִי. הַאי קְרָא חֲבַקּוּק אָמַר (אמרו) בְּשַׁעֲתָא דְּחֲמָא מִיתָתֵיהּ וְאִתְקַיָּים עַל יְדָא דֶאֱלִישָׁע. אַמַּאי אִקְרֵי חֲבַקּוּק. בְּגִין דִּכְתִיב, (מלכים ב ד:יז) לַמּוֹעֵד הַזֶּה כָּעֵת חַיָּה אַתְּ חוֹבֶקֶת בֵּן. וְדָא בְּרֵיהּ (ברה) דְּשׁוּנַמִּית הֲוָה. וּתְרֵין (בשלח מ"ה ע"א) חִבּוּקִין הֲווּ, חַד דְּאִימֵיהּ וְחַד דֶּאֱלִישָׁע. דִּכְתִיב, (מלכים ב ד:לד) וַיָּשֶׂם פִּיו עַל פִּיו.
Zohar, Introduction 12 R. Simeon trembled and wept. “O Lord, I have heard the report of you, and I am afraid” (Hab 3:2), he said. This verse did Habakkuk exclaim at the time when he reflected on his own death and his resurrection through Elisha. Why was he named HaBaKkuK? Because it is written, “At this season when the time comes round, you shall be embracing (HoBeKeth) a son” (2 Kgs 4:16), and he—Habakkuk—was the son of the Shunammite. He received indeed two embracings, one from his mother and one from Elisha, as it is written, “and he put his mouth upon his mouth” (2 Kgs 4:34).
Translation follows The Zohar (London: Soncino, 1933), with modifications.
Had the narrator wanted to indicate that Elisha worked a miracle that cannot last, we would expect the realization of his promise to be followed immediately by something like “some time later the son of the Shunammite woman died.” Instead, we learn that the child grew up (v. 18). Cf. the account of the death of the son of the widow of Zarephath (1 Kgs 17:17).
We are to understand that after staying out too long under the broiling harvest sun the child succumbed to heatstroke or sunstroke, as frequently happens in hot climates. This view can be traced back to the Jerusalem Talmud, where it is expressed by R. Mana (y. Yevamot 15:2 [14d]).
See, for example, Shields, "Subverting a Man of God, Elevating a Woman,” 65–66; Amit, “A Prophet Tested,” 282.
Simon, Reading Prophetic Narratives, 233, 258.
The previous emphasis on the child being laid on Elisha’s bed (v. 21) and Elisha’s use of his staff here suggest that there may be an element of magic in the story, reflecting the notion, common in saints’ legends, that the personal effects of holy people absorb their sanctity and acquire their own intrinsic power to work miracles. See Itzchak Ganuz, “The Personal Belongings of Tsaddikim as Treasures of Virtues,” Proceedings of the 10th World Congress of Jewish Studies, Division D (1989): 29–31 (Hebrew).
The narrator conveys the prophet’s surprise by suddenly shifting to his point of view by means of the word הִנֵּה (hinneh). Traditionally translated as “behold,” הִנֵּה may emphasize, as it does here, that what follows it is new information. See HALOT, s.v. הִנֵּה, 252.
As observed by T. R. Hobbs, 2 Kings, WBC (Waco: Word Books, 1985), 49. In the previous story, closing the door keeps the miracle private, in the protected space inside the walls of the widow’s house. Rofé, The Prophetical Stories, 17, argues that the miracle of the resurrection of the Shunammite matron’s son takes place behind a closed door for reasons associated with arcane nature of magic.
The narrative does not identify the king, but the text has been situated within the section of 2 Kings dealing with King Joram’s reign.
The sequence of the oil jar miracle followed by the resurrection of the Shunammite’s son parallels two miracles performed by Elijah in Zarephath (1 Kgs 17). The difference is that in Zarephath, the miracle of the flour and oil is performed for the same woman whose son Elijah brings back to life, such that the two events can be seen as two scenes in a single story (see Simon, Reading Prophetic Narratives, 159–167), whereas in the Elisha cycle the miracles benefit two different women in two separate (although closely linked) stories. The narratives also differ in their characterizations of the two prophets. The stories about Elijah emphasize YHWH’s involvement in the miracles that Elijah performs, whereas the emphasis in the Elisha stories is on Elisha’s own power to perform miracles.
The unity of the compilation is also often overlooked. An extreme example of this is Yehuda T. Radday’s argument, in “Chiasm in Kings,” Linguistica Biblica 31 (1974): 52–67, that the cycle has no internal unity, lacks dramatic and literary power, and that the many miracles it recounts, which verge on magic and even fantasy, stand in total contrast to the rational and restrained nature of the stories about Elijah (pp. 62–63).
The later episode in which the Shunammite woman’s property and revenue are restored (2 Kgs 8) serves as a complementary postscript that shows that the woman’s close relationship with Elisha eventually helped her in a domain that she had rejected when he first asked her what he could do to reward her for her generosity—interceding on her behalf with the king (2 Kgs 4:13).