How the Jerusalem Temple Was “Chosen” as the Only Place of Worship

Deuteronomy commands centralizing worship of YHWH at the Temple once peace is obtained. When was this supposed to occur according to the Deuteronomic History, and when did it happen historically?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"How the Jerusalem Temple Was “Chosen” as the Only Place of Worship." TheTorah.com, August 16, 2017. https://www.thetorah.com/article/how-the-jerusalem-temple-was-chosen-as-the-only-place-of-worship.

APA Style

Click to copy

"How the Jerusalem Temple Was “Chosen” as the Only Place of Worship" (2017, August 16). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/how-the-jerusalem-temple-was-chosen-as-the-only-place-of-worship

How the Jerusalem Temple Was “Chosen” as the Only Place of Worship

Dedication of Solomon’s Temple in Jerusalem (adapted), James Tissot, c. 1896-1902, The Jewish Museum

Categories:

Re’eh

Published: August 16, 2017

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. Vv. 8–9 contrast the situation current during the wilderness wanderings, in which anyone can offer sacrifices anywhere, and the situation that is to pertain after entering the land, in which the cult will be centralized. This portrayal of the wilderness period stands in stark contrast with Lev. 17:1–7, according to which the Israelites were commanded during the wilderness wanderings to make sacrifices only at the entrance to the Tabernacle.

  2. Editor’s note: For a redactional critical approach to the difference between these two passages, see Simeon Chavel,“Debates Over Centralizing Sacrificial Worship and Eating Non-Sacrificial Meat,” TheTorah.com (2016). 

  3. This is one of the many signs that this section is part of a Priestly stratum in Joshua, as is the report in Josh. 18:1 of the establishment of the Tent of Meeting in Shiloh. The idea of a central Tent of Meeting or Tabernacle in the wilderness is a Priestly conception; as noted above, Deuteronomy assumes that the Israelites sacrificed “wherever they wished” during the wilderness period (Deut 12:8-9), and knows nothing about a central Tabernacle. Insofar as Shiloh itself, Deuteronomistic texts certainly describe it as a central sanctuary between the time of Joshua and Samuel (see in particular the Samuel birth story in 1 Samuel 1) but hardly the sole legitimate sanctuary. See, for example, Josh. 24:25–26 referring to God’s temple in Shechem (according to the MT) and Judg. 20:26–28 that refers to sacrifices being offered before the Ark of the Covenant that resided in Bethel.

  4. Although the various periods of respite reported in the Book of Judges (e.g. 3:11, 30; 5:31; 8:28) might reflect the work of a Deuteronomistic editor, they do not express the central motif of “rest from enemies roundabout,” which looks forward to a period of permanent peace suitable for putting centralization into practice.

  5. This latter phrase also echoes Deuteronomistic theology as expressed in verses like Deut. 12:5 quoted above (כִּי אִם אֶל הַמָּקוֹם אֲשֶׁר יִבְחַר יְהוָ-ה אֱלֹהֵיכֶם מִכָּל שִׁבְטֵיכֶם לָשׂוּם אֶת שְׁמוֹ שָׁם).

  6. The term can perhaps best be rendered as a cultic installation. They were extremely popular throughout the period of Israelite settlement in the land. For a concise discussion with further references, see Mordechai Cogan, 1 Kings: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary (Anchor Bible vol. 10; New York: Doubleday, 2001), pp. 184–185.

  7. The archaeological evidence for Hezekiah’s cultic reform is not clear-cut, which is why certain scholars remain suspicious of its historical veracity. In what follows, I am partially dependent on Mordechai Cogan, Understanding Hezekiah of Judah: Rebel King and Reformer (Jerusalem: Carta, 2017), pp. 7–11.

  8. For the Assyrian account of these events, see Mordechai Cogan, The Raging Torrent: Historical Inscriptions from Assyria and Babylonia Relating to Ancient Israel, 2nd ed. (Jerusalem: Carta, 2015), pp. 121–133, esp. 125.

  9. Most notably Beersheba and Arad, for which see Cogan, Understanding Hezekiah, p. 10 with references.

  10. The notion of centralization as a religious ideal might have already been percolating in the period leading into Hezekiah’s reign. Thus, the prophet Hosea, whose career may have extended into the beginning of Hezekiah’s tenure, states with reference to the northern kingdom (Hos 8:11):

    כִּי הִרְבָּה אֶפְרַיִם מִזְבְּחֹת לַחֲטֹא
    הָיוּ לוֹ מִזְבְּחוֹת לַחֲטֹא.
    For Ephraim has multiplied altars for guilt;
    His altars have redounded to his guilt.

    In other words, Hezekiah’s emergency measures of restricting cultic activity to Jerusalem may have dovetailed with the prophetic call for a purer form of worship.

  11. Some scholars either antedate centralization to the early monarchic period or postdate it to the post-exilic period. For representative examples of each position, respectively, see J. Gordon McConville, Law and Theology in Deuteronomy (JSOTSup 33; Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1984), pp. 21–29; Ronald E. Clements, “The Deuteronomic Law of Centralisation and the Catastrophe of 587 B.C.E.,” in After the Exile: Essays in Honour of Rex Mason (eds., John Barton and David J. Reimer; Macon, Ga: Mercer University Press, 1996), pp. 5–25. Nevertheless, I find the mainstream position articulated above to be the most convincing.

  12. Indeed, Moses’s successor, Joshua, is described as reading out selections based on Deuteronomy 27–28, i.e. blessings and curses, to the entire people (Josh 8:30–35).

  13. For the likely identification of the “Teaching of Moses” referred to in this verse with an early form of Deuteronomy, see my essay, “Deuteronomy: The First Torah,” TheTorah.com(2015).

  14. Deuteronomic history never states exactly how the book was lost. Josiah’s wicked grandfather, Manasseh, seems like a prime candidate for having consigned the law book to oblivion. Although this is never stated specifically, Radak, in his comments to 2 Kings 22:8, considers this to be the most likely scenario. According to b. Sanhedrin 93b, it was Josiah’s father, Amon, who burnt the Torah. In any event, the ark of the covenant, alongside which the law-book was meant to be stored (according to Deut 31:26), seems to have disappeared during the reign of Manasseh, for which see Menahem Haran, “The Removal of the Ark of the Covenant,” in his collected studies The Bible and its World: Selected Literary and Historical Studies (Jerusalem: Magnes, 2009), pp. 146–154 [Hebrew].

  15. For further discussion of this issue, see my article “Revealed and Concealed: The Status of the (Law) Book of Moses within the Deuteronomistic History,” in Nili S. Fox et al. (eds.), Mishneh Todah: Studies in Deuteronomy and its Cultural Environment in Honor of Jeffrey H. Tigay (Winona Lake, In: Eisenbrauns, 2009), pp. 185–199.