Students cut up the flood story in Genesis 6–9 and sort the passages into the J (YHWH, blue) and P (Elohim, yellow) sources, using divine names, language, and narrative details to identify the two accounts.
Introducing Students to Source Criticism: Cutting up Noah’s Flood Story
I asked my 12th-grade students to divide the flood story (Genesis 6–9) into two narratives by applying four rules: look for different divine names, variations in style and language, distinct themes, and contradictions in the storyline. Is this the best pedagogical approach, or should we first teach students the established scholarship? And how can we teach students to read critically without misrepresenting the complexity of source criticism?
Published: October 14, 2026
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
Marc Brettler, “Monopoly and Biblical Studies,” Ancient Jew Review, August 9, 2023.
Editor’s note: On the source division of the flood story, see Staff Editors, “A Textual Study of Noah’s Flood,” TheTorah (2014).
All names in this piece are pseudonyms and all three student accounts are recreated from my teaching notes alongside artifacts of student work. While quotes from student logs are direct quotes (I have them), student dialogue is recreated from my notes. (I did not audio record classes.)
Mikhail M. Bakhtin, The Dialogic Imagination: Four essays by M. M. Bakhtin, ed. Michael Holquist, trans. Caryl Emerson and Michael Holquist (University of Texas Press, 1981).
David J. A. Clines, “New Directions in Pooh Studies: Überlieferungs- und religionsgeschichtliche Studien zum Pu-Buch,” Theolog Review 12 (1976): 2–10; repr. in On the Way to the Postmodern: Old Testament Essays, 1967–1998, vol. 2, JSOTSup 293 (Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 1998), 830–839.
On concerns about the “death of reading” and a “post-literate society,” see, e.g., Maryanne Wolf, Reader Come Home: The Reading Brain in a Digital World (Harper Perennial, 2026); and Rose Horowitch, “The End of Reading is Here,” The Atlantic, July 8, 2026.