Meat or Murder?

The Torah first describes a world that is created to be vegetarian. It is only after the Flood that humans were allowed to eat meat. Leviticus restricts meat consumption to the sacrificial offerings only, whereas Deuteronomy permits even non-consecrated meat. How do we understand the tension between these approaches?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Meat or Murder?." TheTorah.com, July 28, 2013. https://www.thetorah.com/article/meat-or-murder.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Meat or Murder?" (2013, July 28). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/meat-or-murder

Meat or Murder?

Slaughtering, Jan Stobbaerts c. 1873. Royal Museum of Fine Arts Antwerp. Wikimedia

Published: July 28, 2013

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The sources discussed in this section (Genesis 1 and 9; Leviticus 17) are generally viewed in modern research as pertaining to the Priestly tradition (P), including the Holiness Source (H), identified primarily with Leviticus 17–26.

  2. It is somewhat ironic that after Noah has saved the animals, he is then given permission to eat them. The medieval commentator R. Joseph Bakhor Shor actually justifies the permission to eat meat on these grounds: Since Noah saved the animals, they are henceforth at his disposal!

  3. See, e.g., Num 35; Deut 19.

  4. See especially R’ Abraham Isaac ha-Kohen Kook, Talelei Oroth, ch. 8.

  5. This type is also often translated “peace” offering.

  6. For the sake of accuracy, it should be noted that Leviticus 17 does not require that all ritually clean animals be sacrificed in order to be consumed. Verses 13 and 14 explicitly permit the hunting and private consumption of non-domestic clean animals (e.g. deer, gazelles; cf. Deut 14: 4–5) and birds as long as one is careful not to eat their blood together with the flesh.

  7. There is a wide variance of opinion regarding the nature of this punishment, including whether it is carried out by humans or God. Assuming the latter (following the traditional Jewish view), it remains to be decided whether this punishment involves premature death, childlessness, death of progeny or the cutting off of the soul in the afterlife (or some combination of these).

  8. The narrative in 1 Samuel 14:32 – 35 seems to address this very issue, whereby Saul creates an ad hoc altar to enable meat consumption.

  9. Many scholars detect a tension within Deuteronomy 12 between these verses and v. 15 which seems to give a blanket permission for non-sacral slaughter. For the purposes of our discussion, we will focus on this chapter in its canonical form as it was received by its Second Temple Period interpreters.

  10. The Samaritan Pentateuch is often longer/expansionistic.

  11. Other texts from Qumran would seem to share R. Ishmael’s understanding, specifically the Temple Scroll 52:13–21 and Miqṣat Ma‛aśe ha-Torah (4QMMT) B 27 –28, 35. However, unlike the rabbinic view, these scrolls seek to determine the distance from Jerusalem at which secular meat can be consumed, following a strict reading of Deut 12:20. In contrast, the rabbis understood Deut 12:20 as nullifying the requirements of Leviticus 17 almost completely once the land’s territory has expanded, permitting secular meat even in Jerusalem (see Ramban on Deut 12:20).

  12. The Akkadian and Ugaritic cognates to Hebrew חל”ל refer to being free of obligations (legal claims, guilt) as well as to being ritually pure.

Related Topics:BloodSacrificesMurder