On the Origins of Tevilah (Ritual Immersion)

When and why washing became immersion: between traditional-rabbinic and scientific-critical approaches to the origin of immersion and the mikveh.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"On the Origins of Tevilah (Ritual Immersion)." TheTorah.com, April 19, 2017. https://www.thetorah.com/article/on-the-origins-of-tevilah-ritual-immersion.

APA Style

Click to copy

"On the Origins of Tevilah (Ritual Immersion)" (2017, April 19). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/on-the-origins-of-tevilah-ritual-immersion

On the Origins of Tevilah (Ritual Immersion)

A mikveh at Qumran, the Judean Desert. Photo: Yonatan Adler

Categories:

Metzora

Published: April 19, 2017

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. [1] Many thanks to my dear friend Dr. Levi Cooper for reading a draft of this essay and offering helpful comments, many of which have been incorporated into the final version.

  2. [2] Cf. Sifre Zuta, Ḥuqat 19:19 (ed. Horovitz, p. 314).

  3. But not the Covenant Collection, which is likely the earliest of the legal collections. See: Lev. 14:8–9; 15:5–8, 10–11, 13, 16, 18, 21–22, 27; 16:26, 28; 17:15–16; 22:4–6; Num. 19:7–8, 19; Deut. 23:12; cf. 2 Sam. 11:2–4). In one instance (with regard to the purification of the zab—a male who experienced an abnormal genital discharge) we find an injunction to wash with “living water” (במים חיים; Lev. 15:13). When impurity is to be removed from clothing, the verb used is: כבס, i.e. to launder (Lev. 11:25, 28, 40; 13:6, 34; 14:8–9, 47; 15:5–8, 10–11, 13, 17, 21–22, 27; 16:26, 28; 17:15; Num. 8:7; 19:7–8, 10, 19, 21; 31:24). Purification of impure vessels through washing in water is accomplished by having the vessel “brought into” water (במים יובא; Lev. 11:32), “rinsed” in water (ישטף במים; Lev. 15:12), or “passed through” water (תעבירו במים; Num. 31:23).

  4. To clarify, Exod. 30:19 describes the priests washing “from” the basin: ורחצו אהרן ובניו ממנו את ידיהם ואת רגליהם. This precludes immersion since one cannot immerse “from” a container—one immerses “in” a container. The same is true for Exod. 40:31: ורחצו ממנו משה ואהרן ובניו את ידיהם ואת רגליהם. As for the eglah arufah ritual (Deut 21:6), here too the term rachatz means something other than immersion since the the elders wash their hands “over” the calf (ירחצו את ידיהם על העגלה הערופה).

  5. See also, Lev. 14:6; Num. 19:18; 1 Sam 14:27.

  6. See also, Lev. 4:17; 9:9; 14:16; Deut. 33:24; Josh. 3:15

  7. In the narrative of the healing of Na’aman, Elisha instructs the Aramean army commander to “wash” (ורחצת) in the Jordan (2 Kings 5:10) after which we are told that Na’aman “immersed” (ויטבל) in the river (2 Kings 5:14). While in this particular instance washing in a river is conflated with immersing, I see little reason to view this source as a prooftext for concluding that immersion is necessarily intended throughout whenever the term “rachatz” is used. 

  8. Although it seems likely that the author here had in mind the Pentateuchal call for “washing” at the end of the seven-day process of purification from corpse-impurity (Num. 19:19), this is not completely certain. The original Hebrew version of this work is thought to date to the first quarter of the second century BCE, while its translation into Greek dates to the second half of the same century. As this section of the work has not survived in any Hebrew manuscripts, it is difficult to know if the Hebrew verb for immersion (טבל) may have appeared here in the Greek’s vorlage.

  9. Although it appears that the purpose of this immersion was purificatory in nature (cf. Jdt. 12:9), it remains questionable whether or not Judith’s actions here should be viewed as in any way representative of normal purity practices within Jewish society contemporaneous to the author of this work. Most scholars suggest that Judith was authored sometime during the Hasmonean period, but this remains somewhat uncertain.

  10. The text is written in an early Herodian script with a first century BCE estimated paleographic date.

  11. In Greek: καθεὶς αὑτὸν εἰς ὕδωρ ψυχρὸν. Elsewhere (AJ 18:117) Josephus refers to the teachings of John the Baptist, who exhorted his listeners in their practice of immersion (βάπτισις, βαπτισμός). It is unclear, however, how John’s practices relate to the Pentateuchal ablutions for purification of ritual impurity. The same problem, of course, relates to the various Gospel accounts relating the practices of John the Baptist.

  12. Standard editions which translate here βαπτίζω as “wash,” “bathe,” “cleanse” or even “baptize”(!) misconstrue the true meaning of the Greek verb; see: Eckhard J. Schnabel, “The Meaning of βαπτίζειν in Greek, Jewish, and Patristic Literature,” Filologia Neotestamentaria, 44/24 (2011), pp. 3–40; idem, “The Language of Baptism: The Meaning of βαπτίζω in the New Testament,” in Andreas J. Köstenberger and Robert W. Yarbrough (eds), Understanding the Times: New Testament Studies in the Twenty-First Century: Essays in Honor of D.A. Carson on the Occasion of His 65th Birthday (Wheaton, Il: Crossway, 2011), pp. 217–46. A small minority of textual witnesses read here ῥαντίσωνται instead of βαπτίσωνται, but this is most likely a late corruption; see: Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark: A Commentary (Hermeneia; Minneapolis, MN: Fortress, 2007), pp. 339, 348–349 n. 7. I thank Dr. Morten Hørning Jensen for discussing this issue with me.

  13. For the most comprehensive corpus of such installations to date, see: Yonatan Adler, The Archaeology of Purity: Archaeological Evidence for the Observance of Ritual Purity in Ereẓ-Israel from the Hasmonean Period until the End of the Talmudic Era (164 BCE–400 CE)(Ph.D. diss.; Bar-Ilan University, 2011), pp. 321–43 [Hebrew]. For a largely parallel but smaller corpus, see: Ronny Reich, Miqwa’ot (Jewish Ritual Baths) in the Second Temple, Mishnaic and Talmudic Periods (in Hebrew; Jerusalem: Yad Yizhak Ben-Zvi and Israel Exploration Society, 2013).

  14. Reich, Miqwa’ot, pg. 209.

  15. Catherine Bell, Ritual Theory, Ritual Practice (New York: Oxford University Press, 1992), p. 90.

  16. Among a list of those said to defile terumah heave-offerings are: “one whose head and the majority of his body has gone into drawn water” and “a pure person upon whose head and the majority of his body has fallen three lôg measures of drawn water” (m. Zabim 5:12. Cf. m.Miqw. 3:4). Elsewhere, this regulation is attributed to “the words of the Scribes” (m. Ṭehar.4:11) and is said to be a “light impurity” (m. Miqw. 2:2).

  17. See, however, the following note.

  18. In light of the attribution of disputes about “drawn water” to the late first century Shema‘yah and Avtalion and their successors (m. ʿEduyyot. 1:3), it may well be that notions regarding the invalidating nature of “drawn water” first appeared close to the time of Herod the Great.

    It is perhaps not altogether surprising to find that some third–fourth century rabbis suggested a somewhat similar “historical” reconstruction for the Mishnaic imposition of impurity upon one who bathes or rinses in “drawn water” (b. Shabbat 14a):

    והבא ראשו ורובו במים שאובין, מאי טעמא גזרו ביה רבנן טומאה?
    “And one who’s head and the majority of his body has gone into drawn water.” Why did the rabbis decree against this?
    אמר רב ביבי אמר רב אסי: שבתחלה היו טובלין במי מערות מכונסין וסרוחין, והיו נותנין עליהן מים שאובין, התחילו ועשאום קבע – גזרו עליהם טומאה.
    Rabbi Bibi said in the name of Rabbi Assi: “Because in the beginning they used to immerse in gathered, putrid cavern-water and then rinse themselves with drawn-water. Once they began to make this a fixed practice—they decreed impurity upon the [drawn-water].”
    מאי קבע? – אמר אביי: שהיו אומרים: לא אלו מטהרין – אלא אלו ואלו מטהרין.
    What is meant by ‘a fixed practice’? Abaye said: “For they used to say: ‘[Immersion in] this does not purify, but rather both [immersion and subsequent rinsing with drawn-water are necessary to] purify!’”
    אמר ליה רבא: מאי נפקא מינה? הא קא טבלי בהנך!
    Rava said to him: ‘What difference does it make? They are anyway immersing in this [valid water]!’
    אלא אמר רבא: שהיו אומרים לא אלו מטהרין – אלא אלו מטהרין.
    But rather said Rava: ‘For they used to say: “[Immersion in] this does not purify, but rather this [subsequent rinsing with drawn-water] purifies!’”