Rebecca Ran to Her Mother’s Household - Where Was Her Father?

Betuel, Rebecca’s father, mysteriously appears and disappears in the negotiations over Rebecca’s marriage.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Rebecca Ran to Her Mother’s Household - Where Was Her Father?." TheTorah.com, November 9, 2017. https://www.thetorah.com/article/rebecca-ran-to-her-mothers-household-where-was-her-father.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Rebecca Ran to Her Mother’s Household - Where Was Her Father?" (2017, November 9). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/rebecca-ran-to-her-mothers-household-where-was-her-father

Rebecca Ran to Her Mother’s Household - Where Was Her Father?

Abraham’s Servant with Rebecca, (detail) Jacob Hogers ca. 1616. Wikimedia

Categories:

Chayei Sarah

Published: November 9, 2017

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The core idea of this piece appeared as an addendum to, “Was Betuel Lavan’s Father? An Analysis of Lavan and Rebecca’s Genealogy,” TheTorah (2014). The piece has been greatly expanded and the section laying out Stanley Gevirtz’s suggestion is entirely new. We thank David Steinberg for his many helpful suggestions in developing this piece.

  2. The verse takes a strange step backwards since in the previous verse Laban already went to the spring. We can see the further evidence of redaction from the Wiederaufnahme (resumptive repetition) at the end of the verse, where again, Laban goes out to meet the man at the spring. Perhaps this was added in later as a way of making Laban look greedy, implying that it was not out of hospitality or care for his sister that he invited the man, but because he was clearly from a rich household.

  3. The LXX has “brothers” here, probably to make it fit with the blessing in vv. 59-60 “our sister.” The plural in these verses is admittedly strange. Perhaps it implies the appearance of younger brothers that are unnamed in the story. Alternatively, “sister” could be a term of affection coming from the entire household, including her mother, and possibly other siblings, extended family, and even servants.

  4. R. Aryeh Klapper calls this “murder by midrash.” See, Aryeh Klapper, “Murder by Midrash: The Case of the Disappearing Father,” Modern Torah Leadership (2014).

  5. This refers to the right of a lord in certain cultures to sleep with a woman before her husband on the night of her wedding.

  6. Ephraim A. Speiser, Genesis: Introduction, Translation and Notes (Anchor Bible 1, Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1964), pp. 181-2.

  7. For a full discussion, see Zev Farber, “Who Was Rebecca’s Father?” TheTorah.com (2017).

  8. See both HALOT and BDB on the name.

  9. See Robert Wilson, Genealogy and History in the Biblical World (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1977).

  10. Comparing these two genealogies is a great exercise—photocopy the two genealogies and place them side by side, and put them into charts, and use colored pencils and lines to see how the name do or do not match up. You may just become convinced of the utility of source-criticism!

  11. Tzemah Yoreh suggests that the entire genealogy in v. 15 was added later, noting that the genealogy comes awkwardly after the verb. See, Tzemah Yoreh, Genesis: Israel’s Origins (Kernel to Canon; Modern Scriptures, 2014), 204-211. In fact, this awkward syntax is glossed over in many English translations (e.g., NJPS, NRSV) by putting the genealogy immediately after her name is mentioned and, as noted by Uzi Weingarten (personal communication) removing the phrase would make this description better parallel that of Abraham’s servant in v. 45. Nevertheless, the argument here is not definitive, since delaying the verb until after the genealogy would also have been awkward and the comment is a parenthetical note from the narrator to the reader and not something the servant would have repeated.

  12. This is the most problematic of the three, since it requires positing that the redactor deleted the word “and” (ו) and replaced it with the word “son of” (בן).

  13. בעבור שהיה לנחור בנים מפלגשו ראומה ייחסו לעולם בתואל בן מלכה
    Since Nahor had sons from his concubine, Reumah, Betuel is always referred to as “the son of Milkah.”
  14. Both Gen 11:27-32 and Gen 22:20-24 are likely products of the redactor, included to create genealogical back-stories for the characters and to combine the key elements of J and P, and are not part of any original source.