Isaac Blessing Jacob, Nicolas-Guy Brenet 1768
Rebecca, the Hidden Prophetess
Rebecca endures a difficult pregnancy and inquires of YHWH, who reveals that the younger will surpass the older. Yet commentators hesitate to call her a prophet, perhaps because she withholds this revelation from Isaac and later deceives him when he moves to bless Esau. But far from mere guile, her actions mark her as a Kierkegaardian Knight of Faith—acting decisively in service of the divine, much like Abraham at the binding of Isaac.
Published: November 20, 2025
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
I thank the editors for helping expand and fill out some of the points.
Nehemiah (6:14) mentions a Noadiah the prophetess, but he depicts her as an enemy, so he is likely not intending to support her claims to true prophecy. Isaiah 8:3 also mentions an unnamed נביאה, though in context, this is generally understood to mean “wife of a prophet” as opposed to prophetess.
Sarah is the only one of the four Matriarchs who appears on this list, though other rabbinic texts including the other matriarchs among the prophetesses (see below).
This association is based on a rabbinic attempt to understand the convoluted genealogy offered in Genesis 11:29. Through the midrashic technique described as Joseph Heinemann as “Flight from Anonymity” the otherwise unknown Jessica is associated with (and subsumed by), the better known, Sarah.
In his supercommentary on Rashi’s commentary known as Gur Aryeh (Gen. 29:34), R. Judah Loew ben Betzalel of Prague (Maharal) notices that Sarah is the only one of the four Matriarchs who are on the Talmudic list, and adds that Leah and Rachel were also prophetesses but that their prophecies were never written down, thereby warranting their exclusion from the list. This interesting analysis reinforces the Talmudic view of these prophetesses as less significant than Sarah.
For another discussion of Rebecca in post-biblical descriptions, see Malka Z. Simkovich, “Rebecca’s Character,” TheTorah (2017).
According to this midrash, Sarah’s prophecy is this rebuke, not her message to Abraham to kick Hagar and Ishmael out of the house, as per the Babylonian Talmud. The “leaps”—other than the speaker making a play on his own name—refers to the number of steps before God actually speaks to Sarah. Originally, the message was to Abraham, and then Abraham speaks to Sarah, then she denies what happened, and only then does God speak.
The term here is שליח “messenger” as opposed to prophet. Kara’s commentary here is lost. The reference appears in Rashi’s commentary MS Munich 5 as from Kara, but in several other MSS it is just included in Rashi without attribution (see discussion ad loc. in AlHaTorah.com), and this is what many of the commentaries on Rashi are responding to. The term is also used by Hizkuni, likely taken from his text of Rashi.
For both Ibn Ezra and Hizkuni, this is their second/alternative interpretation.
And yet, this could simply mean she needed to take a walk to encounter God, as Balaam does, as he explains to Balak:
במדבר כג:ג וַיֹּאמֶר בִּלְעָם לְבָלָק הִתְיַצֵּב עַל עֹלָתֶךָ וְאֵלְכָה אוּלַי יִקָּרֵה יְ־הוָה לִקְרָאתִי וּדְבַר מַה יַּרְאֵנִי וְהִגַּדְתִּי לָךְ וַיֵּלֶךְ שֶׁפִי.
Num 23:3 Then Balaam said to Balak, “Stay here beside your offerings and I will walk. Perhaps YHWH will grant me a manifestation, and whatever He reveals to me I will tell you.” And he went off alone.
This is a very common verb, however, so not a definitive demonstration that walking is part of the process.
There are many other examples, and this extends to inquiring of foreign gods as well.
R. Loew had a version of Rashi with both the “messenger” answer and that of Shem, so he goes on to explain why Rashi thinks it was specifically Shem and not Eber, like the other view in the midrash:
גור אריה בראשית כה:כג ובודאי אל שם הלכה ולא אל מדרשו של עבר, דאם שם לא ידע, שהוא הגדול, עבר מנא ליה:
Gur Aryeh Gen 25:23 Certainly she must have gone to Shem and not the study house of Eber, since if Shem didn’t know, and he was the senior one, how would Eber know?
In his revisions, Nahmanides added a further point:
רמב"ן בראשית כז:ד והנה מתחלה לא הגידה לו דרך מוסר וצניעות כי: ותלך לדרוש את י"י (בראשית כ"ה:כ"ב) – שהלכה בלא רשות יצחק, או שאמרה: אין אנכי צריכה להגיד נבואה לנביא כי הוא גדול מן המגיד לי, ועתה לא רצתה לאמר לו כך הוגד לי מאת השם טרם לדתי.
Ramban Gen 27:4 In the beginning, she didn’t tell him out of consideration and modesty for “she went to inquire of the LORD” (Gen 25:22)—she went without his permission, or she said to herself “I don’t need to tell the prophecy to a prophet, for he is greater than the one who told me.” And now [realizing he didn’t know], she didn’t want to tell him that “this is what was told to me from God before I gave birth.”
A third, weaker example is her using foreign wives as pretext. When she hears that Esau wants to kill Jacob, she doesn’t talk to him or to Isaac about the issue, but complains about Esau’s wives, leading Isaac to send Jacob back to Aram to marry one of his cousins.
This is the opinion of Rabbi Pinchas in Midrash Bereshit Rabbah 93:4. Note however that the same midrash also cites opinions that Rebecca was positively differentiated from her family in that she was the only one who was not a cheater.
Carol Meyers “Rebekah: Bible,” Shalvi/Hyman Encyclopedia of Jewish Women (2021) writes:
Rebekah’s behavior—in securing the birthright for her favored son Jacob and in protecting him from Esau’s wrath by having him sent away—is sometimes seen as problematic. A few male commentators, ignoring frequent instances of deceit by male heroes and the positive role of tricksters in ancient folklore, aver that deceitful women like Rebekah subvert biblical values….As a resourceful trickster, Rebekah serves God and preserves the ancestral lineage.
For more on this theme in general, see Dean Andrew Nicholas, The Trickster Revisited: Deception as a Motif in the Pentateuch, Studies in Biblical Literature 117 (Peter Lang, 2009).
According to Kierkegaard, a woman can also be a Knight of Faith. In fact, the only other Knight of Faith he explicitly identifies is Mary, mother of Jesus.
This is emphasized by Moses Maimonides:
Guide 3:24 Here we have a childless man who had deeply longed for a son. Blessed with great wealth and honor, he cherishes hopes that a nation will issue from his seed. At last, when he has given up hope, the son he yearned for arrives. How he would love and cherish him! Yet beside his fear of God and devotion to His command, his beloved son seems a trifle. He throws away all his hopes for him and sets off to slaughter him, after several days’ journey.
Had he wished to do so as soon as he received the command, it might have meant that he was dumbstruck or troubled of mind. But undertaken days after the command came, the act was well considered and deliberate, based on recognition of God’s authority, and in love and fear of Him. No one could claim otherwise or lay it to the influence of some passion.
From Moses Maimonides, The Guide to the Perplexed: A New Translation, trans. and com., Lenn E. Goodman and Phillip I. Lieberman (Stanford University Press, 2024), 410.
Notably, the Moroccan rabbi and kabbalist, R. Chayim ben-Attar (1696–1743), in his Or HaChayim commentary on the Torah, understands Rebecca as trying to communicate this point to Jacob, when he tells her to listen to her voice, which, ben-Attar understands as her explaining that this was part of her prophecy:
אור החיים בראשית כז:ח שמע בקולי – פי' הגם שיש בדברים אלו כגניבת הדעת, עם כל זה יש לך לשמוע בקולי פי' מלבד חיוב מצות כיבוד אב ואם שהיא מצות עשה גם היא נביאה וכתיב בדברי נביא אמת (דברים יח:יד) אליו תשמעון לזה אמרה שמע בקולי.
Or HaChayim Gen 27:8 “Listen to my voice”—meaning, even though these instructions contain deceit, even so, you should listen to my voice. Meaning, in addition to the requirement to honor father and mother, which is a positive commandment, she is also a prophetess, and it says regarding the words of a true prophet (Deut 18:14) “you shall listen to him.” Therefore, she said, “listen to my voice.”
Notably, ibn Attar does see Rebecca as a prophetess.
See Erich Auerbach, “Odysseus’ Scar,” in Mimesis: The Representation of Reality in Western Literature (Doubleday, 1953), 3–23; Robert Alter, The Art of Biblical Narrative (New York: Basic Books, 1981); Barry W. Holtz, “Midrash,” in Back To The Sources: Reading the Classic Jewish Texts, ed. Barry W. Holtz (Simon and Schuster, 2006; repr. of Summit Books, 1984), 177–212 [p. 180].