Cyrus the Great allowing the Jews to return to and rebuild Jerusalem. Artist Jean Fouquet (1420–1480) or Maître du Boccace de Munich
Survival and Revival: Megillat Esther and Ezra-Nehemiah
Jews in the Persian Period dealt with the reality of the destruction of Judah in two different ways. The Book of Esther emphasized the diaspora while Ezra-Nehemiah emphasized the rebuilding. For most of Jewish history the Ezra-Nehemiah model was all but non-existent, but this changed with the emergence of Zionism and the establishment of the State of Israel.
Published: July 7, 2015
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
In Jewish tradition, Ezra-Nehemiah form a single book.
This observation led Elias Bickerman to posit that Megillat Esther is actually a combination of two separate accounts. See Albert I. Baumgarten, “Scroll of Esther,” Encyclopedia Judaica 14, p. 1053, based on Elias J. Bickermann, Four Strange Books of the Bible, 1967, pp. 171-240.
These details bring up the historical difficulties presented by the story.
This absence is amply supplemented by the additions of the Greek and Aramaic Versions, and by the vast midrashic literature.
Compare Neh 1:4-11.
For elaboration on the following matters and the relevant scholarly literature, see Sara Japhet, A Commentary on Ezra-Nehemiah, 2015 (Hebrew).
Contrast Haggai’s prophecy to Zerubbabel, and some hints in Zechariah.
This is not always precisely represented by the English translations.