The Discrepancies Between the Sacrifices in Ezekiel and the Torah

The laws of holiday sacrifices in Ezekiel 45–46 contradict the laws in Numbers 28–29. The problems are so significant that some Talmudic sages thought it would be best to withdraw (לגנוז) the book of Ezekiel. This piece lays out the discrepancies in detail, surveys some traditional and modern answers, and ends with my own thoughts about why Ezekiel’s system is so different.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The Discrepancies Between the Sacrifices in Ezekiel and the Torah." TheTorah.com, April 6, 2016. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-discrepancies-between-the-sacrifices-in-ezekiel-and-the-torah.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The Discrepancies Between the Sacrifices in Ezekiel and the Torah" (2016, April 6). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-discrepancies-between-the-sacrifices-in-ezekiel-and-the-torah

The Discrepancies Between the Sacrifices in Ezekiel and the Torah

Sheep in Peza’el Valley, Israel. Photo by Dr. Avishai Teicher. Wikimedia

Categories:

Pinchas

Published: April 6, 2016

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Editor’s Note: This piece was translated from the Hebrew by Eve Levavi Feinstein and adapted for TABS by the editors with the author’s permission.

  2.  This anecdote also appears in b. Shabbat 13b and b. Hagiga 13a, with minor differences.

  3. Editor’s note: For a discussion of the absence of Shavuot from Ezekiel, see Evan Hoffman’s TABS essay, “Ezekiel’s Failure to Mention Shavuot.” For the absence of Yom Kippur in Ezekiel, see the TABS essay, “Does Ezekiel in 572 B.C.E Know of Yom Kippur?”

  4.  Thus, for example, Menahem Haran suggests that Shavuot is not mentioned here because it is the least important festival or because it is the festival of the wheat harvest, which is an extension of the festival of Matzot. See Menahem Haran, The Biblical Collection: Its Consolidation to the End of the Second Temple Times and Changes of Form to the End of the Middle Ages [Hebrew], volume 3 (Jerusalem: The Bialik Institute, 2008), 373–74.

  5.  There are additional differences with respect to the meal offerings for freewill offerings (Ezekiel 46:11; Numbers 15:4–10), as well as the timing of the daily burnt offering. In Numbers (28:3–4), the daily burnt offering, or Tamid, is offered twice a day, in the morning and at twilight. In Ezekiel, in contrast, it is offered only in the morning. Ezekiel repeats three times that this sacrifice is offered in the morning (46:13, 14, 15), possibly to emphasize the difference between his rule and the tradition reflected in Numbers. (It is possible that Ezekiel assumes an evening meal offering along with the morning burnt offering, as suggested by 2 Kings 16:15; an evening meal offering is also mentioned in Psalm 141:2; Daniel 9:21; and Ezra 9:4–5.)

  6.  See also Rashi on Ezekiel 46:6, where he comments on the number of bulls offered on Rosh Chodesh.

  7. Haran by no means thinks the two texts are equal in value or precedence, however, as he continues with the following:

    המגילות הכוהניות שבספרי התורה מצטרפות לכלל מסכת ספרותית -אידיאולוגית, שיש בה הרבה יותר שלמות, הרבה יותר אותנטיות וסימנים של ראשונות, עד כי לעומתה נראה הקובץ של יחזקאל כשלוחה מדולדלת בלבד. משמע שקובץ זה אינו אלא התגלמות מאוחרת וירודה של אותה אסכולה, שהגיבוש המופתי שלה ניתן בתורה.
    The Priestly texts in the books of the Torah join together to form one literary ideological complex, which is much more complete and much more authentic, with markers that show it to be the more original text, such that in comparison, the collection found in Ezekiel appears to be merely a dwindling branch. What this means is that the collection [in Ezekiel] is a late and inferior expression of that school, whose ultimate expression appears in the Torah.
  8. Rimon Kasher, Ezekiel: Introduction and Commentary, vol. 2, chs. 25–48 (Mikra LeYisrael; Tel Aviv: Am Oved, 2005).

  9. Daniel I. Block, The Book of Ezekiel: Chapters 25–48 (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1998).

  10. Walther Zimmerli, Ezekiel II: A Commentary on the Book of the Prophet Ezekiel chs. 25–48 (Hermeneia: A Critical Historical Commentary on the Bible; Augsburg Fortress Press, 1983), 485–486.

  11. Moshe Greenberg, “The Design and Themes of Ezekiel’s Program of Restoration,”Interpretation 38 (1984): 181–208.

  12. Sukkot requires a different approach, since in this case he decreased the number of sacrifices. The same problem exists with the removal of some holidays from his list.

  13. This change is explained in Ezekiel 44:15, which states that while the other kohanim allowed sinful activity to occur in the Temple, the Zadokites remained true to God. Editor’s Note: For more on this story, see Ely Levine’s TABS essay, “The Historical Circumstances that Inspired the Korah Narrative.”

  14. Granted that this does not explain why in certain cases (like Sukkot), Ezekiel actually reduces the number of sacrifices, though this could be for the reasons Zimmerli suggested above (to make Sukkot and Pesach more parallel with each other), or some other reason. In the end, Ezekiel is probably driven by multiple considerations, but expanding holiness seems to be one of them.