Aaron as High Priest, Jan Luyken, 1698. Rijksmuseum.nl
The Double Rebellion and the Defense of God's Chosen
Published: June 2, 2013
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
This is not the first time a complaint has been heard, nor is it the last (see, for example, Exodus 16:3; Numbers 14:1-4; 21:5). In fact, the entire section of Numbers from chapter 10 through 21 is filled with complaints about the difficulties encountered in the wilderness. The theme of complaint is a significant theme of the JE source of Exodus and Numbers.
The exact division of the narratives is a matter of dispute. For some suggestions, see: Joel Baden, “A Narrative Pattern and its Role in Source Criticism,” Hebrew Scriptures 49 (2008), 41-54 [52-54]; Israel Knohl, The Sanctuary of Silence: The Priestly Torah and the Holiness Code (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 2007), 73-85. See also Tzemah Yoreh’s division on his website: www.biblecriticism.com/numbers_16_j_p_h.doc. In this essay, I will restrict myself to a rough description of the theme of each rebellion without attempting a phrase by phrase source critical division.
The verse suggestions are just to give the readers a general sense and are not meant as a definitive claim about the exact contours of the two stories. The relationship between the first two verses of the chapter and either version is difficult to determine.
This is not unusual; elsewhere in the Torah, where two similar stories existed, they are interwoven. See, for example, the Noah story in Genesis and the plague narrative in Exodus.