Abraham expels Hagar and Ishmael. Jacob Folkema 1712. Rijksmuseum.nl
The Expulsion of Ishmael: Who Is Being Tried?
The literary similarities between the expulsion of Ishmael account and that of the Akedah implies that a trial is taking place.
Published: November 13, 2016
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Sarah never names her in this episode, though Hagar was first introduced as her Egyptian maidservant (שפחה) (Gen. 16:1). In the former chapter, she may have been elevated to the status of wife upon bearing Abraham a son (16:3). In Genesis 21, Sarah calls her “thatslavewoman [אמה]”, which lowers her status further, reducing her to a mere object in Sarah’s eyes. Yet the narrator does identify her by name upon her banishment in v. 14, and the angel of God calls to her by name in v. 17, as if to restore her humanity. These two chapters in which Hagar finds salvation by a well is called a “literary doublet” or “type scene”. According to the Documentary Hypothesis, chapter 16 is attributed to the J-source and chapter 21 to E.
This reverses the consequences of his first hearing her voice (16:2), when she urged Abraham to take her maidservant to bear him a child.
Accord to P (the Priestly source), Abraham was 86 upon the birth of Ishmael (16:16), 99 at the covenant of circumcision when Ishmael was 13 (17:1, 24-25), and 100 at Isaac’s birth (17:17 and 21:5). If we assume that this scene follows the weening ceremony (with Issac at the age of 2 or 3), Ishmael would be 16 or 17. Jon Levenson, however, points out correctly that we may not assume that this age difference stands behind our story, which is from the E source, where Ishmael is much younger – Hagar may even carry him (21:14), cast him away (v. 15), and lift him up (v. 18). See Jon Levenson, The Death and Resurrection of the Beloved Son (New Haven: Yale University Press 1993), 105.
Genesis Rabbah 53:11, T. Sota 6:6, and Sifre Deut. 31. Pirkei deRabbi Eliezer (PRE 30) however, ignores this exegetic tradition, and reports that Ishmael was merely playing a deadly game of “William Tell” (with bows and arrows). PRE, which was composed in a post-Islamic milieu (mid-8th c.), did not find it appropriate to saddle the ancestor of Muhammed and the ancient founder of the Muslim faith with idolatry.
Robert Alter, Genesis (New York: Norton 1996), p. 98.
See Deut. 21:15-17. This principle that the first-born receives the double portion (that is double the share of his brothers’ inheritance), finds parallels in Assyrian, Hittite, and Nuzi legal records in the Ancient Near East. See the discussion in Sarna, Understanding Genesis, (New York: Schocken Books, 1966), 184–87, and 190, n.22. For a discussion of the principle in Jewish sources, see Levenson, Death and Resurrection of the Beloved Son, 55-60, and Frederick E. Greenspahn, When Brothers Dwell Together: The Preeminence of Younger Siblings in the Hebrew Bible (New York, Oxford: Oxford University Press 1994).
Ishmael is referred to as “the son [ben]”, “the boy [yeled],” or “the youth [na‘ar].” The epithet “son [ben]” (x 5) is an effect of focalization: Ishmael is “her son [בְּנָהּ ]”, through Sarah’s eyes in v. 9 and 10 (x2), and v. 12; his son [בְּנוֹ] in Abraham’s eyes (v. 11). He is also called “the boy [הַיֶּלֶד]” (x 3, vv. 14, 15, and 16), a neutral or distancing term deployed by the narrator and by Hagar, after she casts him away. And is he referred to as “the youth [הַנַּעַר]”, which is God’s or the angel’s term for him, as in vv. 12, 17 (x2), 18, 19 and 20.
The term “casts” suggests almost certain death, as in Pharaoh’s edict to cast the baby boys in the Nile (Exod. 1:22).
This is the third iteration of the promise. The first was when Hagar fled from her mistress’ cruel hand. Pregnant, she received a promise, resonant with the patriarchal covenant: “I will so greatly multiply your offspring that they cannot be counted for multitude.” (Gen. 16:10; cf. 13:16, 15:5, 22:17). But following Ishmael’s initiation into the covenant of circumcision, a caveat is introduced that he would be excluded from the divine covenant (Gen. 17:21). Nevertheless God promises: “I will bless him and make him fruitful and exceedingly numerous; he shall be the father of twelve princes, and I will make him a great nation” (Gen. 17:20). This chapter, on the covenant of circumcision, is attributed to the P-source. Both the chapters on the Binding of Isaac (Gen. 22:1-19) and the Banishment of Ishmael (Gen. 21:9-21) are attributed to E.
This is suggested by the verb, va-t’a-t’a, and she strayed. See Aaron Pinker, “The Expulsion of Hagar and Ishmael” (Gen 21:9-21),” Women and Judaism 6:1 (2009), 1-24.Pirkei deRabbi Eliezer (30) suggests that Abraham gave her veil רדיד – which was meant to leave a trail in the sand, by which Abraham might have followed her.
See note 3 above.
In the final form of the Torah, this can be read as the first fulfillment of the prophecy, to which she alone was privy, that he would live, “his hand against everyone, And everyone’s hand against him [יָדוֹ בַכֹּל וְיַד כֹּל בּוֹ]” (Gen. 16:12).
Based on the final redacted text, which assumes that Hagar was privy to this promise prior to the banishment in chapter 21.
Abraham tells him to divorce his first wife, who was so inhospitable towards strangers, and then to bless his second choice of wife, since she freely offered him food and water. In this latter source, the Islamic tradition exerts a strong influence, See the discussion of PRE30, and the impact of the Islamic context of its composition in Rachel Adelman, The Return of the Repressed: Pirqe de-Rabbi Eliezer and the Pseudepigrapha (Leiden: Brill 2008), 35-42. These lines linking our parallel destinies, Muslim and Jew, through history and sacred text should serve as a basis for dialogue, a means of bridging the divide between the sons of Sarah and Hagar, the children of Isaac and the children of Ishmael.
The identification of Hagar with Keturah is found in Gen. Rab. 47:2 and 61:7, and PRE30. In Gen. 25:1, when Abraham takes Keturah as a wife, it is considered a “re-marriage.” According to Rashi (based on Gen. Rab. 60:14), Isaac effects this reconciliation between Abraham and Hagar after the death of his mother, when he returns from Beer lahai-Roi (Gen. 24:62, cf. 25:11). Critical biblical scholarship considers Hagar and Keturah to be different individuals. For more on Keturah, see the TABS essay, “Our Stepmother Keturah.”