The Menstruant Is Dangerous: Nahmanides’ Science and Mysticism

Why did Laban accept that Rachel could not rise before him when she said, “For the way of women was upon me”? Why does the Torah forbid sexual relations during menstruation? Nahmanides’ answers place him at the crossroads of medieval science and mysticism.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The Menstruant Is Dangerous: Nahmanides’ Science and Mysticism." TheTorah.com, May 30, 2025. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-menstruant-is-dangerous-nahmanides-science-and-mysticism.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The Menstruant Is Dangerous: Nahmanides’ Science and Mysticism" (2025, May 30). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-menstruant-is-dangerous-nahmanides-science-and-mysticism

The Menstruant Is Dangerous: Nahmanides’ Science and Mysticism

Head of a Young Algerian Jewish Woman, Théodore Chassériau, 1855.

Categories:

Tazria

Published: May 30, 2025

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Editor’s note: For a discussion of the possible form and function of these teraphim see Erin Darby, “Rachel’s Teraphim: A Critique of the Northern Kingdom.”

  2. Biblical translations follow NRSVue, with modifications

  3. Translations of Nahmanides here and following from Nahmanides and Charles Ber Chavel, Commentary on the Torah (Shilo Publishing House, 1971)

  4. Chavel uses the term ‘unclean” for the Hebrew word tamei.  I prefer to translate it as “impure” or “ritually impure,” and do so throughout this paper. The rest of Chavel’s translation is unchanged.

  5. For example, BT Pesahim 111a:

    הָנֵי בֵּי תְרֵי דְּמַצַּעָא לְהוּ אִשָּׁה נִדָּה, אִם תְּחִלַּת נִדָּתָהּ הִיא — הוֹרֶגֶת אֶחָד מֵהֶן, אִם סוֹף נִדָּתָהּ הִיא — מְרִיבָה עוֹשָׂה בֵּינֵיהֶן
    “If a menstruating woman passes between two [men], if it is at the beginning of her menses she will slay one of them and if it is at the end of her menses she will cause strife between them.”
  6. Israel Ta-Shma, ״חסידות אשכנז בספרד: רבנו יונה גירונדי – האיש ופועלו״ [Hasidut/Pietistic Literature of Ashkenaz in Spain: Rabeinu Yonah Gerondi – the man and his work] in Studies in Medieval Rabbinic Literature, (Bialik Institute, 2004), 110-11.

  7. Michael Swartz, “Like the Ministering Angels: Ritual and Purity in Early Jewish Mysticism and Magic,” AJS Review 19, no. 2 (1994): 135, 139.

  8. “Like the Ministering Angels: Ritual and Purity in Early Jewish Mysticism and Magic,” AJS Review 19, no. 2 (1994): 139, 165 n. 138.  See also Shaye Cohen, “Menstruants and the Sacred in Judaism and Christianity,” in Women’s History and Ancient History, ed. Sarah B. Pomeroy, (UNC Press Books, 1991), 281.

  9. Dinari, Yedidyah. "The Customs of the Impurity of the Niddah." Tarbiz 49 (1979): 302-324, 310.

  10. See Ron Barkai, History of Jewish Gynecological Texts in the Middle Ages, Vol. 20 (Brill, 1998), 3, 16. Barkai states that Hebrew gynecological texts first appeared in the twelfth century, beginning with the translation of Arabic works. The writing of original Hebrew medical and scientific treatises began in the twelfth century and continued through the beginning of the sixteenth century.

  11. Hannah Davidson,  ״כאפעה הממית בהבטתו: הנידה בתפיסת הרמב״ן [‘Just as a Viper Kills with its Gaze:’ the Niddah in the commentary of the Ramban], Hispania Judaica Bulletin 5 (2007), 1-41.

  12. Editor’s note: For more on this passage, see Zev Farber, “Postpartum impurity: Why is the duration double for a girl?”

  13. The Hebrew word in the text is v’halvanah, or “white”, but the Tur, another medieval commentator, seems to have had a version of Nahmanides’ commentary which instead reads v’halaha, or “dampness”, which makes more sense.

  14. Galenic medicine was in turn based on the medical theories of the Hippocratic school.

  15. Vivian Nutton, “The Fatal Embrace: Galen and the History of Ancient Medicine,” Science in Context 18, no.1 (2005):115. Terms such as “sanguine”, “phlegmatic”, and “bilious”are holdovers from the Galenic idea that an excess of one of the humors will affect one’s personality.

  16. Sharon Faye Koren, “Kabbalistic Physiology: Isaac the Blind, Nahmanides, and Moses de Leon on Menstruation,” AJS Review 28 no. 2 (2004): 327.

  17. Sharon Faye Koren, “Kabbalistic Physiology: Isaac the Blind, Nahmanides, and Moses de Leon on Menstruation,” AJS Review 28 no. 2 (2004): 327.

  18. Editor’s note: A similar prohibition, including a severe penalty, occurs again in Leviticus 20:18. For more on the development of these laws, see Eve Levavi Feinstein, “Sex During Menstruation: From Impurity to Prohibition.”

  19. Leviticus 18:6; see Chavel, Ramban Commentary on the Torah, Leviticus, 255, n. 297.

  20. In the beginning of Leviticus Ch. 12; see Chavel, Ramban Commentary on the Torah, Leviticus, 255, n. 299.

  21. Hannah Davidson,   ״כאפעה הממית בהבטתו: הנידה בתפיסת הרמב״ן [‘Just as a Viper Kills with its Gaze:’ the Niddah in the commentary of the Ramban], Hispania Judaica Bulletin 5 (2007): 5.

  22. Hannah Davidson,   ״כאפעה הממית בהבטתו: הנידה בתפיסת הרמב״ן [‘Just as a Viper Kills with its Gaze:’ the Niddah in the commentary of the Ramban],,” Hispania Judaica Bulletin 5 (2007): 5-6.

  23. Tanchuma, Metzora 1; Chavel, Ramban Commentary on the Torah, Leviticus, 256, n. 300.

  24. Job 37:16; see Chavel, Ramban Commentary on the Torah, Leviticus, 256, n. 301.

  25. Others translate the term af’ah as “basilisk,” a supernatural snake whose gaze or breath causes instant death.

  26. Hannah Davidson,  ״כאפעה הממית בהבטתו: הנידה בתפיסת הרמב״ן״ [‘Just as a Viper Kills with its Gaze:’ the Niddah in the commentary of the Ramban], 19-20.

  27. I.e. in the comment on Genesis 31:35 discussed above, which appears in the Torah portion Vayetzei.

  28. Evyatar Marienberg, La Baraïta de-Niddah: Un texte juif pseudo-talmudique sur les lois religieuses relatives a la menstruation [The Baraita of Niddah : A Jewish Pseudo-Talmudic Text on the Religious Laws Related to Menstruation], (Brepolis, 2012), 19.

  29. Israel Ta-Shma, ״חסידות אשכנז בספרד: רבנו יונה גירונדי – האיש ופועלו״ [Hasidut/Pietistic Literature of Ashkenaz in Spain: Rabeinu Yonah Gerondi – the man and his work] in Studies in Medieval Rabbinic Literature, (Bialik Institute, 2004), 110-11.

  30. Ephraim Kanarfogel, “On the Assessment of Moses ben Nahman (Nahmanides) and his Literary Oeuvre,” Jewish Book Annual 51, (1993-4):172, n. 51.

  31. Ephraim Kanarfogel, Peering through the lattices: mystical, magical, and pietistic dimensions in the Tosafist period. (Wayne State University Press, 2000), 199.

  32. Oded Yisraeli, ״מקובל בעל-כורחו : ר' יהודה בן יקר - בין דמות לדימוי״ [A Kabbalist Against his Will: Rabbi Judah ben Yakar – between character and image] Kabbalah 31 (2014) 281-2.

  33. This was due in part to the Maimonidean controversy: at its peak in 1230-1235, the Rabbis of Provence issued a ban against the philosophical writings of Moses Maimonides, in which Maimonides sought to reconcile Judaism with Greek philosophy, particularly Aristotle. See Ephraim Kanarfogel, “Between Ashkenaz and Sefard: Tosafist Teachings in the Talmudic Commentaries of Ritva,” in Between Rashi and Maimonides: Themes in Medieval Jewish Thought, Literature, and Exegesis, ed. E. Kanarfogel and M. Sokolow, (Yeshiva University Press, 2010), 242.

  34. “Open Rebuke and Concealed Love: Nahmanides and the Andalusian Tradition,” in Rabbi Moses Nahmanides (RAMBAN): Explorations in His Religious and Literary Virtuosity, ed. I. Twersky, (Harvard University Press, 1983), 12.

  35. Haviva Pedaya, הרמב"ן: התעלות - זמן מחזורי וטקסט קדוש [Nahmanides: Cyclical Time and Holy Text], (ʻAm ʻoved, 2003), 91.

  36. Haviva Pedaya, הרמב"ן: התעלות - זמן מחזורי וטקסט קדוש [Nahmanides: Cyclical Time and Holy Text], (ʻAm ʻoved, 2003), 93.

  37. Haviva Pedaya, הרמב"ן: התעלות - זמן מחזורי וטקסט קדוש [Nahmanides: Cyclical Time and Holy Text], (ʻAm ʻoved, 2003), 95.