The Satan Provokes God into Testing Job and Abraham

Why would God make righteous people suffer just to test their faithfulness? With Job, the Bible is explicit that it was in response to Satan’s challenge, but what about Abraham? Jubilees (2nd cent. C.E.), and later the Talmud and midrash, reimagine the Akedah to have been instigated by Mastema, the Satan, or jealous angels. The midrash goes further and envisions the demon Samael tempting Abraham to make him fail.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The Satan Provokes God into Testing Job and Abraham." TheTorah.com, November 25, 2025. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-satan-provokes-god-into-testing-job-and-abraham.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The Satan Provokes God into Testing Job and Abraham" (2025, November 25). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-satan-provokes-god-into-testing-job-and-abraham

The Satan Provokes God into Testing Job and Abraham

The Sacrifice of Isaac, Mato Celestin Medović 1895. Wikimedia

Categories:

Vayera

Published: November 25, 2025

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. English is based on the NJPS with adjustments.

  2. For one discussion of this, see Marc Zvi Brettler, “(Divine) Silence Is Golden: A New Reading of the Prologue of Job,” in Interested Readers: Essays on the Hebrew Bible in Honor of David J. A. Clines, ed., James K. Aitkin, Jeremy M. S. Clines, Christl M. Maier (SBL, 2013), 19–26.

  3. Indeed, the author of Job included several striking parallels to the story of Abraham, including the description of him as יְרֵא אֱלֹהִים “God fearing” (Gen 22:12, Job 1:1)—the only two biblical characters with this description. Klitsner further notes that several place names in Job reflect names in the story of Abraham (see Job 1:1. Genesis Rabbah also notes this in 57:4), and that “Moreover, they are the only two biblical characters to refer to themselves as עפר ואפר, ‘dust and ashes.’” God’s admission that Job spoke truth may even constitute an indirect commentary to the Akedah that allows us to question God’s justice.

  4. James Kugel, “Jubilees,” in Outside the Bible: Ancient Jewish Writings Related to Scripture, eds. Louis Feldman, James Kugel, and Lawrence Schiffman (Lincoln: Nebraska University Press, 2013), 1.272-465 [p. 272]. One major difference between Jubilees and Rabbinic Judaism is the calendar, since the former uses a strict solar calendar, made up of 364 days. See Michael Segal, “The Jewish Calendar in Jubilees,” TheTorah (2014). This is one reason Rabbinic Judaism rejected the book entirely, despite the influence of many of its narrative expansions on later midrash. See, Zvi Ron, “The Book of Jubilees and the Midrash on the Early Chapters Of Genesis,” Jewish Bible Quarterly Vol. 41. 3 (2013), 143.

  5. The name comes from the Hebrew מַשְׂטֵמָה,a word which appears as a noun in Hosea 9:7–8 meaning “iniquity.” The root, ש.ט.מ is similar to that of Satan, as James Kugel (“Jubilees,” note 107, p. 457) writes:

    The name Mastema means “loathing,” and he is “the chief of the [evil] spirits”—in other words, Satan (both these names are used in Jubilees to describe the same figure). Indeed, the verb derived from the same root as Mastema can mean “accuse,” the satanic activity par excellence (see Job 1:9–11).

  6. Translation follows Orval S. Wintermute with Jame’s Kugel’s adjustments, as it appears in “Jubilees,” Outside the Bible.

  7. Genesis Rabbah was redacted before the Babylonian Talmud, though if the quote from Rabbi Yossi ben Zimra is authentic, it would be earlier. Either way, I started with the Talmud since its homiletical approach is more similar to that of Jubilees, which is certainly the earliest extant version of this homily.

  8. “Hirhur” indicates a thought as opposed to speech, and in Rabbinic Hebrew can mean a sinful thought or a troubled one. It can also refer to criticism, which makes sense for the angels and the nations below. That the thoughts were “troubled” is from the context; the Soncino translation has “misgivings,” but this only works in the case of Abraham, not in the subsequent instances.

  9. The phrase "על מנת ש-" is translated in the Soncino text (and apparently everywhere else) as “even if,” but only in this one passage in GR. Since it otherwise always means “in order to,” or “on the condition that,” generally in a legal sense (I commit to do X only if Y is the case), my translation works to incorporate its primary meaning. One can also translate it “understanding that it will be said of you that you will sacrifice . . .”

  10. Both Job and the midrash have an ironic subtext: Job, who sacrifices for his children’s benefit, is about to lose them, and Abraham, who worries that he should have sacrificed offerings of thanksgiving, is about to be asked to sacrifice his son. Thanks to Herbert Basser for pointing this out to me as we were studying together.

  11. The unnecessary “and” implies that it isn’t just God but God’s entourage involved.

  12. We cannot say whether the rabbinic redactors or their sources knew Jubilees. It is likely that they knew of some older tradition of demons or jealous angels acting as Satan the Adversary does in Job. As is often the case, the midrash finds a way to incorporate this tradition into its technical interpretation of a specific verse. I do not think this was a purely artificial exercise, but one that was done with respect for scripture. I imagine the rabbi/darshan (the scholar/preacher) happy to find solid exegetical confirmation for an early tradition that had previously lacked it, the way a graduate student might rejoice in an authoritative citation to support her view, or a man might treasure a medical finding that backs up his grandmother’s folk remedy.

  13. In many rabbinic texts, the rabbis assume Isaac here is 37-years-old in the story, based on their assumption that Sarah dies upon hearing of the Akedah. He is born when Sarah is 90 years old, and she dies in the very next story at 127, which the midrash understood as her reaction to hearing the news of the Akedah. Thus, Isaac must have been 37 when it took place.

  14. Jubilees does not have this theme, which appears only in rabbinic literature. Here we are looking at the Genesis Rabbah version, though b. Sanhedrin 89b has a parallel account, though with a different purpose. See discussion in Kristen Lindbeck, “Abraham as Hero in the Synagogue and Study House: The Aqedah in Genesis Rabbah and the Babylonian Talmud,” in Making History: Studies in Rabbinic Literature, History, and Culture in Honor of Richard L. Kalmin, ed. Carol Bakhos and Alyssa M. Gray (Brown U. Press, 2024), 366-369.

  15. Samael is often mentioned as a demonic figure in Second Temple literature, and also appears in late Amoraic texts, of which Genesis Rabbah appears to be first. See Lindbeck “Abraham as Hero” 363; see also Gershom Scholem, “Samael,” in Encyclopaedia Judaica, 2nd ed., ed. Michael Berenbaum and Fred Skolnik (Macmillan Reference USA, 2007), 17:714–15.

  16. The Hebrew itself, al manat ken, has a troubling resonance with Tosefta Sanhedrin 11:1-4, which discusses instances in which the death penalty cannot be imposed unless the guilty party has been warned that he intends a capital crime and he says, יודע אני ועל מנת כן אני עושה “I know, and I act with this understanding.”

  17. See Scott B. Noegel, "Abraham's Ten Trials and Biblical Literary Convention." Jewish Bible Quarterly 21 (2003),73-83. For the ten trials in Genesis Rabbah, see Kristen Lindbeck “The Purpose and Weight of Abraham’s Trials in Genesis Rabbah,” paper delivered at SECSOR (Southeastern Regional Meeting of the American Academy of Religion and Society of Biblical Literature) (March 2018), Atlanta, Georgia.

  18. The scene of temptation on Mt. Moriah in B Sanhedrin 89b also has Satan quoting Job 4:2, though there he continues the passage.

  19. Lindbeck, “Abraham as Hero,” 364.

  20. Lindbeck, “Abraham as Hero,” 363-66; 372-74.

  21. James Kugel, “Jubilees,” note on 18:9-11, 357.

  22. The rabbis are understanding this term as it if were הודעתי.

  23. This reading also finds support within the biblical text. When God says that “All the nations of the earth shall bless themselves by your descendants, because you have obeyed My command” (Gen. 22:18, NJPS), scripture implies that Abraham’s obedience means something for the whole world. In its interpretation of this later verse, Jubilees inserts a sentence (in italics below) that agrees with the Rabbinic interpretation that God commanded the Akedah in order to make Abraham’s faithfulness known to all: “And all of the nations of the earth will bless themselves by your seed because you obeyed My word. I have made known to all that you are faithful to Me in everything which I say to you” (18:16 and see also Kugel’s commentary on p. 589).

  24. It appears three more times in the Bible, outside the Torah: Isaiah 45:23, Jeremiah 22:5, 49:13.

  25. This part of the midrash implicitly criticizes the Akedah as too severe a test, and it works together with Abraham’s complaint to God, when he learns God is about to destroy Sodom and Gomorrah:

    בראשית יח:כה חָלִלָה לְּךָ מֵעֲשֹׂת כַּדָּבָר הַזֶּה לְהָמִית צַדִּיק עִם רָשָׁע וְהָיָה כַצַּדִּיק כָּרָשָׁע חָלִלָה לָּךְ הֲשֹׁפֵט כָּל הָאָרֶץ לֹא יַעֲשֶׂה מִשְׁפָּט.
    Gen 18:25 Far be it from You to do such a thing, to bring death upon the innocent as well as the guilty, so that innocent and guilty fare alike. Far be it from You! Shall not the Judge of all the earth deal justly?
  26. See Klitsner, “The Book of Job and its Paradoxical Relationship with the Akedah.”

  27. Earlier in the midrash (55:3), Genesis Rabbah questions God’s terrible test, or at least implies that it was almost too much to bear, in a mashal (parable), which compares God to an ethically inconsistent teacher. The mashal does not mention Abraham by name; instead, it concludes with the whole people of Israel (or the Rabbinic author), questioning the double standard implicit in “You shall not test the Lord your God” (לֹא תְנַסּוּ אֶת יְ־הֹוָ֜ה , Deuteronomy 6:16) combined with “God tested Abraham” (וְהָאֱלֹהִים נִסָּה אֶת אַבְרָהָם, Gen. 22:1).