Israelites at the Jordan River. YoramRaanan.com ©
The Settlement of Reuben and Gad: A Rhetorical Case for Transjordan as Part of the Promised Land
Moses misunderstands the request of the Gadites and Reubenites to settle in the Transjordan as a result of unwillingness to participate in the conquest of Canaan with the rest of the Israelites. Once he realizes that they do mean to fight, he accepts their request. The author of Numbers 32 creates a rhetorically rich argument that the Transjordan is part of the Promised Land—but not everyone was buying what this author was selling.
Published: August 1, 2019
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
On relevance theory, see Deirdre Wilson and Dan Sperber, “Relevance Theory,” in The Handbook of Pragmatics, ed. Laurence Horn and Gergory Ward (Oxford: Blackwell, 2004), 607–32; Deirdre Wilson and Dan Sperber, Meaning and Relevance (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012).
E.g., Liane Feldman, “Gad and Reuben Receive Land in the Transjordan: A Documentary Approach,” TheTorah.com (2018); Jacob Wright, “Redacting the Relationship to the Transjordanian Tribes,” TheTorah.com (2014).
It is widely, and rightly, recognized that the story is about Reuben and Gad, and that the inclusion of Manasseh in the land allotments at the very end of the chapter is forced. The inclusion of Manasseh does not affect the rhetorical analysis of the main body of the story, so I have not addressed it here.
For discussion of this, see Angela Roskop Erisman, “Navigating the Torah’s Rough Narrative Terrain into the Land,” TheTorah.com (2019).
Again, see Erisman, “Navigating the Torah’s Rough Narrative Terrain into the Land.”
For discussion of the Numbers 33 itinerary, see Angela Roskop (Erisman), The Wilderness Itineraries: Genre, Geography, and the Growth of Torah, History, Archaeology, and Culture of the Levant 3 (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 2011), 223–232.
Numbers 33–34 are not the only texts to do this. I devote significant attention to these two chapters as well as Numbers 16–17, 25, and 31 in Angela Roskop Erisman, “Numbers,” in The New Oxford Bible Commentary, ed. Katherine Dell and David Lincicum (Oxford: Oxford University Press, forthcoming); Erisman, Numbers, New Cambridge Bible Commentary (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, forthcoming); and Erisman, The Wilderness Narratives in the Hebrew Bible: Religion, Politics, and Biblical Interpretation (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, forthcoming). Joshua 22 also weighs in on this question, albeit from a different angle; there, the source of conflict is an altar in Transjordan, and the presence of Israelites in Transjordan is accepted on condition that the altar is merely symbolic and not a competitor to the sanctuary in Jerusalem.
Editor’s note: For some discussion of the Mesha inscription and its relevance to Israelite settlement in the area, see David Ben-Gad HaCohen, “War at Yahatz: The Torah Versus the Mesha Stele,” TheTorah.com (2015); Israel Finkelstein and Thomas Römer, “North Israelite Memories of the Transjordan and the Mesha Inscription,” TheTorah.com (2019); Aaron Koller, “The Tribe of Gad and the Mesha Inscription,” TheTorah.com (2013).