Torah, Historically Not from Sinai, Can Still Be from Heaven
Published: February 5, 2023
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
This is based on the revelation story related in Exodus 19–24 and, with a somewhat different emphasis (oral as contrasted with visual), in Deuteronomy 4–5.
See Sifra, Behukotai, Parasha 2 8:13; Sifrei Devarim §351, Exodus Rabbah, Yitro §28, and many other places. In fact, any future derivation of the Torah’s teaching, the midrash suggests, was already revealed to Moses. This is related to another, narrower but related, doctrine—that of Halakha le-Moshe mi-Sinai, the notion that halakhot that are not explicit in the Written Torah have been transmitted orally through the generations, such that they have the status of Torah law even though they are not manifest in the Written Torah.
For these and many additional sources, see: Yoshi Fargeon, “Annotated Anthology—“Wisdom and Knowledge Will be Given to You” in The Believer and the Modern Study of the Bible, Yehudah Brandes, Tovah Ganzel, and Chayuta Deutsch (Boston : Academic Studies Press, 2019), 1–190; trans. of "החכמה והמדע נתון לך: אסופת מקורות מוערת" in בעיני אלוהים ואדם: האדם המאמין ומחקר המקרא, second edition (Haifa: Pardes, 2017; repr. of Jerusalem: Morasha, 2015), 19–161.
For more on these sources, see my, “What Was the Book of the Wars of the Lord?” TheTorah (2017). For more on how the Torah presents itself, see Christopher Rollston, “Who Wrote the Torah According to the Torah?” TheTorah (2017).
Gloss on Numbers 21:14.
For example, Genesis 5:1; Exodus 17:14; 24:7; Numbers 21:14; Deuteronomy 28:58, 61; 29:19, 20, 26; 30:10; 31:24, 26.
Editor’s note: See Yuval Cherlow, “Authorship of the Torah: The Position of Ibn Ezra and Yehuda HaChasid,” TheTorah (2013); Zev Farber, “Seven Torah Passages of Non-Mosaic Origin According to Ibn Ezra and R. Joseph Bonfils,” TheTorah (2014); Baruch Schwartz, “When Moses Placed Ephraim Before Manasseh,” TheTorah (2017); Zev Farber, “Edomite Kings List: Is It Post-Mosaic?” TheTorah (2019).
Editor’s note: See discussion in, Zev Farber, “The Hebrew Slave: Exodus, Leviticus, and Deuteronomy,” TheTorah (2015); Aaron J. Koller, “The Hebrew Slave: Reading the Law Collections as Complementary,” TheTorah (2015).
Editor’s note: See discussion in, Marvin A. Sweeney, “How Do We Conceive the Divine?” TheTorah (2014); Deena Grant, “Loving God Beyond the Way You Love Ashurbanipal,” TheTorah (2016); Gad Barnea, “Enforcing YHWH’s Covenant with Blessings and Curses—Imperial Style,” TheTorah (2022).
Mircea Eliade The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion, trans. Willard R. Trask, (New York: Harcourt Brace, 1959), 70; trans. of Le Sacré et le Profane (Hamburg: Rowohlt, 1957).
Editor’s note: This is explored in Zev Farber, “‘Torah Is from Heaven’: What Do We Really Mean?” TheTorah (2019).