Scroll of Esther, Morocco, 18th century, The Magnes Collection / Flickr
Using Memory, Megillat Esther Confronts the Jewish People with their Past
Although the book of Esther seems to have “forgotten” important Jewish themes like God, a closer look reveals that memory and biblical allusions play an important role in how the book tells its story.
Published: March 20, 2019
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
In this article, I am discussing only the Masoretic text of Esther. For the Greek text, see Aaron Koller, “A More Religious Megillat Esther,” TheTorah (2014); Jean-Daniel Macchi, Le Livre D’Esther [The Book of Esther] (Geneva: Labor et Fides, 2016), 14–123, as the Greek versions have several expansions and are quite different. Concerning the different theologies the different recensions suggest, see Elsie Stern, “Megillat Esther: A Godless and Assimilated Diaspora,” TheTorah (2014).
For some versions of this approach, see, Elias Bickerman,Four Strange Books of the Bible: Jonah, Daniel, Koheleth, Esther (New York: Schocken, 1967), 171–240; Albert Baumgarten, “Scroll of Esther,” Encyclopedia Judaica 14:1053; Christoph Levin, The Old Testament: A Brief Introduction, trans. Margaret Kohl (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2005), 161–164; Sarah Japhet and Zev Farber, “Unraveling Megillat Esther: How the Story Was Developed,” TheTorah (2016). This theory has been widely criticized. See, e.g., Carey A. Moore, Esther, Anchor Bible 7b (Garden City: Doubleday, 1971), 51; Edward L. Greenstein, “A Jewish Reading of Esther,” in Judaic Perspectives on Ancient Israel, ed. Jacob Neusner, Baruch A. Levine, and E. S. Frerichs (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1987), 225–243 [237–238]; Sidnie Ann White, “Esther: A Feminine Model for Jewish Diaspora,” in Gender and Difference in Ancient Israel, ed. Peggy L. Day (Minneapolis: Augsburg Fortress, 1989), 161–177 [p. 163].
See Jon D. Levenson, Esther, Old Testament Library (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1997), 7–9; Yehudah T. Radday, “Chiasm in Joshua, Judges and Others,” Linguistica Biblica 3 (1973): 27–28; Jonathan Grossman, אסתר: מגילת סתרים [Esther: Scroll of Secrets] (Jerusalem: Maggid, 2013), 8–12.
On the structure of the book, see also Sandra B. Berg, The Book of Esther: Motifs, Themes and Structure (Missoula, MT: Scholars Press, 1979), 106–113.
Timothy K. Beal, Esther, Berit Olam (Collegeville, MN: Michael Glazier, 1999), 17–18.
According to Radday’s division, these two appearances of the root are located precisely at two parallel points in the megillah.
Concerning the ungainly conclusion and the repetitions within it, see Orit Avnery, עומדות על הסף שייכות וזרות במגילות רות ואסתר [Liminal Women: Belonging and Otherness in the Books of Ruth and Esther] (Jerusalem: Shalom Hartman Institute, 2015), 113–114, 147–148.
Even this statement is unclear, since bowing before Haman does not seem to violate any obvious Jewish law or principle. This explains why the answers offered in rabbinic interpretation are so diverse. For more on this, see Rachel Adelman, “Why Did Mordechai Not Bow Down to Haman?,”TheTorah.com (2015).
“Esther was [motionless] like the ground of the earth” (אסתר קרקע עולם היתה), b. Sanhedrin 72b.
Traditional exegesis identified allusions to the presence of God and explained God’s apparent absence by reference to the secular nature of the megillah. Others have sought to learn from the absence of the divine name that the megillah did not originate as a religious work. A third approach is that the absence of the name of God is a means of expressing a theological position. In the reality of exile, where there is no direct revelation, faith becomes complicated. The story of the megillah is the story of religious ambiguity: a person must choose to see and to feel the presence of God in his lived reality. For a broader discussion and additional references, see Avnery, Liminal Women, 158; Stern, “Megillat Esther: A Godless and Assimilated Diaspora.”
See Koller, “A More Religious Megillat Esther.”
A more expansive version of this midrash appears in Pirkei de-Rabbi Eliezer 49:
“ותאמר אסתר להשיב אל מרדכי,” אמרה לו “לך כנוס את כל היהודים הנמצאים בשושן וצומו עלי ואל תאכלו ואל תשתו שלשת ימים לילה ויום,” ואלו הן י”ג בניסן י”ד בניסן ט”ו בניסן.
“Esther told Hatach to take back to Mordecai the following reply”—She said to him: “Go, assemble all the Jews who live in Shushan, and fast in my behalf; do not eat or drink for three days, night or day”—and these are they: the thirteenth of Nisan, the fourteenth of Nisan, and the fifteenth of Nisan.
אמר לה מרדכי והלא יום שלישי הוא יום ראשון של פסח, אמרה לו זקן שבישראל ואתה ראש לסנהדרין ואתה אומ’ דבר זה, ואם אין ישראל לעשות הפסח למי הוא פסח,
Mordechai said to her: “But is the third day not the first day of Passover?!” She said to him: “Elder of Israel, head of the Sanhedrin—yet you say this?! If there are no Israelites to observe Passover, then for whom is Passover?”
ושמע מרדכי את דבריה והודה לה מרדכי ועשה לה כל אשר צותהו, שנ’ ויעבור מרדכי ויעש ככל אשר צותה עליו אסתר, מה הוא לשון ויעבור מרדכי, מלמד שעבר יום ראשון של פסח בלא אכילה ושתיה”
Mordecai listened to what she said, and Mordecai deferred to her and did all that she had commanded him, as is said: “So Mordecai passed along and did just as Esther had commanded him.” What is the sense of the diction “Mordecai passed along”? This teaches that he passed the first day of Passover without eating or drinking.
Most scholars date Esther to the close of the Persian Period or the beginning of the Greek Period; see Adele Berlin,Esther, in The Jewish Study Bible, 2nd ed., ed. Adele Berlin and Marc Zvi Brettler (New York: Oxford University Press, 2014), 1621; Lawrence Wills, “Rejoicing on Purim with a Jewish Novel,” TheTorah.com (2014).
Editor’s note: For more on this contrast, see Sara Japhet,“Survival and Revival: Megillat Esther and Ezra-Nehemiah,”TheTorah.com (2015).
Editor’s note: For more on the identification of Ahasuerus with Xerxes, see part 1 of Mitchel First, “If Achashverosh Is Xerxes, Is Esther his Wife Amestris?,” TheTorah.com (2016). For an overview of Persian history, see Zev Farber, “The 220-Year History of the Achaemenid-Persian Empire,”TheTorah.com (2017).
For a general discussion of this, see Jonathan Grossman, “‘Dynamic Analogies’ in the Book of Esther,” Vetus Testamentum 59 (2009): 394–414; Jonathan Grossman,Esther: The Outer Narrative and the Hidden Meaning, Siphrut 6 (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 2011).
On Esther and Sarah, see Yair Zakovitch, מקראות בארץ המראות [Through the Looking Glass: Reflection Stories in the Bible], ספריית הילל בן חיים [The Hillel ben Haim Library] (Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad, 1995), 65–67.
For these and other parallels between the Joseph story and the megillah, see Esther and the story of Joseph: see, Moshe Gan, “מגילת אסתר באספקלריית קורות יוסף במצרים” [The Book of Esther in the Light of the Story of Joseph in Egypt], Tarbiz 31 (1961), 144–149; Berg, The Book of Esther, 123–142; Grossman, Esther: Scroll of Secrets, 257–259. The beginnings of this equation can be found as early as midrashic literature; see Esther Rabbah 7–8.
David Silber with Ben Zion Ovadia, אם לעת כזאת: השתקפויות מקראיות במגילת אסתר [For Such a Time as This: Biblical Reflections in the Book of Esther] (Jerusalem: Maggid, 2016), 54–55.
Silber, For Such a Time as This, 192.
Gillis Gerleman, Esther, Biblischer Kommentar, Altes Testament (Neukirchen-Vluyn 1982); Charles E. Hambrick-Stowe, “Ruth the New Abraham, Esther the New Moses,”Christian Century, December 7, 1983, 1130-1134.
Arie C. Leder, “Hearing Esther After Joshua,” in The Book of Joshua, ed. Ed Noort, Bibliotheca Ephemeridum Theologicarum Lovaniensium 250 (Leuven: Peeters, 2012), 267–279.
Esther and Saul: Moore, Esther, 37; Ariella Deem-Goldberg, “התשתית האמנותית במגילת אסתר” [The Artistic Foundations of the Scroll of Esther], ביקורת ופרשנות [Criticism & Interpretation] 11–12 (5738 [1978]): 285–297; Beal, Esther, 25; Marc Zvi Brettler, “Megillat Esther: Reversing the Legacy of King Saul,” TheTorah.com (2017).
Yitzhak Berger, “Esther and Benjaminite Royalty: A Study in Inner-Biblical Allusion,” Journal of Biblical Literature 129 (2010): 625-644 [641].
The only other verse that makes use of these two terms is Deuteronomy 28:47:
תַּחַת אֲשֶׁר לֹא עָבַדְתָּ אֶת יְ־הֹוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ בְּשִׂמְחָה וּבְטוּב לֵבָב מֵרֹב כֹּל.
Because you would not serve YHWH your God in happiness and light-heartedness over the abundance of everything.
This, however, is not adjectival, nor is it part of a story. Also, when Haman is commanded to honor Mordechai, King Ahasuerus says אַל תַּפֵּל דָּבָר מִכֹּל אֲשֶׁר דִּבַּרְתָּ “let nothing you have said drop” (Esth 6:10). This formal phrasing is reminiscent of what King Solomon says about God after building the Temple, כְּכֹל אֲשֶׁר דִּבֵּר לֹא נָפַל דָּבָר אֶחָד מִכֹּל דְּבָרוֹ הַטּוֹב, “according to all that he said, not one thing was dropped from all of his good words” (1 Kgs 8:56). See Amos Frisch, “בין מגילת אסתר וספר מלכים” [Between the Book of Esther and the Book of Kings], Mehqerei Hag 3 (5752 [1992]): 25–35.
Yitzhak Berger, “Esther and Benjaminite Royalty: A Study in Inner-Biblical Allusion,” Journal of Biblical Literature 129 (2010): 625–644.
Jonathan Grossman, “גזרות המן וכרם נבות” [The Edicts of Haman and the Vineyard of Naboth], Megadim 30 (1999): 49–66.
Memory, as noted by Avi Sagi, has an active function. Avi Sagi, The Present Age: Looking at Jewish Thought Today (Ramat Gan: Bar-Ilan University; Jerusalem: Shalom Hartman Institute, 2017), 185.
It is not amiss to note that in this book of remembrances, God is “forgotten.”
Berl Katznelson, “מקורות לא-אכזב” [Sources Unfailing], in כתבי ברל כצנלסון [The Works of Berl Katznelson], 11 vols. (Israel: Miphleget Poalei Eretz Yisrael, 1945–1950), 6:389.