What Melacha did the Wood Gatherer Violate?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"What Melacha did the Wood Gatherer Violate?." TheTorah.com, June 12, 2014. https://www.thetorah.com/article/what-melacha-did-the-wood-gatherer-violate.

APA Style

Click to copy

"What Melacha did the Wood Gatherer Violate?" (2014, June 12). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/what-melacha-did-the-wood-gatherer-violate

Categories:

Shelach

Published: June 12, 2014

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. See, for example, Jer. 17:19-27, Neh. 13:14-22.

  2. Nevertheless, this suggestion falls short on why there is no mention of the gatherer actually lighting the fire. Is it likely he was put to death for planning to light a fire?

  3.  

    ר’ חייה בר גמדא שאל מקושש משום מאי מיחייב משום תולש או משום קוצר נישמעינה מהדא [במדבר טו לב] ויהיו בני ישראל במדבר וימצאו מלמד שמצאוהו תולש עצים מן הקרקע.

    This suggestion appears in a different form in the Sifrei Numbers (113):

    וימצאו איש מקושש עצים, תולש מן הקרקע אתה אומר תולש מן הקרקע או אינו אלא איש ושמו מקושש ת”ל ויקריבו אותו המוצאים אותו מקושש עצים הא מה ת”ל וימצאו איש מקושש עצים תולש מן הקרקע.
    ‘They came upon a man gathering [mekoshesh] wood’ – he was detaching [wood] from the ground. Was he detaching wood from the ground or maybe his name was Mekoshesh? The verse comes to teach us, ‘Those who found him as he was gathering the wood brought him…’ Thus what do the words ‘they found a man mekoshesh eitzim’ come to teach us? That he was detaching wood from the ground.
  4.  Tolesh and kotzer are generally considered to be the same melacha. Rabbi David Frankel (Korban Ha-Eida ad loc.) explains the difference that tolesh means uprooting and kotzer is when the plant is cut above the stem (תולש היינו שעוקר הדבר עם שרשו וקוצר היינו שגומם מעל הארץ).

  5. For some suggestions on the origins of the 39 melachot, see the TABS essay of Rabbi Dr. Yoel Bin Nun, “The Textual Source for the 39 Melachot of Shabbat,”  and Rabbi Evan Hoffman, “40 Minus 1 Melachot of Shabbat – Cracking the Rabbinic Code.”

  6. It is also interesting to note that there is already a melacha that has to do with tying: קושר (qosher).