Why Didn’t the Israelites Circumcise in the Wilderness?

Joshua circumcises the Israelites only upon their entry to the land.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Why Didn’t the Israelites Circumcise in the Wilderness?." TheTorah.com, March 25, 2021. https://www.thetorah.com/article/why-didnt-the-israelites-circumcise-in-the-wilderness.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Why Didn’t the Israelites Circumcise in the Wilderness?" (2021, March 25). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/why-didnt-the-israelites-circumcise-in-the-wilderness

Why Didn’t the Israelites Circumcise in the Wilderness?

Israelites in the wilderness, Moshe Rosenthalis, ca. 1978-1980. Wikimedia

Categories:

Lech Lecha

Published: March 25, 2021

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The word חולשא “weakness” appears in the Vilna printing, the Venice printing, and MS Oxford 367. The word חוליא (or חולייא) “illness” appears in the Pesaro printing, MSS Munich 95, Munich 141, Vatican 110-111, and T-S F 1(2).26–27.

  2. The Talmud later explains that God stopped the north wind from blowing at all during the wilderness period to avoid blowing away the clouds of glory.

  3. The comment here is not in Kara’s commentary on the book of Joshua but in the anonymous commentary on the haftara of Passover in MS Cincinnati 1, which has been identified as his. See the edition in AlHaTorah.com.

  4. A similar interpretation can be found in the commentaries of Radak and Ralbag (ad loc.)

  5. Such a reading works well with the premise in the Dinah story, that circumcised individuals were in need of several days of rest in order to heal (cf. Gen 34:25). This is why the brothers insist that the men of Shechem be circumcised, so they can enter the city after a few days and easily dispatch the convalescing men.

  6. שמות ד:כד וַיְהִי בַדֶּרֶךְ בַּמָּלוֹן וַיִּפְגְּשֵׁהוּ יְהוָה וַיְבַקֵּשׁ הֲמִיתוֹ. ד:כה וַתִּקַּח צִפֹּרָה צֹר וַתִּכְרֹת אֶת עָרְלַת בְּנָהּ וַתַּגַּע לְרַגְלָיו וַתֹּאמֶר כִּי חֲתַן דָּמִים אַתָּה לִי. ד:כו וַיִּרֶף מִמֶּנּוּ אָז אָמְרָה חֲתַן דָּמִים לַמּוּלֹת.
    Exod 4:24 At a night encampment on the way, YHWH encountered him and sought to kill him. 4:25 So Zipporah took a flint and cut off her son's foreskin, and touched his legs with it, saying, “You are truly a bridegroom of blood to me!” 4:26 And when He let him alone, she added, “A bridegroom of blood because of the circumcision.”

    Traditional commentators are well aware of the above-mentioned problem, and suggest that the family must have then rested there for a week, though the text says nothing about this.

  7. Allowing for travel time, this might amount to about a year of stationary living at each encampment, if evenly divided!

  8. On account of such problems, some commentators have attempted to reinterpret the story in Joshua. The Babylonian Talmud suggests that the men were already circumcised, and Joshua was commanded to make a slight adjustment their circumcisions (b. Yebamot 72a):

    אמר רבה בר יצחק אמר רב, לא נתנה פריעת מילה לאברהם אבינו, שנא', בעת ההיא אמר ה' ליהושע עשה לך חרבות צרים וגו'.
    Rabbah son of Isaac said in the name of Rav: The periah (peeling off the epithelium after the removal of the foreskin) of circumcision was not given to our father Abraham, as it says, “At that time the Lord said to Joshua, make for yourself flint knives…” (Josh 5:2).

    Strikingly, a very similar explanation was offered by Jack Sasson, “Circumcision in the Ancient Near East,” JBL 85 (1966), 473–476. This interpretation deals with the problematic description of Joshua circumcising the Israelites “a second time” in v. 2, but it ignores the straightforward meaning of vv. 4–7, which assume the Israelites born in the wilderness were uncircumcised. Another implausible explanation comes from the Israeli Bible scholar Yehezkel Kaufmann (1889–1963) in his commentary on Joshua 5:5:

    לא מלו—דבר זה לא נזכר בתורה, וגם כאן לא נתן לו טעם. יש לשער שהיה ספור על נדר שנדרו, שלא ימולו את בניהם עד שיבואו לארצם.
    They didn’t circumcise—This matter is not mentioned in the Torah, nor here does it really give a reason. It is reasonable to speculate that there was a story about a vow that they took not to circumcise their sons until they reached the land.

    (Yehezkel Kaufmann, ספר יהושע [The Book of Joshua] (Jerusalem: Kiryat Sepher, 1959), 107). This idea, however is woven of whole cloth. A third approach, suggested by the contemporary German Bible scholar, Erhard Blum, is that the parenthetical passage isn’t meant to explain or rationalize the failure to circumcise in the wilderness, but instead, comes to highlight the fact that the rebellious exodus generation sinfully refrained from circumcising their children. (Erhard Blum, “Beschneidung und Passa in Kanaan: Beobachtungen und Mutmassungen zu Jos 5,” in Freiheit und Recht. Festschrift für Frank Crüsemann zum 65. Geburtstag, ed. Christof Hardmeier, Rainer Kessler, Andreas Ruwe [Gütersloh: Gütersloher Verlag, 2003]), 292–322 [307–308]. See also, David M. Howard, Jr., Joshua, NAC 5 [Nashville: Broadmand and Holman], 1998, 150.) That is why Joshua had to circumcise the new generation when they entered the land. The text, however, never identifies the failure to circumcise as a sin.

  9. In my previous piece I argued that the claim that circumcision removes Israel’s disgrace was part of the pre-Dtr layer of the story and was stated by Joshua. I am now less sure. This is a possible reconstruction, but it is also possible that the oldest layer went straight from v. 3 to v. 9b (the naming of the place as Gilgal), without this quote. Following this reconstruction, the subject of verse 9b would have been Joshua rather than God. This coincides with the fact that place names are generally given by individuals rather than God. Furthermore, not all name-etiologies are preceded by a speech that provide an explicit explanation for the new name. Not infrequently, name-etiologies are implicit in nature. In our case, the fact that circumcision consists in cutting in a circular fashion may have constituted the original reasoning for the name Gilgal. Alternatively, Gilgal could have been understood as hinting at the heap (גל) of foreskins implied in the name גבעת הערלות. See also Yair Zakovitch, “Explicit and Implicit Name-Derivations,” HAR 4 (1980), 167­–181, who argues that several explicit name-derivations are late additions to texts that originally contained implicit name-derivations alone.

  10. The LXX here has וְשֵׁב, “and sit,” instead of “again.”

  11. This word is absent in the LXX.

  12. The LXX for what we have as vv. 14–15 reads differently here; see discussion later.

  13. Verse 5 is clearly an expansion and will be discussed below at length. Verse 6a may be an expansion as well. Verse 6b continues much more smoothly after verse 4. What is more, verse 6a reflects the conception that the forty-year period of wandering in the wilderness was designed to make time for the adult generation to slowly die out. This idea is clearly reflected in the Priestly part of the Spies story (cf. Num 14:33; 32:13). However, the non-Priestly section of the story of the Spies in Numbers 14 never mentions the idea that the forty-year wandering was introduced for this purpose. It merely condemns the adult generation to die in the wilderness (cf. verse 23). The same is true of Deut 1:34 ff. This probably coincides with the idea that in pre-Priestly and Deuteronomic thinking, the forty-year duration was an independent datum that had nothing to do with punishment. This idea is also reflected in verses 4, 6b of our passage. Verse 6a does have a parallel in Deut 2:14-16. It seems likely, however, that verses 14b-16 are a gloss on verse 14a, which was originally meant as a time marker alone.

  14. These last three words do not appear in the LXX.

  15. That this editor was part of the Deuteronomistic school is clear from the text’s language. Note, for instance, the way YHWH’s speech in v. 9 is introduced in comparison with similar introductions in other Deuteronomistic texts:

    Josh 4:1–2

    Josh 5:8–9

    Deut 2:16–18

    וַיְהִי כַּאֲשֶׁר תַּמּוּ כָל הַגּוֹי לַעֲבוֹר אֶת הַיַּרְדֵּן וַיֹּאמֶר יְ־הוָה אֶל יְהוֹשֻׁעַ לֵאמֹר. קְחוּ לָכֶם מִן הָעָם שְׁנֵים עָשָׂר אֲנָשִׁים...

    וַיְהִי כַּאֲשֶׁר תַּמּוּ כָל הַגּוֹי לְהִמּוֹל... וַיֹּאמֶר יְ־הוָה אֶל יְהוֹשֻׁעַ הַיּוֹם גַּלּוֹתִי אֶת חֶרְפַּת מִצְרַיִם מֵעֲלֵיכֶם...

    וַיְהִי כַאֲשֶׁר תַּמּוּ כָּל אַנְשֵׁי הַמִּלְחָמָה לָמוּת מִקֶּרֶב הָעָם. וַיְדַבֵּר יְ־הוָה אֵלַי לֵאמֹר. אַתָּה עֹבֵר הַיּוֹם אֶת גְּבוּל מוֹאָב אֶת עָר.

    When the entire nation had finished crossing the Jordan, YHWH said to Joshua, “Select twelve men from among the people…”

    After the whole nation finished circumcising … YHWH said to Joshua, “Today I have rolled away from you the disgrace of Egypt.”…

    When all the warriors among the people had finished dying off, YHWH spoke to me, saying: You are now passing through the territory of Moab, through Ar.

    The opening of the story also uses the Deuteronomistic phrase for a supplemental story בָּעֵת הַהִיא, “at that time” (cf., e.g., Deut 10:1). Another possible mark of Deuteronomistic language is YHWH’s use ofהיום “today”—or היום הזה “on this day” (ἐν τῇ σήμερον ἡμέρᾳ) as per the LXX text—which is reminiscent of Joshua 3:7 and Deut 2:25. It should be clear, in any event, that verse 8b interrupts the natural continuity between verses 8a and verse 9. This provides further support for our previously asserted contention that verse 8b belongs to the later, Priestly layer of the text.

  16. A similar shift can be found in Deuteronomy itself with earlier texts describing the laws as coming from Moses and later layers as coming from God. See David Frankel, “Moses’ Commandments: The Secret of R. Nissim of Marseilles,” TheTorah (2016).

  17. Note that the Deuteronomistic author did not invent the story about Joshua circumcising the Israelites; he is merely recasting a story he inherited.

  18. See also, Deut 1:34–35, 39.

  19. This article is based on the latter half of Gili Kugler, “Moses Died and the People Moved On: A Hidden Narrative in Deuteronomy,” Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 43.2 (2019): 191–204. See also most recently, Jeffrey Stackert, “The Wilderness Period without Generation Change: The Deuteronomic Portrayal of Israel’s Forty-Year Journey,” Vetus Testamentum 70 (2020): 696–721. I do not concur, however, with some of Stackert’s analyses.

  20. It never addresses a “why” question. For a good discussion of the texts that use this formula see Zipora Talshir, "נוסחת הפירוט וזה הדבר" [The Detailing Formula], Tarbiz 51 (1981): 23–35.

  21. This is the formal structure of the formula, though obviously what undergirds the text’s distinction is the “why,” namely that intentional murderers deserve their fate while unintentional ones deserve protection.

  22. This contradicts the assertion in 1 Kings 5:26–28, implying that there was some controversy among the scribes about whether the Israelites served as corvée laborers under Solomon or not.

  23. As noted above, the idea that the Israelites at Gilgal stayed stationary until they healed from the circumcision coincides nicely with the idea that they could not circumcise in the wilderness because of the journey. It is also clearly disruptive.

  24. The secondary nature of the Priestly gloss can be seen when we compare the MT version to that of the LXX, which doesn’t have most of v. 5 and which includes Israelites who left Egypt among those whom Joshua circumcises (the Hebrew is a reconstruction):

    Ἰησοῦς 5:4 ὃν δὲ τρόπον περιεκάθαρεν Ἰησοῦς τοὺς υἱοὺς Ισραηλ ὅσοι ποτὲ ἐγένοντο ἐν τῇ ὁδῷ καὶ ὅσοι ποτὲ ἀπερίτμητοι ἦσαν τῶν ἐξεληλυθότων ἐξ Αἰγύπτου 5:5 πάντας τούτους περιέτεμεν Ἰησοῦς
    וזה הדבר אשר מל יהושע את בני ישראל: כל העם הילודים בדרך וכל העם הערלים היוצאים ממצרים—כל אלה מל יהושע.
    This is the matter of Joshua purifying/circumcising the children of Israel: as many as were born on the way and as many as were uncircumcised of those who had come out of Egypt.

    Note that v. 7 in the LXX contains the same text as MT, including the gloss that Joshua circumcises those who were born on the way in the wilderness:

    ἀντὶ δὲ τούτων ἀντικατέστησεν τοὺς υἱοὺς αὐτῶν οὓς Ἰησοῦς περιέτεμεν διὰ τὸ αὐτοὺς γεγενῆσθαι κατὰ τὴν ὁδὸν ἀπεριτμήτους
    And in their place he raised up their sons, whom Joshua circumcised because they remained uncircumcised on the way.
  25. דברים א:לט וְטַפְּכֶם אֲשֶׁר אֲמַרְתֶּם לָבַז יִהְיֶה וּבְנֵיכֶם אֲשֶׁר לֹא יָדְעוּ הַיּוֹם טוֹב וָרָע הֵמָּה יָבֹאוּ שָׁמָּה וְלָהֶם אֶתְּנֶנָּה וְהֵם יִירָשׁוּהָ.
    Deut 1:39 Your sons who today cannot distinguish good from bad, they will enter there, to them I will give it, and they will inherit it.”
  26. The statement of verse 7, “So he raised up their sons in their place” sounds jarring after verse 5, since verse 5 already speaks about the children born in the wilderness. The removal of verse 5 thus facilitates the reconstruction of a smoother and more straightforward statement.

  27. See discussion in, Frankel, “Joshua Circumcises Israel in Response to Egypt’s Scorn.”

  28. 7b goes together with verse 5 in assuming that the failure of the Israelites to perform circumcision needs some special explanation. In fact, this clause makes little sense without the previous affirmation of verse 5 that those who left Egypt were circumcised.

  29. As Joshua is leading a military campaign, circumcision may be thought of here as an initiation into military life in the earliest layer of the text.

  30. Note that in Genesis 34, a non-Priestly text, the men are circumcised but there is no mention of boys (children or babies). Note also in Exodus 4, another non-Priestly text, no mention is made of the 8th day for when Moses was expected to have circumcised his son.