4th Anniversary Reflections on the Vision and Progress of TheTorah.com

Are Jews moving towards studying Torah with academic scholarship?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"4th Anniversary Reflections on the Vision and Progress of TheTorah.com." TheTorah.com, May 30, 2017. https://www.thetorah.com/blog/4th-anniversary-reflections-on-the-vision-and-progress-of-thetorah-com.

APA Style

Click to copy

"4th Anniversary Reflections on the Vision and Progress of TheTorah.com" (2017, May 30). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/blog/4th-anniversary-reflections-on-the-vision-and-progress-of-thetorah-com

May 30, 2017
4th Anniversary Reflections on the Vision and Progress of TheTorah.com

Published: May 30, 2017

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Marc B. Shapiro, “Is Modern Orthodoxy Moving Towards an Acceptance of Biblical Criticism?” Modern Judaism 37.2 (2017): 165-193.

  2. I note here that despite Shapiro’s description of TheTorah.com as in the Modern Orthodox camp, I actually identify Charedi, not Modern Orthodox, and I am the co-founder and director of Project TABS.

  3. Hazony has expressed his lack of comfort with the inclusion of the tenets of biblical criticism in Orthodoxy in his, "Open Orthodoxy?" Torah Musings (2014). Hazony identifies this trend as “Open Orthodox” though TheTorah.com has no affiliation with Open Orthodoxy and its institutions have not supported this cause.

  4. The call for papers writes:

    Among recent challenges is criticism of the classical view of torah from heaven from Jewish scholars and academics, who have proposed the adoption of a rival theology of torah from heaven: One in which God gave his teaching to Israel through the work of large numbers of anonymous scribes over many generations in what has been called an “unfolding” revelation.

    For more on the concept of an unfolding or continuous revelation, see Tamar Ross, "Open Orthodoxy and the Challenge of Biblical Criticism," TheTorah.com (2014).

  5. Berman has been in the forefront of the Modern Orthodox community in dealing with these challenges. See, for example, "Was There an Exodus?" Mosaic Magazine (2015).

  6. For more on Grumet’s views on the challenge of biblical criticism, see "The Questions with Rabbi Zvi Grumet," TheTorah.com (2013).

  7. May non-Orthodox Jews are still resistant to it, as see in the push-back Rabbi David Wolpe experienced in 2001 after delivering a sermon which questioned the historicity of the exodus. See a write up of the conflict in, "L.A. Rabbi Creates Furor by Questioning the Exodus Story," Jweekly (2001), and Wolpe’s reflections on this in, "The Challenge of Biblical Scholarship: One Conservative Rabbi's Perspective," TheTorah.com (2013).

  8. Over the years, I have had off the record conversations with many Orthodox rabbis who are both supportive of our efforts and benefit from our scholarship, but prefer to keep their sympathetic views under the radar.

  9. See Lawrence Grossman, "In What Sense Did Orthodoxy Believe the Torah to be Divine?" TheTorah.com (2015).

  10. See Maimonides, Guide of the Perplexed 3:29 (Pines translation, p. 521):

    All the books that I have mentioned to you are books of idolatry that have been translated into Arabic. But there is no doubt that they are but a very small part of this literature if compared to the writings that have not been translated and are not even extant, but have perished and been lost in the course of the years. However, the books extant among us today contain an exposition of the greatest part of the opinions and the practices of the Sabians; some of the latter are generally known at present in this world.