Does an Intentional Sinner Attain Atonement?

Leviticus 16 describes how the scapegoat ritual on Yom Kippur attains atonement for all of Israel’s sins, even acts of rebellion. Numbers 15, however, states that a person who sins unintentionally can bring an offering and be forgiven, but the person who sins intentionally is cut off from the people.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Does an Intentional Sinner Attain Atonement?." TheTorah.com, October 4, 2022. https://www.thetorah.com/article/does-an-intentional-sinner-attain-atonement.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Does an Intentional Sinner Attain Atonement?" (2022, October 4). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/does-an-intentional-sinner-attain-atonement

Does an Intentional Sinner Attain Atonement?

Aaron casting lots. Leviticus 16:8, Detail of East Window, Lincoln Cathedral. Flicker/Jules & Jenny cc 2.0

Published: October 4, 2022

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The verb pasha is used as synonymous with political rebellion, i.e., a people rebelling against a king or violating their loyalty oath to said king in 1 Kings 12:19 (Israel’s rebellion against Rehoboam); 2 Kings 1:1 (King Mesha of Moab’s rebellion against Joram), and 2 Kings 8:20 (Edom’s rebellion against Joram).

  2. Thus, according to Ps 51:5, the sinner is aware of his specific pesha, and, in Ps 32:5, he spells it out to God. In Micah 6:7 the Israelites consider the possibility of offering their firstborns in sacrifice to atone for their peshaim, which could hardly refer to misdemeanors.

  3. To be sure, the people are required on Yom Kippur to refrain from work and “afflict themselves.” But the import of this should not be overstated. What is required of the people is not, as Maimonides claimed with regard to repentance (Mishneh Torah, Book of Mada, “Laws of Repentance” 2:2), an expression of remorse over specific violations and a pledge to desist from them now and in the future, but only a general gesture of silent submission to God; see David A. Lambert, How Repentance Became Biblical: Judaism, Christianity, and the Interpretation of Scripture (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015), 28–30. Nor does the text lay down further prerequisites for atonement beyond this very basic and vague expectation.

  4. The text reads:

    במדבר טו:כד וְהָיָה אִם מֵעֵינֵי הָעֵדָה נֶעֶשְׂתָה לִשְׁגָגָה וְעָשׂוּ כָל הָעֵדָה פַּר בֶּן בָּקָר אֶחָד לְעֹלָה לְרֵיחַ נִיחֹחַ לַיהוָה וּמִנְחָתוֹ וְנִסְכּוֹ כַּמִּשְׁפָּט וּשְׂעִיר עִזִּים אֶחָד לְחַטָּת.
    Num 15:24 If this was done unwittingly, through the inadvertence of the community, the whole community shall present one bull of the herd as a burnt offering of pleasing odor to YHWH, with its proper meal offering and libation, and one he-goat as a sin offering.
    במדבר טו:כה וְכִפֶּר הַכֹּהֵן עַל כָּל עֲדַת בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל וְנִסְלַח לָהֶם כִּי שְׁגָגָה הִוא וְהֵם הֵבִיאוּ אֶת קָרְבָּנָם אִשֶּׁה לַי־הוָה וְחַטָּאתָם לִפְנֵי יְ־הוָה עַל שִׁגְגָתָם. טו:כו וְנִסְלַח לְכָל עֲדַת בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל וְלַגֵּר הַגָּר בְּתוֹכָם כִּי לְכָל הָעָם בִּשְׁגָגָה.
    Num 15:25 The priest shall make expiation for the whole Israelite community and they shall be forgiven; for it was an error, and for their error they have brought their offering, a gift offering to YHWH and their sin offering before YHWH. 15:26 The whole Israelite community and the stranger residing among them shall be forgiven, for it happened to the entire people through error.
  5. This view of exculpatory sacrifices appears in Leviticus 4–5 as well, where the chatat (sin offering) and asham (guilt offering) are described as being for unintentional sins. Editor’s note: For more on these sacrifices, see James W. Watts, “Leviticus’ Rhetorical Presentation of the Sin and Guilt Offerings,” TheTorah (2019).

  6. For Milgrom’s understanding of karet see Jacob Milgrom, Numbers, The JPS Torah Commentary (Philadelphia: JPS, 2004), 405–408.

  7. For his attempt to synthesize various Priestly texts on atonement within a single, coherent system see Jacob Milgrom, “The Priestly Doctrine of Repentance,” RB 82 (1975): 186–205. Milgrom suggests that the karet of Numbers 15:30–31 refers only to intentional sins committed in public, as a brazen and provocative display of rebellion and maintains that the case of Leviticus 5:20–26 supports this analysis. This text concerns a person who misappropriates another person’s property and lies about it in court under oath. Such a person, the text tells us, may step forward at any time, confess his act of theft, compensate the offended neighbor, and offer an asham sacrifice to God for his sin of perjury. Though his perjury is premediated, he is not barred from the sanctuary and subject to karet as ostensibly required by Numbers 15:30-31, because swearing falsely is not visibly sinful at the time that it is done. The perjurer’s decision to come clean and confess his intentional sin (cf. Numbers 5:5–8) converts it into an unintentional one, which can then be rectified through the presentation of a personal asham before the arrival of Yom Kippur. But the Numbers text makes no reference to a distinction between intentional sins done in public and intentional sins done in private, and this distinction should not be superimposed on it. Furthermore, the idea that confession transmutes an intentional sin into an inadvertent one is never expressed in any biblical text.; Milgrom has invented it to harmonize these two texts.

  8. For Qumran practice see Gary A. Anderson, “Intentional and Unintentional Sin in the Dead Sea Scrolls,” in David P. Wright et al eds., Pomegranates and Golden Bells: Studies in Biblical, Jewish, and Near Eastern Ritual, Law, and Literature in Honor of Jacob Milgrom (Winona Lake, Indiana: Eisenbrauns, 1995), 49—64. For karet as banishment see Tom Hobson, “Punitive Expulsion in the Ancient Near East,” ZAR 17 (2011), 1—18; G. Thomas Hobson, “KARATH as Punitive Expulsion,” in L. R. Lanzillotta and I. M. Gallarte, eds., Greeks, Jews, and Christians: Historical, Religious, and Philological Studies in Honor of Jesus Pelaez del Rosal (EFN 10; Cordoba: Ediciones El Almendro, n.d.), 67—90.

  9. See Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 1-20, Anchor Yale Bible (New York: Doubleday, 1993), 466.

  10. For close connection between banishment from sacred space and death, see Gen 3:23, where access to the “tree of life” is prevented, and Gen 4:14, where Cain’s removal from the protective presence of the deity into no man’s land makes his murder seem inevitable. See also 1 Samuel 26:19—20. The fact that David has been banished from YHWH’s domain and forced to take on the patronage of other gods apparently makes it possible for Saul to execute him.

  11. Elsewhere, I have argued that the rituals described in Leviticus 16 were not originally tied to a specific day, and that the connection to Yom Kippur (the tenth day of the seventh month) was a later addition. See, David Frankel, “Recasting the Temple Purification Ritual as the Yom Kippur Service,” TheTorah (2014). For the alternative view, that the chapter is all of a piece, see Baruch J. Schwartz, “Yom Ha-kippurim: The Biblical Significance,” TheTorah (2014).

  12. Note the connection between סליחה and the restoration of the divine-human relationship in Psalm 130:4: כי עמך הסליחה למען תורא, “Forgiveness is yours so that you will be worshipped.” The idea seems to be that it is in God’s interest to forgive his worshippers because that allows for the continuation of God being worshipped. See also 1 Kings 8:46–51.

  13. This is akin to God’s initial position in the story of the Garden of Eden with regard to the punishment for eating of the prohibited tree of knowledge. The punishment is presented as immediate death regardless of the inherent severity or triviality of the specific violation (which is not, after all, murder or idolatry).

  14. Other biblical texts similarly highlight certain commandments or covenant stipulations that are particularly important (e.g., Deut 27:15–26; Ezek 18; Ps 15), showing that hierarchy of sin is an accepted concept in many biblical texts. Numbers 15 is unusual in this regard. See my discussion in, David Frankel, “Mitzvah Piety and the Need for Individual Atonement,” TheTorah (2017).

  15. Ezekiel’s ideal vision is in keeping with this model. In one speech, the book claims that people can rid themselves of their sins without ritual mediation and can even radically transform themselves:

    יחזקאל יח:לא הַשְׁלִיכוּ מֵעֲלֵיכֶם אֶת כָּל פִּשְׁעֵיכֶם אֲשֶׁר פְּשַׁעְתֶּם בָּם וַעֲשׂוּ לָכֶם לֵב חָדָשׁ וְרוּחַ חֲדָשָׁה.
    Ezek 18:31 Throw away all your acts of rebellion and fashion for yourselves a new heart and a new spirit!

    Elsewhere, Ezekiel speaks of how God will personally purify Israel at some time in the future so that sin and rebellion will forever become a thing of the past (Ezek 36:25–27). What both texts have in common is the irrelevance of priestly ritual for dealing with intentional sin.

  16. Other passages that give expression to the inevitability of human sin include Gen 8:21; 1 Kings 8:46; Psalm 130:3; Job 15:14–16.

  17. Mishneh Torah, Book of Mada, “Laws of Teshuva,” 1:1.

  18. For a similar view see Gen 6:5; 8:21. Interestingly, while the first text expresses the idea that the proper response to humanity’s evil is destruction, the second expresses the idea that destruction is inappropriate.

  19. For the rootedness of כפרה in the conception of sin as a concrete reality that must be physically removed from the environs of the deity see the classic study of Jacob Milgrom, “Israel’s Sanctuary: The Priestly Picture of Dorian Gray,” RB 83 (1976): 390–399.

  20. Hence, sojourners are included among the participants.

  21. Editor’s note: For more on how this ritual works, see Noga Ayali-Darshan, “The Scapegoat Ritual and Its Ancient Near Eastern Parallels,” TheTorah (2020).

  22. For an analysis of this rite see Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1-16 (AB 3; New York: Doubleday, 1991), 1041–1045.

  23. See, for example, Leviticus 20:4-5, where failure of the community to execute the Molech worshipper results in divine punishment upon his entire clan.

  24. This point is further indicated by the fact that the text fails to present God as the one bestowing atonement to the people. Contrast Rabbi Akiva, who declared:

    משנה יומא ח:ט אשריכם ישראל, לפני מי אתם מטהרין, ומי מטהר אתכם, אביכם שבשמים.
    m. Yoma 8:9 Happy are you, O Israel! Before whom are you purified? Who purifies you? Your heavenly father!”

    The biblical verse, however, contains no subject to the pivotal verb יְכַפֵּר, “atonement shall be made for you”:

    ויקרא טז:ל כִּי בַיּוֹם הַזֶּה יְכַפֵּר עֲלֵיכֶם לְטַהֵר אֶתְכֶם מִכֹּל חַטֹּאתֵיכֶם לִפְנֵי יְ־הוָה תִּטְהָרוּ.

    Lev 16:30 For on this day atonement shall be made for you to cleanse you of all your sins; you will be cleansed before YHWH.

    The verb is in the passive, hinting that not God but the priest effects atonement. Similarly, the “purification” takes place לִפְנֵי יְ־הוָה, “before God,” but not by God.

  25. See the classic study of Moshe Weinfeld, “המגמה האוניברסליסטית והמגמה הבדלנית ובשיבת ציון” [Universalism and Particularism in the Period of Exile and Restoration], Tarbiz 33 (1964), 228–242, and more recently, Joseph Blenkinsopp, Judaism, the First Phase: The Place of Ezra and Nehemiah in the Origins of Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2009). Editor’s note: For some specific discussions on differences between communities in this period, see Sara Japhet, “Survival and Revival: Megillat Esther and Ezra-Nehemiah,” TheTorah (2015); Isaac S.D. Sassoon, “The Tabernacle: A Post-Exilic Polemic Against Rebuilding the Temple,” TheTorah (2018); Attila Marossy, “Between Holy and Mundane: The Development of the Term Havdalah,” TheTorah (2022).

  26. Translation from James C. Vanderkam, The Book of Jubilees, Corpus Scriptorum Christianorum Orientalium 511 / Scriptores Aethiopici 88 (Leuven: Peeters, 1989), 34.

  27. The rabbinic understanding of this verse is the opposite of its simple meaning. See discussion in Zev Farber, “Does YHWH Remit Punishment?” TheTorah (2018).

  28. Mishneh Torah, Book of Mada, “Laws of Teshuvah,” ch. 1.