by anshie.com
Four Ways to Derive the Thirty-Nine Avot Melakhot
The Torah never defines specifically what, melakha, labor, on Shabbat entails, but the Mishnah already has an exact list of 39 categories of labor prohibited on Shabbat. A comparison of the structure of the Yerushalmi and Bavli sugyot highlight the different ways the Amoraim conceptualized melakha in contrast to the Mishnah.
Published: March 22, 2017
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
I would like to thank the editors at TheTorah.com as well as Samuel Berkovitz for their helpful comments and corrections.
In previous posts to TheTorah.com, my teacher Rabbi Dr. Yoel Bin Bun and Rabbi Evan Hoffman have offered learned analyses of the origins of thirty-nine principle labors (avot melakhot) that are prohibited on Shabbat. Rabbi Bin Nun, “The Textual Source for the 39 Melachot of Shabbat,” and Rabbi Hoffman, “The Melachot of Shabbat Are 40 minus 1: Cracking the Rabbinic Code” My piece will be in conversation with theirs.
וְי֙וֹם֙ הַשְּׁבִיעִ֔֜י שַׁבָּ֣֖ת׀ לַי-הֹוָ֣ה אֱ-לֹהֶ֑֔יךָ לֹֽ֣א־תַעֲשֶׂ֣֨ה כָל־מְלָאכָ֡֜ה
Exod. 20:10. All biblical translations are from NJPS.
Ibid. 31:14 and 25:2.
Exod. 16:22-29.
Num. 15:32-36. Interpreters provide various explanations for the precise Sabbath violation involved in this pericope. Philo, Moses 2.220, writes that gathering wood connects to the act of making a fire and furthermore that one may not move wood. See further at Samuel Belkin, Philo and the Oral Law: The Philonic Interpretation of Biblical Law in Relation to the Palestinian Halakah (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1968), 198; and Lawrence Schiffman, The Halakhah at Qumran (Leiden: Brill, 1975), 118. Onkelos translates the prohibited act as binding, while Targum Pseudo-Jonathan accuses the sinner of uprooting trees. Similarly, B. Shabbat 96b records suggestions by various rabbis that the wood gatherer was guilty of detaching the branches from the trees, of carrying the wood in public domain, or of tying them up into bundles. See also Yitzhak D. Gilat, Studies in the Development of the Halakha (Jerusalem: Bar-Ilan University Press, 1992) (Hebrew), 33 n. 9; and idem, “Introduction: The Sabbath in the Bible,” in Yad la-Talmud: Selected Chapters, ed. E. E. Urbach (Jerusalem: 1984), 47; and the TABS essay, “What Melacha did the Wood-Gatherer Violate?”
Exod. 35:3.
Exod. 34:21.
Exod. 20:10, 23:12, Deut. 5:14.
Amos 8:5 and Isa. 58:13.
Jer. 17:21-22. Neh. 10:32 and 13:15-23 mentions also buying food and wares as well as pressing wine and loading animals. On the biblical Sabbath prohibitions, see further at Gilat, Studies, 33; and idem, “Introduction,” 45-51; Admiel Kosman, “On the History of the Category of ‘Ovadin DeChol’ and Yom-tov and its Relationship to the Category of ‘Shevut’ Prohibitions,” (Hebrew; PhD diss., Bar-Ilan University, 1993), 9-12; and Gerhard F. Hasel and W.G.C. Murdoch, “The Sabbath in the Prophetic and Historical Literature of the Old Testament,” in The Sabbath in Scripture and History, eds. Kenneth Albert Strand and Daniel Andre Augsburger, (USA, 1982), 44-56.
This follows ms. Parma; see the insightful analysis of Michal Bar-Asher Siegal, “Mountains Hanging by a Strand? Re-reading Mishnah Hagiga 1:8,” Journal of Ancient Judaism 4 (2013), 235-256.
הלכות שבת חגיגות והמעילות הרי הם כהררים (כחררים) התלויין בשערה שהן מקרא מועט והלכות מרובות
For the prohibitions in the category of shevut, see Richard Hidary, “’One May Come to Repair Musical Instruments’: Rabbinic Authority and the History of the Shevut Laws,”Jewish Studies, an Internet Journal (forthcoming).
Gilat, Studies, 39-43. (Professor Yitzhak D. Gilat (1919-1997) was a Professor of Talmud at Bar-Ilan University. He studied in Lithuanian Yeshivot and in Yeshivat Hevron in Jerusalem and graduated from the Hebrew University. He served as guest professor at Tel-Aviv University, at Yeshiva University in New York and at the Shechter Rabbinical Seminary in the United States. He published many books and articles in the field of Talmudic literature and history of the halakha.) See also Rabbi Bin Nun’s discussion of R. Eliezer as well as Rabbi Hoffman’s insightful discussion and his citation from Midrash Lekach Tov.
See ibid., 36-39.
בן זומא כשראה אוכלסין בהר הבית או’ ברוך מי שברא את אלו לשמשני כמה יגע אדם הראשון ולא טעם לוגמה אחת עד שזר’ וחרש וקצר ועמר ודש וזרה וברר וטחן והרקיד ולש ואפה ואחר כך אכל ואני עומד בשחרית ומוצא אני את כל אילו לפני כמה יגע אדם הראשון ולא לבש חלוק עד שגזז ולבן ונפס וצבע וטווה וארג ואחר כך לבש ואני עומד בשחרית ומוצא את כל אילו לפני כמה אומניות שוקדות ומשכימות ואני עומד בשחרית ומוצא כל אילו לפני
See also Y. Shekalim 5, 1 (48c), and ibid., 42.
B. Shabbat 74b and Y. Shabbat 7:2, 10b.
See Gilat, Studies, 35 n. 15, citing R. Eliezer of Metz, “Scripture left it up to the sages [to determine that] these are fitting to be called melakha.”
Abraham Goldberg, Commentary to the Mishna Shabbat (Jerusalem: Jewish Theological Seminary of America, 1976) (Hebrew), 137; and Shmuel Safrai and Ze’ev Safrai, Mishnat Eretz Israel (Jerusalem: E.M. Liphshitz College Publishing House, 2008), 259. For this reason, I would not accept Rabbi Hoffman’s suggestion that this number is chosen to relate it to forty-less-one lashes. I do agree, however, that the rabbis enacted great leniencies in the Shabbat laws compared to Second Temple sectarian interpretations. See further at Hidary, “‘One May Come to Repair Musical Instruments.’”
ויאמר אליהם אלה הדברים וגו’. רבי אומר, להביא שלשים ותשע אבות המלאכות שאמר להם משה על פה
See comment at I. H. Weiss, Mekhilta (Wien: Buchdruckerei Von Jacob Schlossberg, 1865), 111.
Section F in the table below.
Perhaps an original version of the Bavli had only the wording of the Mekhilta without “דברים, הדברים.” But even without this conjecture, these midrashim may simply be pointing out the superfluity of the words אלה הדברים so as to understand why Rabbi would find in them an allusion to an oral teaching by Moshe. See also Rabbi Bin Nun’s article and the next note.
Midrash ha-Gadol is a 14th cent. C.E. Yemenite anthology that includes much ancient material that has been otherwise lost.
I disagree, however, that this derivation is more original than any of the others or that this is the original meaning of the Mekhilta and its parallels at B. Shabbat 70a and 97b (see the previous note) or of R. Hanina bar Hama in B. Shabbat 49b. The meaning of R. Hanina bar Hama’s statement is clearly explicated at the end of the sugya as belonging to the fourth strategy of deriving the avot from the types of work activities performed in the mishkan; see further analysis below for strategy IV.
See further discussion below and in Rabbi Bin Nun’s article.
See Lea Himmelfarb, “The Identity of the First Masoretes,” Sefarad 67, no. 1 (2007), 37-50.
See references at Gilat, Studies, 34 n. 12.
This explanation does not sit well with the manuscript evidence since no manuscript or early printing includes מלאכתו in the list of what to count. Nevertheless, there is enough confusion in the textual transmission reflected in the many textual variants to warrant a proposal that attempts to reconstruct a lost original formulation. See variants below, n. 37.
For an enumeration, see Saul Lieberman, Ha-Yerushalmi ki-fshuto (Jerusalem: Hotsa’at Darom, 1934), 128, citing Israel Elnecave, Menorat Hama’or (New York, 1843), 3:603-604.
Gilat, Studies, 34.
See Goldberg, Commentary to the Mishna Shabbat, 243 and 38 n. 10; and Safrai and Safrai, Mishnat Eretz Israel, 352.
Y. Shabbat 7, 2 (9b-10d). For the last instance, Ed. Venice reads, “mikdash,” but this does not fit the context; see parallel at Y. Shabbat 12, 1 (13c), which reads, “mishkan.”
Translation based on Jacob Neusner, ed., The Talmud of the Land of Israel: A Preliminary Translation and Explanation, 35 vols. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1982).
Translation based on Isidore Epstein, ed., Babylonian Talmud (Soncino Press, 1971).
See Leib Moscovitz, Talmudic Reasoning: From Casuistics to Conceptualization(Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2002); and Hidary, “‘One May Come to Repair Musical Instruments.’”
T. Beṣah 2:18; Mekhilta De-R. Shimon bar Yoḥai 12:16; and see Gilat, Studies, 53 n. 100.
B. Betzah 13b and see Gilat, Studies, 48-59, who shows that various other conditions that are only implicit in the Mishnah and explained to some degree in the Yerushalmi are only fully conceptualized and applied in the Bavli.
On the conceptual and textual linkage between Shabbat and the mishkan generally, see Nehama Leibowitz, New Studies in Shemot (Ha’omanim, 1995), 471-86; and Moshe Shamah,Recalling the Covenant: A Contemporary Commentary on the Five Books of the Torah(Jersey City: Ktav, 2011), 462-63 and 501-3.
Text from MSS Cambridge – Westminster College G.F. Talmudica II 2. Major variants are indicated in the notes.
MSS Oxford 366, Munich 95, and Ed. Soncino add “bar Hama.”
MS Oxford 366 reads, “מלאכה ומלאכת.” MS Munich 95 reads, “מלאכה ומלאכות.” MS Vatican 108 reads, “מלאכה ומלאכה.” Eds. Soncino and Venice reads, “מלאכה מלאכתן ומלאכות.” Ed. Vilna reads, “מלאכה מלאכתו ומלאכת.” See discussion above.
MS Oxford 366 also reads, “מיבעיא.” MS Munich 95 has, “מסתפקא,” MS Vatican 108 has, “מיסתפקא,” and Ed. Soncino reads, “מספקא.”
MS Vatican 108 also reads, “ויבא הביתה,” but it is omitted in MSS Oxford 366, Munich 95, and Ed. Soncino.
Lieberman, Ha-Yerushalmi ki-fshuto, 128, cites an alternate version that makes this line similar to B. Shabbat 70a and 97b, cited above.
All other witnesses omit, “כיצד.”