Photo courtesy of The Louis Jacobs Foundation
Louis Jacobs: We Have Reason to Believe
Rabbi Dr. Louis Jacobs, voted “the greatest British Jew,” is best-known for his 1957 book that denied traditional notions of Torah min HaShamayim, the divine origin of the Torah. The resulting controversy still reverberates today.
Published: June 15, 2020
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
This essay is based on our forthcoming book on the history of the Jewish reception of critical biblical scholarship. An excellent source on Jacobs is Elliot Joe Cosgrove, “Teyku: The Insoluble Contradictions in the Life and Thought of Louis Jacobs,” Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Chicago, 2008. Many documents relating to Jacobs are at https://louisjacobs.org.
The same pattern pertained at the Hildesheimer Rabbinical Seminary, whose students studied for the Ph.D. at the University of Berlin.
Louis Jacobs, Helping With Inquiries: An Autobiography (London: Vallentine Mitchell, 1989).
Jacobs, Helping With Inquiries, 107 and Cosgrove, “Teyku,” 132–133.
We Have Reason to Believe: Some Aspects of Modern Jewish Theology Examined in the Light of Modern Thought (London: Vallentine Mitchell, 1957), 60. Jacobs’s polemic against colleagues who would simply ignore the issue had already been voiced four decades earlier by Rev Joshua Abelson, a fellow Jewish minister whose writing he cited approvingly. See Abelson, “Bible Problems and Modern Knowledge,” Jewish Review 3 (1913) 479.
We Have Reason to Believe, 69.
This is among the many important contributions of Cosgrove, Teiku (see esp. 177-178), whose dissertation moved beyond seeing Jacobs in relation to Anglo Jewry. For an early essay on liberal supernaturalism, see his “Liberal Supernaturalism” in Varieties of Jewish Belief, ed. Ira Eisenstein (New York: Reconstructionist Press, 1966): 109-122.
We Have Reason to Believe, 81.
Ibid., 64.
Epstein’s attitude toward biblical criticism, for example, was very much in line with Hertz; see Isidore Epstein, The Faith of Judaism: An Interpretation for Our Times (London: Soncino, 1954), 112-113, where he expresses his doubts concerning the documentary hypothesis, and claims that the Bible is confirmed by archeology. See also his critique of Ben-Gurion’s views of the Bible in The Jewish Chronicle June 3, 1960, p. 19, which opens with his discussion of the “fundamental errors of the critical method.”
Some evidence suggests that his appointment included the proviso that he not teach Bible.
This affair was so significant that it was sometimes called “l’affaire Jacobs,” as if to suggest that it was as momentous as the earlier “l’affaire Dreyfus”!
See the Jewish Chronicle, January 5 1962, p. 8. Brodie’s equally evasive statement regarding Jacobs’s “published views” was reported in the Jewish Chronicle, May 11, 1962.
These criticisms were often disingenuous: In some instances, Hertz quotes scholarly positions out of context, in others, he suggested that Christian and Jewish scholars who articulated anti-Wellhausean arguments were traditionalists, when in fact they adopted other non-traditional approaches.
Available at https://booksof.louisjacobs.org/articles/the-sanction-for-the-mitzwoth/?highlight=mitzwoth.
Some earlier traditional rabbis were willing to entertains similar claims about Nevi’im and Ketuvim, but not about the Torah.
This is how the new synagogue is described in advertisements in the Jewish Chronicle (e.g. May 8, 1964, p. 12) and elsewhere. The founding of this synagogue that upheld Orthodox practices is seen, in retrospect only, as a break from the Orthodox world, and the beginning of the creation of the Masorti (traditional) movement in England, which would eventually ally itself with the Conservative movement in the U.S.
Jewish Chronicle May 8, 1964. This issue, and subsequent issues, also have a number of articles and letters to the editor representing many different angles. The statement was also published as a separate pamphlet: Statement by the Very Rev. the Chief Rabbi Dr. Israel Brodie to a Meeting of Rabbis and Ministers of the Anglo-Jewish Community Delivered at the Adolph Tuck Hall on 5th May 1964 – 23 Iyar 5724 (London: n.p., 1964). The page numbers in the following note refer to this edition.
Ibid., 4, 5, 6, 8. In its original context, the word torah in this verse refers to the following material in Deuteronomy; in Judaism, especially when recited during hagbah (the opening and raising of the Torah toward the conclusion of the Torah service), it is taken to mean the entire Torah.
See Miri J. Freud-Kandel, Orthodox Judaism in Britain Since 1913: An Ideology Forsaken (Portland, OR: Vallentine Mitchell, 2006) , 123-157; Benjamin J. Elton, Britain’s Chief Rabbis and the Religious Character of Anglo-Jewry, 1880-1970 (Manchester: Manchester Univ. Press, 2009), esp. 242–258; Sefton Temkin, “A Crisis in Anglo-Jewry,” Conservative Judaism 18 (Fall 1963), 18-34; Ignaz Maybaum, “The Jacobs Affair: Crisis in Anglo-Jewry,” Judaism 13 (1964), 471–478; and Norman Cohen, “The Religious Crisis in Anglo-Jewry,” Tradition 8/2 (Summer 1966), 40–57. Much additional material, may be found at https://louisjacobs.org; primary material is at https://louisjacobs.org/the-jacobs-affair/primary-sources/
See The Jewish Chronicle Oct. 29, 1961 and Nov. 3, 1961. This lecture later served as part of the basis of the book he wrote with Raphael Patai, Hebrew Myths: The Book of Genesis (Garden City: Doubleday & Company, Inc., 1964). Although condemned by many in the Jewish community, Graves, was both philosemitic and pro-Zionistic; see Shalom Goldman, “White Goddess, Hebrew Goddess: The Bible, the Jews, and Poetic Myth in the Work of Robert Graves,” Modern Judaism 23.1 (2003): 32–50. Jacobs refers approvingly to Graves’s views in “Faith and Reason: A Modern View,” Jewish Heritage (Spring 1963), available at https://booksof.louisjacobs.org/articles/faith-reason-modern-view/.
The Affair was covered in the North American Jewish newspapers as well.
See especially the controversy around the 1963 publication of Honest To God by the Anglican Bishop John A. T. Robinson.
London: Vallentine Mitchell, 1964; see esp. 216-301.
Ibid., 271.
Ibid., 218-219, 242, 248, 245.
Louis Jacobs, Beyond Reasonable Doubt (London: Littman Library of Jewish Civilization, 1999), 44.
See e.g. Beyond Reasonable Doubt, 237-238.
Dan Cohn-Sherbok, Issues in Contemporary Judaism (Hampshire: Macmillan, 1991), 31-37. Sacks, the most influential chief-rabbi since Hertz, was conservative on matters concerning revelation and biblical criticism. The antagonism toward Jacobs continued in more petty matters as well, e.g. when the London Beth Din prevented the 83 year old Louis Jacobs from being called to the Torah on the occasion of his grandson’s bar mitzvah (see https://www.jta.org/2003/09/08/archive/british-jews-fighting-after-rabbi-doesnt-get-called-to-torah).
Chaim Waxman, “Halakhic Change Vs. Demographic Change: American Orthodoxy, British Orthodoxy, and the Plight of Louis Jacobs,” Journal of Modern Jewish Studies 14 (2015), 58-71; Marc B. Shapiro, “Is Modern Orthodoxy Moving Towards an Acceptance of Biblical Criticism,” Modern Judaism 37/2 (May 2017), 165-193; see esp. 165; and Adam S. Ferziger, “Fluidity and Bifurcation: Critical Biblical Scholarship and Orthodox Judaism in Israel and North America,” Modern Judaism 39/3 (2019), 233-270; see esp. p. 236.
See the bibliography at: https://louisjacobs.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/LJ-bibliography-online-1.pdf. See also the festschrift honoring him: Dan Cohn-Sherbok, A Traditional Quest: Essays in Honour of Louis Jacobs, JSOTSup 114 (Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 1991).
Jonathan Wittenberg, European Judaism, 39 no 2 (Winter 2006), 160-169.
Teiku, 344.