Marrying Your Daughter to Her Rapist

Are the Torah’s laws perfect or do they reflect biblical times and can adapt as society develops? The punishment of a rapist is a good test case for thinking about morally problematic biblical laws.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Marrying Your Daughter to Her Rapist." TheTorah.com, September 4, 2014. https://www.thetorah.com/article/marrying-your-daughter-to-her-rapist.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Marrying Your Daughter to Her Rapist" (2014, September 4). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/marrying-your-daughter-to-her-rapist

Published: September 4, 2014

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. For example, see R. Dr. David Tzvi Hoffmann’s gloss on Genesis 1:9 (p. 31 in the Hebrew edition).

  2. See her discussion in part 19 of her TABS essay, “Orthodoxy and the Challenge of Biblical Criticism.“ See also her interview for the Kavvanah website. See also her application of these views to the question of ethics in the Torah in her book, Expanding the Palace of Torah (Brandeis, 2004), which deals with the place of women in the Torah and Judaism.

  3. For other critiques of the dictation model, see the TABS essays “Making Sense of the Revelation at Sinai: Revisiting Maimonides’ Eighth Principle of Faith” by Prof. Sam Fleischacker, “I shall Fear God Alone and not Show Favor in Torah: A Conceptual Foundation for Wrestling with Biblical Criticism”by R. David Bigman, and “‘The Lord Spoke to Moses’ – Does God Speak?” by Dr. Baruch Schwartz.

  4. I discuss this approach in part four of “Torah Min HaShamayim: A Guide to the Four Questions.”

  5. The fact that the law reflects a patriarchal society that both objectifies the girl and makes her decisions for her is clear, but is this a fair critique? After all, the Torah is not creating a chauvinistic society, but it is itself a product of such a society. Stating that a premodern law code is patriarchal is to judge it by anachronistic standards.

  6. A piece like this is not the place for a detailed study of Israelite society. For some studies on the topic, see: J. David Schloen, The House of the Father as Fact and Symbol: Patrimonialism in Ugarit and the Ancient Near East (Studies in the Archaeology and History of the Levant, 2; Eisenbrauns, 2001); Avraham Faust, The Archaeology of Israelite Society in Iron Age II (Eisenbrauns, 2012); Hanoch Raviv, The Elders in Ancient Israel: A Study of a Biblical Institution (Magnes, 1992); Roland De Vaux,Ancient Israel: Its Life and Institutions (Eerdmans, 1997 [original French, 1958]). For study specifically about the dowry and bride price, see Tracy Maria Lemos, Marriage Gifts and Social Change in Ancient Palestine: 1200 BCE to 200 CE (Cambridge University Press, 2010).

  7. Here is the full text:

    If a man forcibly seizes and rapes a maiden who is residing in her father’s house, […] who is not betrothed (?), whose [womb?] is not opened, who is not married, and against whose father’s house there is no outstanding claim–whether within the city or in the countryside or at night, whether in the main thoroughfare, or in a granary, or during the city festival—the father of the maiden shall take the wife of the fornicator of the maiden and hand her over to be raped; he shall not return her to her husband, but he shall take (and keep?) her; the father shall give his daughter who is the victim of fornication into the protection of the household of her fornicator. If he (the fornicator) has no wife, the fornicator shall give “triple” the silver as the value of the maiden to her father; her fornicator shall marry her; he shall not (reject?) her. If the father does not desire it so, he shall receive “triple” silver for the maiden, and he shall give his daughter to whomever he chooses.

    Translated by Martha T. Roth, in Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor (SBL Writings from the Ancient World Series; SBL, 1995). Note: In Luckenbill’s translation this is law #54.

  8. Levavi Feinstein does note that Deuteronomy leaves out any possibility of retaliation by raping the rapist’s wife, an important difference that demonstrates that Deuteronomy does not see women as men’s chattel in all ways.

  9. The value of the Torah, in my opinion, is intrinsic not comparative. In other words, our job is to try to understand the laws of the Torah and what they were meant to accomplish, not to try to prove that a given law was better than any alternatives that may have existed. Comparative study is important because it allows modern readers access to the world in which the Torah was written and its laws practiced. Sometimes there are differences with contemporary alternatives, sometimes similarities. These should be studied, of course, but not as an attempt at triumphalism, to prove the Torah is “better,” but as a way of better understanding the Torah and what its authors were trying to accomplish.

  10. Within reason and ethical boundaries, of course.