Questioning God’s Call: Moses Versus Gideon

Moses and Gideon are each called upon to deliver Israel from its enemies, and each poses questions in response. And yet, a close comparison of the stories demonstrates a sharp contrast between the two characters; surprisingly, Gideon is more faithful than Moses.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Questioning God’s Call: Moses Versus Gideon." TheTorah.com, January 15, 2020. https://www.thetorah.com/article/questioning-gods-call-moses-versus-gideon.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Questioning God’s Call: Moses Versus Gideon" (2020, January 15). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/questioning-gods-call-moses-versus-gideon

Questioning God’s Call: Moses Versus Gideon

Scenes from the Life of Gideon and Moses and the Burning Bush, Master of James IV of Scotland, c. 1510-1520. Getty

Categories:

Shemot

Published: January 15, 2020

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Editor’s note: For more on Isaiah 6, see Marvin A. Sweeney, “When the God of Justice Goes Rogue,” TheTorah (2016); Richard Lederman, “The Seraphim,” TheTorah (2019). For more on Ezekiel 1, see, Carl Ehrlich, “Ezekiel's Vision of God and the Chariot,” TheTorah (2019).

  2. For example, the revelations to Abraham in Genesis 12 and Jacob in Genesis 28 have aspects of the call narrative. For a reading of Genesis 37 as a kind of call narrative for Joseph, see Jason Tron, “Joseph: The Making of a Prophet,” TheTorah (2017).

  3. Norman Habel, “The Form and Significance of the Call Narratives,” ZAW 77 (1965): 297–323; Klaus Baltzer, “Considerations Regarding the Office and Calling of the Prophet,” HTR 61 (1968): 567–581; Brevard Childs, The Book of Exodus: A Critical and Theological Commentary,” OTL (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1974), 53–60; J. O. Akao, “Biblical Call Narratives: An investigation into the Underlying Structures,” Ogbomoso Journal of Theology (1993): 1–11; Gregory T. K. Wong, “Gideon: A New Moses,” in Reflection and Refraction: Studies in Biblical Historiography in Honour of A. Graeme Auld (Leiden: Brill, 2006), 529–545.

  4. Exodus 3:11 and 4:10 likely stem from the same source (E). However, the point stands even if they do not, since I am focusing on the rhetoric employed in the chapter as a whole.

  5. A loaded question presumes a negative answer, to which an addressee refuses to acknowledge. Adina Moshavi, “Can a Positive Rhetorical Question have a Positive Answer in the Bible?” Journal of Semitic Studies 56 (2011): 253–273 [p. 263].

  6. The insincerity of Moses’ question may be supported by the context of this same interrogative phrase in its other occurrences in the Bible. In 1 Samuel 18, David responds to Saul’s offer of his daughter in marriage with the question,

    שמואל א יח:יח מִ֤י אָֽנֹכִי֙ וּמִ֣י חַיַּ֔י מִשְׁפַּ֥חַת אָבִ֖י בְּיִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל כִּֽי־אֶהְיֶ֥ה חָתָ֖ן לַמֶּֽלֶךְ
    1 Sam. 18:18 Who am I and who are my kinsfolk, my father's family in Israel, that I should be son-in-law to the king?

    David’s humility is disingenuous because immediately prior, the text recounts how he routs the Philistines and is marched by Israelites singing his praises. David would thus expect the king to bestow such an honor on his military champion. Moses’ question is disingenuous but in a different way. Moses does believe he is a poor speaker, but this means that he is not truly searching for an answer from God. Importantly, neither Saul nor God answer this question posed by their addressees, likely because it is not sincere. Rather, both instances of the “Who am I?” question appear to function as a rhetorical device to highlight the success of those supported by God. Saul comes to realize that David’s success derives from God, who now stands with David instead of him. Similarly, with Moses’ question, the narrator introduces the idea that Moses succeeds on account of God alone.

  7. Editor’s note, for an argument that this verse is supplementary and that God’s name is revealed in v. 15, see Zev Farber, "How Does God Answer the Question: 'What Is Your Name?'" TheTorah (2017). For an argument that the verse is a popular etymology and that the name YHWH is not related to the Hebrew root ה.י.ה/ה.ו.י, see Israel Knohl, “YHWH: The Original Arabic Meaning of the Name,” TheTorah (2018).

  8. This is an example of a conducive question. A conducive question demands answers an answer that the questioner has already predicted. Moshavi, “Can a Positive Rhetorical Question,” 263.

  9. Deena Grant, Divine Anger in the Hebrew Bible, Catholic Biblical Quarterly Monograph Series 52 (Washington DC: The Catholic Biblical Association of America, 2014).

  10. The chapter alternately refers to Gideon’s interlocutor as a malʾakh of YHWH and as YHWH. To explain this variation in the use of the term malʾakh, Benjamin Sommers “understand[s] an angel as a small-scale manifestation of God or even as a being with whom Yhwh’s self overlaps.” Benjamin Sommer, The Bodies of God and the World of Ancient Israel (New York: Cambridge, 2009), 43.

  11. LXX reads “angel of the LORD” (ὁ ἄγγελος κυρίου) here and in v. 16. Note that even in MT, some of the verses return to “angel of YHWH” (vv. 21–22) and in one case “angel of God” (v. 20)

  12. The word is a homonym. Here it means something like “Oh,” however, it can also function as a first person prepositional suffix meaning “with me.”

  13. Detecting the formal structure that underpins biblical calls and, in turn, how a given call emphasizes or underplays various elements therein, has proven quite helpful in identifying the distinct aims of each call narrative. However, form criticism provides only “limited assistance in deciphering a given call narrative” because the interrelationship of the various commission accounts “may owe as much to intertextual influence as to reliance on a hypothetical Urform.” George Savran, “Theophany as a Type Scene,” Prooftexts: A Journal of Jewish Literary History 23/2 (2003): 119-49. For an argument that the Gideon story is working directly with the Moses narrative, see Hava Shalom-Guy, “The Call Narratives of Gideon And Moses: Literary Convention Or More,” Journal of Hebrew Scriptures 11 (2011): 1–19 [9–10].

Related Topics:Moses