Revelation and Authority: Author’s Presentation
Published: January 4, 2017
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
In the blessing before the Torah reading, one affirms that God “gave us His Torah” (נתן לנו את תורתו).
A word on terminology to keep things clear: In this essay, I use the word Pentateuch to refer to the חומש (the Five Books of Moses). When I use the word Torah, I use it not in the narrow sense of the Pentateuch but in its broad sense of sacred Jewish religious teaching generally. Thus, the Pentateuch is one work of Torah; so are the Mishnah, the Shulḥan Arukh, books by Abraham Joshua Heschel, and homilies by Yitzchok Hutner. Indeed, it is my hope–and even my belief–that this website is a work of Torah in this broad sense.
Scholarship refers to this approach as dialogical theology. Good examples of their writings on this issue include Abraham Joshua Heschel, God in Search of Man. A Philosophy of Judaism (New York: Farrar Straus and Giroux, 1955); Heavenly Torah as Refracted Through the Generations, ed. and trans. Gordon Tucker (New York: Continuum, 2005; Hebrew original: Torah min Hashamayim B’aspaqlarya shel Hadorot, 3 vols. [London and New York: Soncino and the Jewish Theological Seminary, 1965 and 1990]); Franz Rosenzweig, On Jewish Learning, ed. Nahum N. Glatzer (New York: Schocken Books, 1965); Louis Jacobs, Beyond Reasonable Doubt (London: Littman Library of Jewish Civilization, 1999).
See Yochanan Silman, Qol Gadol Velo Yasaf: Torat Yisrael Bein Shleimut Lehishtalmut (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1999); Tamar Ross, Expanding the Palace of Torah: Orthodoxy and Feminism (Waltham: Brandeis University Press, 2005). On these themes in the work of Rav Kook and Rav Hutner, see David Bigman, “A Ladder Upon the Earth, Whose Top Reaches the Heavens,” Conversations: The Journal of the Institute for Jewish Ideas and Ideals 11 (2011): 1–18, and, for Hutner’s relevant homily, see the third Chanukkah derashah in his Paḥad Yitshak Kuntres Ve-Zot Hanukah (Brooklyn: Gur Aryeh, 1964).
That is, the עשרת הדברות, often referred to (especially by Christians) as the Ten Commandments.
This becomes evident when we examine five consistent and deliberate ambiguities in Exodus 19-20; a detailed description of the ambiguities and the interpretive reasoning behind this interpretation is found in my book, pp. 30–53. For a brief summary of some of the ambiguities and their interpretive effect, see the section, “Three Textual Ambiguities” in my TABS essay, “The Source Critic and the Religious Interpreter.”
For a defense of this reading, see my book, pp. 64–72.
The P source puts less emphasis on this issue that E and D, but when it does address it, it shows a marked affinity for the participatory approach.
For details, see my book, pp. 75–95. For a brief summary, see the section, “The Differing Views of Revelation among the Sages,” in my TABS essay, “The Source Critic and the Religious Interpreter.”
Most of my book focuses on biblical predecessors of later Jewish views of revelation. Another biblical predecessor for later forms of Judaism I discuss involves Jewish mysticism. Insofar as we follow the great Israeli scholar Moshe Idel in defining kabbalah as a set of ritual practices designed to affect God and especially to bring God down into this world, it follows that the Pentateuch’s P document is the first kabbalistic work, since its ritual program as laid out in Leviticus is designed to allow the immanence (in the משכן) of the transcendent God. To follow this theme more fully, see the references to “theurgy” in my book’s index. On biblical predecessors (in P, J, and E) of kabbalistic understandings of God’s nature, see my earlier book, The Bodies of God and the World of Ancient Israel (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2009), 38–57, 129–32.
In his review of the book in the Israeli newspaper Haaretz, Hillel Ben-Sasson refers to me as a איקנוקלסט שמרן — a conservative iconoclast, which I think gets my combination of tradition theology and untraditional method just right.
I also discuss this in my TABS essay, “The Centrality of Law.“ In more detail, see the book, pp. 99–146 and 241–51.
For more on this, see my TABS essay, “The Source Critic and the Religious Interpreter.”In more detail, see the book, pp. 122–27.
E and P hint that the revelation of the law may not have occurred in language, while D insists that God spoke human-type words to Moses.
E and D maintain that the law was given in one or two moments at Mount Horeb, always through Moses’ intermediation (other than for the Decalogue; for D the whole people heard the whole Decalogue directly from God, while E allows that possibility but does not confirm it). For P, revelation of the law was a lengthy process, involving multiple mediators over the forty years of wandering, and arguably to some degree also before and after that era.
D requires us to boil the offering; P requires us to roast it, and specifically not to boil it. See Robert Harris’ TABS essay, “The Cow that Laid an Egg (!) – Korban Chagigah: From the Torah to the Seder Plate.”.
For E, this right only applies to Hebrew male slaves. D extends it to female Hebrew slaves as well. See Zev Farber’s TABS essay at “The Law of the Hebrew Slave: Exodus, Leviticus, and Deuteronomy.”
See the book, 147–87 , esp. 151–61.
The connection between the malleability of the law and the participatory theology is especially evident in the P source of the Pentateuch, as P’s narratives of amendments to the law on the basis of questions or new situations that arise over time make clear (e.g., the stories about the daughters of Zelophechad). See the book, 56, see further, the detailed study by Simeon Chavel, Oracular Law and Priestly Historiography in the Torah (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2014).
See pp. 241–47 of my book for a longer discussion of this point. In summarizing the position with which I disagree, I borrow language from my friend Bernard Levinson, one of the most eloquent proponents of that position. See, for example, his book, Legal Revision and Religious Renewal in Ancient Israel (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2008), 27–28, 48.
Gershom ben Yehudah was an Ashkenazic rabbi who lived around 1000 CE, and whose name is associated with several important rulings (תקנות רבינו גרשום), for instance, bans on polygamy and on divorcing a woman against her will.