Phinehas kills Zimri and Cosbi (colorized). Johann Teufel, 1572. Herzog August Library Wolfenbüttel, CC BY-SA 3.0
Sedition at Moab: Josephus’ Reading of the Phinehas Story
The Torah describes Phinehas as a zealot, who kills Zimri in an act of vigilante fervor, and is rewarded by God with eternal priesthood. Anticipating the rabbis’ discomfort with Phinehas’ vigilantism, Josephus transforms Phinehas into a military general and Zimri’s sin into a dangerous sedition requiring a military response.
Published: July 25, 2019
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
Much of the ambiguity revolves around the noun q.b.h; on the interpretive history of this noun, see Stefan C. Reif, “What Enraged Phinehas? A Study of Numbers 25:8,” Journal of Biblical Literature 90:2 (1971): 200-206. The abrupt shift from sinfulness with Moabite women to sinfulness with a Midianite woman is one of many inconsistencies between vv. 1-5 and vv. 6ff, leading many scholars to argue for a composite text. For a summary of critical approaches to Numbers 25, see Josebert Fleurant, “Phinehas Murdered Moses’ Wife: An Analysis of Numbers 25,” Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 35.3 (2011): 286–287.
For more general overviews of Josephus’ rendition of this biblical episode, see Louis Feldman, “The Portrayal of Phinehas by Philo, Pseudo-Philo, and Josephus,” Jewish Quarterly Review 92.3–4 (2002): 315–345; and David Bernat, “Josephus’s Portrayal of Phinehas,” Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha 13.2 (2002), 137–149. Feldman touches only briefly on the portrayal of violence in Josephus’ narrative, and Bernat makes clear that his study does not treat Phinehas’ zealotry (p. 139, n3).
This plotline is based on the reference to “Balaam’s act” as the cause of the trouble with the Midianite women in Numbers 31:16 and the Israelites having killed him in the war against Midian in Numbers 31:8 and Joshua 13:22. Numbers 25, however, does not connect Balaam to this sin. A similar embellished narrative is found in the writings of Philo of Alexandria (Life of Moses 1.296-299; On Virtue 7.34-40). On the possibility of Josephus’ acquaintance with Philo’s work, see Seth Schwartz, Josephus and Judaean Politics (Leiden: Brill, 1990), 52–54.
This and all other translations of, and references to, Josephus are quoted from Louis H. Feldman, ed., Flavius Josephus: Judean Antiquities 1-4 (Leiden: Brill, 2000).
On the pathetic genre and its use by Josephus, see Fausto Parente, “The Impotence of Titus, Or Flavius Josephus’s Bellum Iudaicum as an Example of ‘Pathetic’ Historiography,” in Josephus in Jewish History in Flavian Rome and Beyond, ed. J. Sievers and G. Lembi (Leiden: Brill, 2005), 45–70. On consciousness among the ancients about this style of writing and its ahistorical character, see already Polybius, History, 2.56.
The previous sedition mentioned by Josephus refers to the rebellion of Korah (Antiquities 4.10–65), which he described as a stasis so severe that it surpassed any known sedition among both Greeks and barbarians (Ant. 4.12). On stasis in Josephus’ writings, see Louis Feldman, Josephus’s Interpretation of the Bible (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1998), 140–143.
Willem C. van Unnik, “Josephus’ Account of the Story of Israel’s Sin with Alien Women in the Country of Midian,” in Travels in the World of the Old Testament: Studies Presented to M.A. Beek on the Occasion of His 65th Birthday, ed. Matthieu S.H.G. Heerma van Voss, Philo H.J. Houwink ten Cate, and Niek A. van Uchelen (Assen: Van Gorcum, 1974), 241–261 [252]. On stasis in Greek literature, see Jonathan J. Price, Thucydides and Internal War (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001), 11–78; for stasis in Josephus’ War, see Jonathan J. Price, “Josephus’ Reading of Thucydides: A Test Case in the Bellum Iudaicum,” in Thucydides: A Violent Teacher: History and Its Representations, ed. Georg Rechenauer and Vassiliki Pothou (Göttingen: V&R unipress, 2011).
Mark Andrew Brighton, The Sicarii in Josephus’ Judean War: Rhetorical Analysis and Historical Observations (Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature Press, 2009), 79-82. See also Tessa Rajak, “The Against Apion and Continuities in Josephus’s Political Thought,” in Understanding Josephus: Seven Perspectives, ed. Steve Mason (Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 1998), 222–243 [240].
This omission is perhaps a function of Josephus’ hagiographic portrayal of Moses and erasure elsewhere of Moses’ misdeeds. See Wayne Meeks, The Prophet-King: Moses Traditions and the Johannine Christology (Leiden: Brill, 1967), 131–145. On the thematic disjunction between God’s orders and Moses’ actions, see Jonathan Grossman, “Divine Command and Human Initiative: A Literary View on Numbers 25-31,” Biblical Interpretation 15 (2007): 54–79.
Per LSJ (s.v.) the verb has a wide lexical range, and it is unclear whether a sexual union is intended. A similar ambiguity exists in the biblical text; see Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 21–36: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, Anchor Bible 4a (New York: Doubleday, 2000), 282–283.
This constitutes a distinct contrast with the rabbinic portrayal of Moses’ inaction in this episode, and conforms well with Josephus’ larger program of portraying Moses in the most positive possible light. On rabbinic criticism of Moses’ role in the Phinehas episode, see Yonatan S. Miller, “Phinehas’ Priestly Zeal and the Violence of Contested Identities,” Jewish Studies Quarterly 26.2 (2019): 117–145 [140–144].
The motif of the dangers faced by Phinehas is played up in Sifre Numbers 131.
במדבר כה:יא פִּינְחָס בֶּן אֶלְעָזָר בֶּן אַהֲרֹן הַכֹּהֵן הֵשִׁיב אֶת חֲמָתִי מֵעַל בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל בְּקַנְאוֹ אֶת קִנְאָתִי בְּתוֹכָם וְלֹא כִלִּיתִי אֶת בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל בְּקִנְאָתִי. כה:יב לָכֵן אֱמֹר הִנְנִי נֹתֵן לוֹ אֶת בְּרִיתִי שָׁלוֹם. כה:יג וְהָיְתָה לּוֹ וּלְזַרְעוֹ אַחֲרָיו בְּרִית כְּהֻנַּת עוֹלָם תַּחַת אֲשֶׁר קִנֵּא לֵאלֹהָיו וַיְכַפֵּר עַל בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל.
Num 25:11 Phinehas, son of Elazar son of Aaron the priest, has turned back My wrath from the Israelites by acting zealously for My zealotry, so that I did not wipe out the Israelite people in My zealotry. 25:12 Say, therefore, “I grant him My Covenant of Peace. 25:13 It shall be for him and his descendants after him a Covenant of Eternal Priesthood, because he was zealous for his God, and atoned for the Israelites.”
See Martin Hengel, The Zealots: Investigations into the Jewish Freedom Movement in the Period from Herod I until 70 A.D., trans. David Smith (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1989), 155; Torrey Seland, Establishment Violence in Philo and Luke (Leiden: Brill, 1995), 60–61; Feldman, “The Portrayal of Phinehas,” 326–327. For a thoroughgoing review of scholarship and critique of the notion that the root “zeal” is to be automatically associated with the Zealot movement, see Morton Smith, “Zealots and Sicarii, Their Origins and Relation,” Harvard Theological Review 64.1 (1971): 1–19.
Nowhere in the biblical text is Phinehas described as a “priest anointed for war” (כהן משוח מלחמה); cf. t. Sotah 7:17; y. Megillah 1:10 [72a]. This office, which is of a stature just beneath that of High Priest, appears to be an exegetical creation of the rabbis.
On squaring this formula with Josephus’ writings, see Louis Feldman, Studies in Josephus’ Rewritten Bible (Leiden: Brill, 1998), 539-570.. For Feldman, this formula was “intended merely to assure the reader that the historian has done his research honestly” (540).
See Josephus’ superlative comments about his priestly lineage in his Life 1–2. See also Schwartz, Josephus and Judaean Politics, 88–92.
On the etiological function of the motif of priestly violence, see Miller, “Phinehas’ Priestly Zeal.”
David Bernat has suggested two further considerations. First, that Josephus saw the covenant of eternal priesthood as extraneous, because the office of the priesthood should have been passed to Phinehas at his birth, and to Phinehas’ descendants at their birth. This problem seems to be “anticipated” in the Bavli, where R. Hanina says: “Phinehas was not made into a priest until he killed Zimri” (b. Zevahim 101b). Second, the perpetuity of the Phinehan priesthood seemed to have been violated when the Elides lost their ministering position at Shiloh (1 Sam 3:11-14). Bernat, “Josephus’ Portrayal,” 143–144. On this episode, see Mark Leuchter, Samuel and the Shaping of Tradition (New York: Oxford University Press, 2013), 32–40.
Notably, Aaron in that story, and perhaps by extension the Aaronide priesthood, is portrayed as the ringleader of a mass apostasy.
See the list of episodes in Feldman, Antiquities, 7–8[n22].
Phinehas is portrayed as a military leader in Numbers 31:6, but as a general in the writings of both Philo and Josephus. See also Bernat, “Josephus’ Portrayal,” 139[n7]. On Josephus’ emphasis on military leadership, both autobiographical and exegetical, see Feldman, Josephus’s Interpretation of the Bible, 106–113.
Feldman, “The Portrayal of Phinehas,” 328; Bernat, “Josephus’s Portrayal of Phinehas,” 145–148.
Bernat, “Josephus’s Portrayal of Phinehas,” 138.
With the exception of Philo, the relevant sources are collected and analyzed in Dongshin Don Chang, Phinehas, the Sons of Zadok, and Melchizedek (London: T&T Clark, 2016).
See the history of scholarship in Seland, Establishment Violence.
The skeptical approach regarding rabbinic legal authority now favored among Anglophone scholars of ancient Judaism is represented nicely in Naftali Cohn, “Rabbis as Jurists: On the Representation of Past and Present Legal Institutions in the Mishnah,” Journal of Jewish Studies 60.2 (2009): 245–263.
See, e.g., Sifre Numbers, Shelah 111.
And, as noted by Clenman, “rabbinic traditions are generally uncomfortable with the notion that intermarriage and sexual relations between Jews and non-Jews be punishable by death.” See Laliv Clenman, “‘It Was Not according to the Will of the Sages:’ Halakhic and Aggadic Responses to Pinhas’ Killing of Zimri and Kozbi in Numbers 25,” in Vixens Disturbing Vineyards: Embarrassment and Embracement of Scriptures: Festschrift in Honor of Harry Fox (leBeit Yoreh), ed. Harry Fox and Tzemah Yoreh (Boston: Academic Studies Press, 2010), 169–191 [182].
On rabbinic discomfort with the violence of Phinehas, see Clenman, “It Was Not according to the Will of the Sages”; Hengel, The Zealots, 156–171; David Bernat, “Pinchas’ Extrajudicial Execution of Zimri and Cozbi,” TheTorah.com (2018); Miller, “Phinehas’ Priestly Zeal,” 135–140.
Paul Kahn, “Criminal and Enemy in the Political Imagination,” The Yale Review 99.1 (2011): 148–167 [149].