The Purification of a Niddah: The Legal Responsibility of the Reader

A rejoinder to Rabbi Dr. Zev Farber’s “The Purification of a Niddah: The Torah Requirement.”

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The Purification of a Niddah: The Legal Responsibility of the Reader." TheTorah.com, April 24, 2014. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-purification-of-a-niddah-the-legal-responsibility-of-the-reader.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The Purification of a Niddah: The Legal Responsibility of the Reader" (2014, April 24). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-purification-of-a-niddah-the-legal-responsibility-of-the-reader

The Purification of a Niddah: The Legal Responsibility of the Reader

Pexels / Pixabay

Categories:

Metzora

Published: April 24, 2014

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. [1] For the application of reader-response criticism to priestly rules, see W.K. Gilders, Blood Ritual in the Hebrew Bible. Meaning and Power (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University, 2004), 6 – 12.

  2. Regarding the nature of this washing in the First Temple Period, see the TABS devar Torah on Parashat Metzora by Hayah Katz: “Biblical Purification: Was it Immersion?”

  3. [3] See Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (AB; New York: Doubleday, 1991), 948–53, for a partial but convenient discussion of cross-cultural evidence, as well as Jewish evidence for the fear of menstrual pollution from Second Temple and medieval times. For easily accessible statements, see also m. Shabbat 2:6 and Ramban on Gen 31:35.

  4. Admittedly, since most scholars distinguish between the Priestly Source (P), responsible for most of Lev 1–16 and the Holiness Source (H), responsible for Lev 17–26, it is possible to argue that P did not recognize the punishment of karet for sexual relations with the menstruant. However, Baruch Schwartz has pointed out that the only ostensible halakhic contradiction between P and H pertains to the law of the niddah (The Holiness Legislation: Studies in the Priestly Code [Jerusalem: Magnes, 1999], 26 – 27 [Hebrew]). Namely, Lev 20:18 depicts sexual relations with a niddah as a severe transgression (cf. also 18:19), but in Lev 15 this prohibition is not mentioned at all! From here, many scholars conclude that P permitted these relations. However, if this is the only known contradiction between H and P, we should be cautious before positing such a wide discrepancy between blanket permission (P) and severe punishment (H). It may be more plausible to entertain a harmonistic solution, such as that offered by Ibn Ezra on Lev 15:24 which he understands as referring to accidental relations. A similar solution is expressed in Samaritan halakha. See See I. R. Bóid, Principles of Samaritan Halachah (Leiden: Brill, 1989), 149, 174.

  5. “The Etymology of נדה ‘Menstrual Impurity,’’ in Solving Riddles and Untying Knots: Biblical, Epigraphic, and Semitic studies in Honor of Jonas C. Greenfield (eds. Z. Zevit et al.; Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 1995), 76.

  6. From a cursory inspection of cross-cultural evidence pertaining to menstrual impurity, I can affirm that menstrual pollution was/ is removed by washing in Hindu, Zoroastrian, Muslim and apparently ancient Egyptian religions. Regarding Mesopotamia, a check in the Chicago Assyrian Dictionary (M/2 239 – 40) for musukkatu (= “menstruant”) brings references to the impurity of water that a menstruant touches or bathes in (admittedly the context isn’t entirely clear). The alternative term urruštu (CAD U/W 248) yields similar references. I am not aware of any counter-example in which menstrual pollution goes away automatically.

  7. See Shaye J.D. Cohen, “Purity, Piety and Polemic: Medieval Rabbinic Denunciations of ‘Incorrect’ Purification Practices,” in Women and Water: Menstruation in Jewish Life and Law (ed. R.R. Wasserfall; Hanover: Brandeis University, 1999), 91–96.

  8. It seems doubtful, in fact, that R. Akiva was troubled by the problem discussed by Farber (see the reading of the Sifra cited in n. 11 of Farber’s article). Rather, his intention was take away the textual basis from his peers who were imposing extreme stringencies on niddot. As such, it is not surprising that R’ Yehudai’s solution is more convincing than the Rabbis. He may have been the first to deal seriously with the ‘problem.’

  9. Note that the requirement to launder implies a more stringent degree of impurity, applied on top of the washing requirement (see Lev 15 throughout).

  10. David P. Wright, The Disposal of Impurity: Elimination Rites in the Bible and in Hittite and Mesopotamian Literature (Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1987), 185, n. 38, 191, n. 44; Milgrom, ibid, 672

  11. For another illustration of this point focusing on the formula “eye for an eye,” see Edward Greenstein,”‘An Eye for an Eye, A Tooth for a Tooth’: Peshat, Derash, and the Question of Context” [in Hebrew] Resling: A Multi-Disciplinary Stage for Culture, vol. 5, 1998, 31-34, available here: www.resling.co.il/pdfs/issue_article_53.doc