The Scouts Return from Canaan, Gilliam van der Gouwen, after Gerard Hoet (I), 1728 (adapted). Rijkmuseum
The Scouts’ Report: From Rhetoric to Demagoguery
The scout’s initial report is only skeptical, but Caleb’s good-intentioned challenge pushes them to take a dishonest stand against entering the land.
Published: June 24, 2022
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
Source critical scholars argue that the two reports reflect two different versions of the story, one Priestly and one non-Priestly, that were woven together by a compiler. See, e.g., Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 1-20, Anchor Bible 4.1 (New York: Doubleday 1993), 347-348; Jacob Milgrom, Numbers, The JPS Torah Commentary (Philadelphia: The Jewish Publication Society, 1990), 387-390; Joel Baden, J, E, and the Redaction of the Pentateuch, FAT 68 (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2009), 115–116; TABS Editors, “Unscrambling the Scout Story with the Documentary Hypothesis,” TheTorah (2015). This piece offers a synchronic reading of the passage.
Indeed, the text goes on to say בְּנֵי עֲנָק מִן הַנְּפִלִים, using the word Anakites, but it is possible to read this phrase as an editor’s parenthetical “Anakites are a type of Nephilim”—this is how the NJPS translation understands it—and thus it would not be a parallel in the speech itself, but the narrator calling the reader’s attention to a parallel.
Aristotle, “Rhetoric,” trans. W. Rhys Roberts, in The Complete Works of Aristotle: The Revised Oxford Translation, ed. Jonathan Barnes, Bolingen Series 71.2 (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1984), 2.2152–2269 [p. 2155].
Some ancient Greeks objected to the study of rhetoric since they argued that rhetorical techniques can use emotional manipulation to convince people of falsehood. With his treatise, Aristotle aimed to bridge this gap by offering a model of rhetoric whose core would be the logical argument (logos). See discussion in Yehoshua Gitay, [אמנות הרטוריקה: מיוון העתיקה ועד אובמה] The Art of Rhetoric: From the Greek Sophists to Obama (Moshav Ben-Shemen: Modan, 2013), 13.
“Demagogue”, in The Oxford Dictionary, 172; Nathan Spiegel, מילים מספרות: מבחר מונחים וגלגולם בתרבות האנושית [Tales Words Tell: Selected Terms and Their Cultural History] (Jerusalem: The Magness Press, 1992), 120-121 [Heb]; J. Justin Gustainis, “Demagoguery and Political Rhetoric: A Review of the Literature,” Rhetoric Society Quarterly 20 (1990), 157-161.
The term דבה on its own is always negative, and the phrase הוצאת דבה specifically implies telling falsehoods. See ibn Ezra, Ramban, and Radak (ad loc.), and Milgrom, Numbers, 106.
Levine, Numbers 1-20, 358. See also, Itamar Kislev, “Joshua (and Caleb) in the Priestly Spies Story and Joshua’s Initial Appearance in the Priestly Source: A Contribution to an Assessment of the Pentateuchal Priestly Material”, JBL 136 (2017): 39-55 [p. 42].
Editor’s note: See Benjamin Sommer, “Why Are there Demigods in a Monotheistic Torah?” TheTorah (2015).
Given that they ostensibly didn’t converse with these giants, the midrash points out that this claim is something they could not possibly make with confidence (Numbers Rabbah 16:11):
וכן היינו בעיניהם: יודעים הייתם מה עשיתי אתכם לעיניהם מי יאמר שלא הייתם בעיניהם כמלאכים?
“And that’s what we were like in their eyes”—Do you know how I (=God) made you appear in their eyes? Who’s to say you didn’t appear as angels to them?
See discussion of this metaphor in Howard M. Markose, Metaphor in the Book of Numbers, Ph.D. Dissertation (Ramat Gan: Bar Ilan University, 2015), 142.