Elisha Raising the Shunammite’s Son by Benjamin West, 1766. Speed Art Museum/ Wikimedia
The Shunammite Woman and the Patriarchy Problem
Virtually all biblical scholars—even feminist biblical scholars—consider the Bible and ancient Israelite society patriarchal. But is that a valid designation?
Published: October 22, 2018
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
See Adele Reinhartz, “Jewish Women’s Scholarly Writings on the Bible,” The Jewish Study Bible, ed. Adele Berlin and Marc Zvi Brettler (2nd ed.; Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014), 2090.
A disconnect between formal or authoritative texts (like the Bible) and social reality is not uncommon; for examples, see Carol Meyers, “Seeing Double: Textual and Archaeological Images of Israelite Women,” in The Bible and Feminism: Remapping the Field, edited by Yvonne Sherwood with the assistance of Anna Fisk (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2017), 514–18.
On gender hierarchy in the Bible, see Marc Zvi Brettler, “Gender in the Bible,” in The Jewish Study Bible, ed. Adele Berlin and Marc Zvi Brettler (2nd ed.; Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014), 2179–80.
Shunem, a site in the territory of Issachar according to Josh 19:18, is located on the southern edge of the Jezreel near Mount Gilboa.
gĕdôlâ is sometimes translated “wealthy” (as NJPS) because important people may have achieved their status because of wealth. However, not every great person was necessarily wealthy, as noted by Mordecai Cogan and Hayim Tadmor, II Kings: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary (Anchor Bible 11; Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1988), 56.
The woman and her family can be considered well-to-do because “reapers” are working for the family (2 Kings 8:18) and because they have multiple servants (2 Kings 8:22).
Note the contrast with Abraham in Gen 18:1-8, where Abraham is the one who recognizes special visitors; he orders Sarah to prepare “cakes,” has a servant bring meat, and seats the guests under a tree for their meal. The Abraham account is in the parasha for which the Shunammite story is the haftara. In both the Abraham and Shunammite accounts, pregnancy rewards hospitality.
To be sure, she does say to her husband “let us make” the room. Yet she is credited with the renovation, for when the prophet (through his assistant Gehazi) offers recompense, the offer is addressed to her alone (2 Kings 8:13).
Many commentators assume that she was a widow at this point, but that claim is unjustified, as noted by Cogan and Tadmor, II Kings, 88.
This designation is suggested by David E.S. Stein, “Dictionary of Gender in the Torah,” in The Contemporary Torah: A Gender-Sensitive Adaptation of the JPS Translation, edited by David. E. S. Stein (Philadelphia: The Jewish Publication Society, 2006), 403.
For a discussion of these texts, see Carol Meyers, Rediscovering Eve: Ancient Israelite Women in Context (New York; Oxford University Press, 2013), 187–92.
Here I’m summarizing part of my article “Was Ancient Israel a Patriarchal Society?,” Journal of Biblical Literature 133 (2014): 8–27.
See Henry Sumner Maine, Ancient Law: Its Connection with the Early History of Society, and Its Relation to Modern Ideas (London: John Murray, 1861); Numa Denis Fustel de Coulanges, La cité antique: Étude sur le culte, le droit, les institutions de la Grèce et de Rome (Paris: Durand, 1864); and Lewis Henry Morgan, Ancient Society, or, Researches in the Lines of Human Progress from Savagery, through Barbarism to Civilization (New York: Holt, 1877).
Bernhard Stade, Geschichte des Volkes Israel (2 vols.; Berlin: Grote, 1887–1888).
Roland de Vaux, Ancient Israel: Its Life and Institutions (trans. John McHugh; New York: McGraw Hill, 1961), 20. His assertions about patriarchal control appear in reference to the incident in Genesis 38:24 where Judah condemns his daughter-in-law to death. The book was originally published in French (Les Institutions de l’Ancien Testament [2 vols.; Paris: Cerf, 1958–60]); it was also reprinted in English as a classic (Grand Rapids, MI; Eerdmans, 1997).
E.g., Susanne Scholz proclaims that “Scholars of all ideological stripes generally agree that ancient Israel was patriarchal and men dominated private, and public life,” in Introducing the Women’s Hebrew Bible: Feminism, Gender Justice, and the Study of the Old Testament (London: Bloomsbury T&T Clark, 2016), 72.
Social analysis goes back to the Greeks if not earlier, but it did not emerge in academia until the end of the nineteenth century.
Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft (2 vols.; Tubingen: Mohr, 1922).
Martin Noth, The History of Israel (trans. Stanley Godman and Peter Ackroyd from the second German edition [1954]; 2nd ed.; New York: Harper, 1960; 1st German ed., 1950), 108.
See the work of Roman historians Richard Saller (Patriarchy, Property, and Death in the Roman Family [New York: Cambridge University Press, 1994], especially chapter 5, “Pietas and patria potestas: obligation and power in the Roman household,” 102–32), and Suzanne Dixon (The Roman Family [Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1992]).
The nineteenth-century theorists assumed erroneously that the legal texts on which they based their formation of the patriarchy concept functioned just as European or American legal systems do.
Saller, Patriarchy, 2.
See Richard Saller “Pater Familias, Mater Familias, and the Gendered Semantics of the Roman Household,” Classical Philology 94 (1999): 182–97. Note that the late fifth–early fourth century Greek historian Xenophon, in his treatise on household management, presents the roles of wife and husband as complementary, with a woman having household authority and sometimes even “exercising authority over her marital partner”; see Sarah B. Pomeroy, Xenophon, Oeconomicus: A Social and Historical Commentary with a New English Translation (Oxford: Clarendon, 1994), 34, 36, 247.
E.g., Suzanne M. Spencer-Wood, “Feminist Gender Research in Classical Archaeology,” in Women in Antiquity: Theoretical Approaches to Gender and Archaeology (ed. Sarah Milledge Nelson; Gender and Archaeology Series; Lanham, MD.: AltaMira, 2007), 29–74.
See, e.g., Celia E. Schultz, Women’s Religious Activity in the Roman Republic (Chapel Hill, NC: The University of North Carolina Press, 2006).
See my Rediscovering Eve, 125–70.
See, inter alia, Paloma González-Marcén, Sandra Montón-Subías, and Marina Picazo, “Towards an Archaeology of Maintenance Activities,” in Engendering Social Dynamics: The Archaeology of Maintenance Activities (ed. Sandra Montón-Subías and Margarita Sánchez-Romero; BAR International Series 1862; Oxford: Archaeopress, 2008), 3–8.
Ethnographic data from premodern societies in ecological environments in the Mediterranean basin similar to that of the Israelites provide information about gender dynamics in households dependent on women’s maintenance activities. These data indicate considerable female agency in running household affairs. See my Rediscovering Eve, 182–87.
For other issues, in addition to those mentioned here, see my “Was Ancient Israel a Patriarchal Society?,” 24–26.
In order for men to be certain of the paternity of their offspring and thus of their heirs, they had to be certain that their wives or those betrothed to them had not been impregnated by someone else; this assurance was effected by controlling female sexuality. Editor’s note: For more on this, see Cynthia Edenburg, “Deuteronomy’s Uncompromising Demand for Women’s Sexual Fidelity,” TheTorah.com (2014).
A more suitable designation might be heterarchy, a term used by anthropologists to depict societies in which a hierarchical model does not allow for the complexities of social or political reality. See my “Hierarchy or Heterarchy? Archaeology and the Theorizing of Israelite Society,” in Confronting the Past: Archaeological and Historical Essays in Honor of William G. Dever (ed. Seymour Gitin, J. P. Dessel, and J. Edward Wright (Winona Lake, IN.: Eisenbrauns: 2006), 249–51; see also my discussion of “The Heterarchy Alternative” in Rediscovering Eve, 196-99.