Elaborately decorated sukkah. Mitzpeh Nevo, Maale Adumim. By Avital Pinnick cc
Published: September 16, 2013
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
[1] The name “Pesach” appears as well, but this is the name of the sacrifice not the name of a holiday.
[2] This historical explanation brings with it a calendrical problem. If dwelling in sukkot is meant to commemorate the desert experience, why pick Tishrei instead of an earlier date for this mitzvah? To this, Rabbi Jacob ben Asher (14th cent. Spain) offers an answer (Tur,Orach Chaim 625):
Even though we left Egypt in the month of Nissan, we were not commanded to build sukkot during that time because it is at the beginning of the summer season when it is normal for people to make a booth for shade. Therefore, it would not be apparent that we are building the sukkah for the purpose of fulfilling the mitzvah. Therefore, we were commanded to make them in the seventh month, which is the start of the rainy season, when it is normal for people to go back into their homes. Thus, when we leave our homes to go into the sukkah we demonstrate that we are doing so to fulfill God’s command.
The historical critical approach to this question would point in a different direction: the mitzvah of sukkah began as an agricultural mitzvah, therefore it came at the end of the harvesting season, in the autumn. Eventually, that mitzvah was reinterpreted as relating to the wilderness experience, but this in itself would not be sufficient cause to move the date of the holiday.
[3] The historicizing of the holiday, from agricultural festival to a commemoration of Egypt/wilderness, is a pattern that begins in the bible with Pesach/Festival of Matzot, occurs here in Leviticus for Sukkot and happens in post-biblical literature with Shavuot. For more on this process, see David Frankel’s TABS essay “Integrating the Exodus Story into the Festivals.” See also Norman Solomon’s TABS essay “Shavuot: How the Festival of Harvest Grew.”