Torah from heaven, generated by DALL·E 2
Torah from Heaven: A Guide to the Four Questions
According to tradition, must we believe that the Torah is: Historical? Mosaic? Univocal? Perfect?
Published: August 15, 2013
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
See: Shubert Spero, “The Biblical Stories of Creation, Garden of Eden and the Flood: History or Metaphor?” Tradition 33:2 (Winter 1999): 5-18. (Spero received his semichah from Yeshiva Torah Vodaas and his Ph.D. in Jewish thought from Case Western Reserve University. He was the rabbi of Young Israel of Cleveland for many years before moving to Israel and taking a position at Bar Ilan University as Irving Stone Professor of Jewish Thought.) This suggestion, and other forms of allegorical or ahistorical readings, are further explored by Rabbi Dr. Joshua L. Golding, in “On the Limits of Non-Literal Interpretation of Scripture from an Orthodox Perspective,” Torah U-Madda Journal 10 (2001): 37-59.
“…suppose someone were to come along and say, ‘I suppose they were not history because of x,y,z evidence- would prove they can’t be historical figures’- In this particular case even though I profess a profound degree of uncomfortableness I don’t think the person has crossed the line because I don’t think the historical existence of the avos is compelling or necessary as one of the ikarei haemunah.” Rabbi Nathanial (Nati) Helfgot is a musmach of RIETS (Rabbi Isaac Elchanan Theological Seminary) in Yeshiva University and is the Chair of Bible and Jewish Thought at YCT Rabbinical School. Rabbi Jeremy Wieder is also a musmach of RIETS and is now one of the Roshei Yeshiva there, and holds the Gwendolyn and Joseph Straus Chair in Talmud. To be fair, both Rabbi Wieder and Rabbi Helfgot state unequivocally that they themselves do believe in the patriarchs and matriarchs, but are just exploring a hypothetical. Additionally, R. Wieder states that rejecting the historicity of the Sinai event is out of bounds in his opinion, religiously speaking, as well may be rejecting the historicity of the Exodus from Egypt.
Much of R. Levi ben Avraham’s magnum opus, the Livyat Chen, has been lost, but large sections exist in manuscripts. Recently, Howard (Chaim) Kreisel has begun publishing the existing pieces, beginning with section three on creation. For more on this debate, see Asher BenZion Buchman’s article “Abraham and Sarah in Provence,” in Hakirah 6 (2008): 223-257; Gregg Stern, Philosophy and Rabbinic Culture: Jewish Interpretation and Controversy in Medieval Languedoc (Routledge, 2009); idem, “Allegorizers of Torah and the Story of Their Prosecution in Languedoc,” TheTorah (2015).
Rabbi Dr. Kula was the Rosh ha-Yeshiva of Ein Tzurim and is currently the rabbi of Kibbutz Alumim as well as the coordinator of Beit Midrash Daroma in Ben Gurion University (where he did his Ph.D. in Jewish thought.) He is a member of both Tzohar and Beit Hillel. For a warm review of his book (in Hebrew), see R. Yuval Cherlow’s post on Musaf Shabbat.
For how Kula speaks of this with regard to the Abraham story, see Amit Kula, “Abraham, Smasher of Idols, and the Question of the Torah’s Historicity,” TheTorah (2014). To be fair, Rav Kula states a number of times that he personally believes in all the stories, but that he does not believe that doing so is essential or even important (pp. 75, 171).
See discussion in Zev Farber, “Editorial Comments in the Opening Chapters of Deuteronomy,” TheTorah (2013); idem, “The Significance of Ibn Ezra’s Position that Verses Were Added to the Torah,” TheTorah (2014).
This last one explicitly refers to:
דברי הימים ב לד:יד ...סֵפֶר תּוֹרַת יְ־הוָה בְּיַד מֹשֶׁה.
2 Chron 34:14 ...The Book of the Torah of God by the hand of Moses.
See Israel Knohl, “Between Faith and Critical Scholarship,” originally published in Megadim 33 and available online on Daat.
For some discussion of this, see David Glatt-Gilad, “Deuteronomy: The First Torah,” TheTorah (2015); Hindy Najman, “The Ancient Practice of Attributing Texts and Ideas to Moses,” TheTorah (2016); Yishai Kiel, “How the Concept of Mosaic Authorship Developed,” TheTorah (2018); Molly M. Zahn, “What Is ‘Torah’ in Second Temple Texts?” TheTorah (2021).
For a translation of Abarbanel’s introduction, see: Eric Lawee, “Don Isaac Abarbanel: Who Wrote the Books of the Bible?” Tradition 30 (1996): 65-73.
See the position of R. Shlomo Fisher and others, see discussion in Dr. Marc Shapiro’s post on The Seforim Blog, Torah Mi-Sinai and More.
For ibn Ezra, see Zev Farber, “Seven Torah Passages of Non-Mosaic Origin According to Ibn Ezra and R. Joseph Bonfils,” TheTorah (2014). For R. Yehudah HeChasid, see Baruch J. Schwartz, “When Moses Placed Ephraim Before Manasseh,” TheTorah (2017); Zev Farber, “Edomite Kings List: Is It Post-Mosaic?” TheTorah (2019).
This position is actually debated on the next page of the Talmud (b. Baba Batra 15a).
Yuval Cherlow, “Authorship of the Torah: The Position of Ibn Ezra and Yehuda HaChasid,” TheTorah (2013). Rabbi Cherlow is the Rosh ha-Yeshiva of Yeshivat Hesder Petach Tikva. He is a graduate of Yeshivat Har Etzion and a retired major in the IDF. After obtaining his semichah, Rabbi Cherlow served as the Rabbi of Kibbutz Tirat Tzvi, and at the Hesder Yeshiva in Chispin. He is among the founders of Tzohar.
Norman Solomon, Torah from Heaven: The Reconstruction of Faith (Oxford: The Littman Library of Jewish Civilization, 2012), 315, 317. Rabbi Dr. Solomon was ordained by Jews College and served as a rabbi in a number of congregations in England. He did his Ph.D. in Jewish thought at the University of Manchester, and has taught and done research in a number of academic settings.
See discussion in, Jonathan Jacobs, “The Double Quail Narratives and Bekhor Shor’s Innovative Reading,” TheTorah (2019).
Rabbi Dr. Soloveitchik (1903-1993), known to many as “the Rav,” was a scion of a rabbinic family and did his Ph.D. in philosophy at Friedrich Wilhelm University in Berlin. Rav Soloveitchik took over his father’s position as Rosh ha-Yeshiva of RIETS upon the latter’s passing and is considered by many to have been the most influential leader of the Modern Orthodox in the United States.
Rabbi Dr. Breuer (1921-2007) was an expert in the masoretic text, and produced the accurate and updated Keter Tanach. He completed his Ph.D. studies at Hebrew University, where he wrote on medieval Ashkenazi yeshivot. He won the Bialik Prize for Jewish thought and the Israel prize for creative research in rabbinic literature.
Mordechai Breuer, “The Study of Bible and the Primacy of the Fear of Heaven: Compatibility or Contradiction,” in Modern Scholarship in the Study of Torah (ed. Shalom Carmy; Orthodox Forum; Northvale: Aaronson, 1996), 159-180; Mordechai Breuer, Pirkei Moadot (Jerusalem: Horeb, 1989) [Hebrew].
Halbertal has written several essay on this. See, for instance, his expanded updated treatment in chapter 1 of, Moshe Halbertal, על דרך האמת: הרמב”ן ויצירתה של מסורת [By Way of Truth: Nahmanides and the Creation of Tradition] (Jerusalem: Hartman, 2006), 21-76.
Ramban was so disturbed by Rambam’s understanding of sacrifices as a divine concession, that he wrote a lengthy rebuttal in his commentary on Leviticus (1:9), and uses rather harsh language against Rambam, calling his idea foolishness and accusing him of making “God’s table disgusting.”
See: Basil Herring, Joseph Ibn Kaspi’s Gevia’ Ha-Kesef (New York: Ktav, 1982), p. 13 in the Hebrew, and 159 in the English.
I heard this from a number of people, including a student of R. Walter Wurzberger, in his name.
Norman Lamm, “Amalek and the Seven Nations: A Case of Law vs. Morality,” in War and Peace in Jewish Tradition (ed. Lawrence Schiffman and Joel Wolowelsky; Orthodox Forum 16; New York: Yeshiva University Press, 2004), 201-238 [226-227]. R. Dr. Lamm was ordained by RIETS and received his Ph.D. in philosophy from YU’s Revel School. He was the third president of Yeshiva University and served as its chancellor until his retirement in 2013. Rabbi Lamm’s discussion follows in the footsteps of similar approaches such as Rabbi Dr. Aharon Lichtenstein, “Does Jewish Tradition Recognize an Ethic Independent of Halakhah?” in Contemporary Jewish Ethics (ed. Menachem Kellner; Sanhedrin Press, 1978), 102–123; Rabbi Dr. Eugene Korn “Legal Floors and Moral Ceilings: a Jewish Understanding of Law and Ethics,” Edah 2:2 (2002); Rabbi Dr. Nahum Rabinovitch, “The Way of Torah,” Edah 3.1 (2003).
Rabbi Dr. David Hartman (1931-2013) received his ordination from Yeshiva University and his Ph.D. in philosophy from McGill University. After spending a number of years as a pulpit rabbi in Canada, he moved to Israel and founded the Shalom Hartman Institute. Hartman’s approach is very influenced by that of R. Dr. Emanuel Rackman. See, for example: Emanuel Rackman, Modern Halakha for our Time (Jersey City: Ktav, 1995); Emanuel Rackman, “Halakha: Orthodox Approach,” Encyclopedia Judaica Year Book 1975-76 (ed. Cecil Roth; Jerusalem: Keter, 1976), 134-144 (143).
Dr. Ross is a professor of Jewish philosophy in Bar Ilan University and a teacher in Midreshet Lindenbaum, and is an expert in the thinking of Rav Kook. See also, Tamar Ross, “Orthodoxy and the Challenge of Biblical Criticism,” TheTorah (2014).