Tzom Gedaliah: Why Commemorate His Assassination?

Gedaliah ben Ahikam, the governor of Judah after the destruction of the Temple, was assassinated by Ishmael ben Nethaniah, a scion of the Davidic family. This event has been commemorated for millennia with a yearly fast—the only fast over the death of an individual. The Talmud points to his righteousness, while Saadia Gaon emphasizes the tragic consequences to the Judahite people he governed.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Tzom Gedaliah: Why Commemorate His Assassination?." TheTorah.com, September 3, 2021. https://www.thetorah.com/article/tzom-gedaliah-why-commemorate-his-assassination.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Tzom Gedaliah: Why Commemorate His Assassination?" (2021, September 3). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/tzom-gedaliah-why-commemorate-his-assassination

Tzom Gedaliah: Why Commemorate His Assassination?

Gedalia murdered by Ishmael (colorized), Jan Luyken, 1704. Rijksmuseum.

Published: September 3, 2021

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. Translations of the Bible are from the NJPS, sometimes slightly modified.

  2. It is observed on the tenth of the month and is known as ʿAsarah be-Tevet (the 10th of Tevet).

  3. In the Bible, this event takes place on the 9th of the month, and the fast was probably observed on this day in the Second Temple Period. Karaite Jews still commemorate it on this day, while rabbinic Jews do so on the 17th (hence the name Shiv‘a ‘Asar be-Tammuz, the 17th of Tammuz), likely because it was on this day that the walls of Jerusalem were breached by the Romans in 70 C.E.

  4. According to the Bible, the destruction happened either on the 7th (2 Kgs 25:8) or the 10th (Jer 52:12). Karaite Jews observe both of these days. See Tomer Mangoubi, “Lamenting with Job: The Karaite Version of the Fasts for Jerusalem,” TheTorah (2016). Rabbinic Jews observe the fast on the 9th, and thus the fast is known as Tisha BʿAv (9th of Av). See Zev Farber, “Tisha B'Av: On What Day Were the Jerusalem Temples Destroyed?” TheTorah (2018).

  5. The fast of the seventh month is also mentioned, alongside the fast of the fifth month, in Zechariah 7:5. On the significance of this mention for the origin and reception of the fast of Gedaliah see Tova Ganzel, “The Fast of Gedaliah: Its Continued Observance Significance in the Restoration Period,” Shnaton: An Annual for Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Studies 20 (2010), 51–69.

  6. Gedaliah’s grandfather, Shafan, was a royal scribe for King Josiah (2 Kgs 22:8).

  7. On the traditional view, recorded in Seder Olam 26, and affirmed by Saadia in a poem entitled תאלת יום מבוכה “The curse of the day of confusion” (l. 7) (on which see note 15 below), Gedaliah was killed on the third of Tishrei immediately following the Temple’s destruction in Av, so that his term lasted only 52 days. More likely, the assassination occurred more than a year or possibly a few years after the Temple’s destruction. On the question of the length of Gedaliah’s term, see Ganzel, “The Fast of Gedaliah,” 51–59, with a detailed review of prior scholarship.

  8. See Jeremiah 41:16-18.

  9. They identify the fast with the one on this date mentioned in Nehemiah 9:1.

  10. The self-identity of this community as the proper heirs of the land becomes visible, in Ganzel’s analysis, elsewhere in contemporaneous prophetic literature. See in particular Ezekiel 33:23–29.

  11. Tosefta Sotah 6:10 (Lieberman edition). All translations of rabbinic texts and piyyut are my own. While the Tosefta provides the date and commemorated event for each fast in Zechariah’s list, only in the case of the fast of Gedaliah, precisely because of its anomalousness, does the Tosefta identify a lesson (“This teaches you, etc.”).

  12. See Robert Brody, Sa'adyah Gaon (Liverpool: Liverpool University Press, 2013).

  13. On the Genizah evidence for Saadia’s siddur see especially Dov Greenberger, “The Siddur of Rasag: Investigations into Text, Structure, and Instruction” (PhD diss.; Ben-Gurion University, 2012).

  14. See Yosef Tobi, “The Liturgical Poems of Rav Sa’adia Gaon: Critical Edition (of the Yoṣeroth) with a General Introduction to His Poetic Work” (PhD diss.; Hebrew University, 1982) 128.

  15. See Israel Davidson et al., eds., Siddur R. Saadja Gaon (Jerusalem: Mekize Nirdamim, 1941), 333–334. The other two seliḥot are תאלת יום מבוכה “The curse of the day of confusion,” printed in the siddur immediately after אבלה נפשי, and אתה היכנתה צרי לכשולי עונות “You prepared balm for those tripped up by sins.” There are numerous verbal overlaps between אבלה נפשי and a qerovah-18 for the fast of Gedaliah, אבל במר נפש מתענים “We suffer mourning with bitter soul” (vocalized text), which suggest a genealogical connection between these compositions.

  16. The Hebrew is from Daniel Goldschmidt, Seder ha-selihot ke-minhag lita (Jerusalem: Mosad Harav Kook, 1965), 143–145.

  17. Per Jeremiah 4:7. Goldschmidt in his edition points to some textual variation around the preposition.

  18. דועכו ordinarily indicates the extinguishing of a flame. There is an ironic progression in the strophe. The burning in l. 2 is a fire of destruction, but this fire is itself something, and it leaves a remnant. In l. 4, even this fire is extinguished, and so the destruction is total. The agent of extinguishing is implicitly water; hence the turn to “seething waters” in the next line.

  19. See especially the final two strophes: Destruction recurs “in every generation and in every era (קץ)” (l. 21). But the word for an “era,” קץ, also indicates an “end” (l. 24), and so the pattern of destruction encodes its own overcoming: “Cover our sins and say: The end (קץ) has arrived.” The poem can thus conclude on a hopeful note: Eventually God will declare an end to destruction.

  20. See the She’iltot to the lections va-yeshev and shelah. On the She’iltot see Robert Brody, The Geonim of Babylonia and the Shaping of Medieval Jewish Culture (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1998), 207–215.

  21. After Ps 124:4-5. I have rendered דלק as “pursuit,” as in Gen 31:36 and other verses, but the literal sense, “burning,” is present too, paradoxically attributed here to waters.

  22. בוססו מקדש “trampling temple” is from Isa 63:18. Given the allusions to Isaiah 14 in ll. 11 and 22, one wonders whether Saadia’s use of the root בוס was inspired by its occurrence in Isa 14:19, 25.

  23. מרגיז הארץ “the land disturber” is from Isa 14:16, a prophecy about the king of Babylon. The words כורמים ויוגבים come from 2 Kings 25:12 = Jeremiah 52:16, which report that the Babylonian administration installed the “lowly of the land” (cf. l. 9) as כרמים ויגבים. The NJPS renders: “vinedressers and fieldhands.” My translation (“pickers and shore men”) depends on Saadia’s approach to these words in “The curse of the day of confusion,” which is something of a companion poem to “My soul mourned.” In l. 8 of the companion poem, Saadia refers to Jews who toiled under the protection of Babylon “to gather medicinals from Ein Gedi, and glass from Tyre.” This line alludes to Babylonian Talmud Shabbat 26a, where Rav Yosef, reading כורמים through the lens of Song of Songs 1:14 (כרמי עין גדי “the vineyards of Ein Gedi”), imagines the Babylonians as Romans avant la lettre, securing control of the key export industries of Roman Palestine: balsam from Ein Gedi (thus כורמים), and blue dye from the hilazon snail along the Mediterranean coast (thus יוגבים). Saadia follows Rav Yosef’s lead, but, perhaps for the sake of obscurantism, relies on Sifre Deuteronomy 354 to replace the dye industry with the geographically proximate glass industry, from coastal sand.

Related Topics:Fasts