What Do Women Contribute to a Baby’s Conception?

Seed, blood, or nothing? This debate among the Greeks about the role of women in the development of a fetus influenced the way Second Temple and Rabbinic interpreters understood the meaning of the biblical verse "If a woman emits seed" (Leviticus 12:2).

SBL Style

Click to copy

"What Do Women Contribute to a Baby’s Conception?." TheTorah.com, April 16, 2026. https://www.thetorah.com/article/what-do-women-contribute-to-a-babys-conception.

APA Style

Click to copy

"What Do Women Contribute to a Baby’s Conception?" (2026, April 16). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/what-do-women-contribute-to-a-babys-conception

What Do Women Contribute to a Baby’s Conception?

Tractate Niddah 31a, describing “three partners” in conception: father, mother, and God. © TheTorah

Categories:

Tazria

Published: April 16, 2026

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Owsei Temkin, trans., Soranus: Gynaecology (Johns Hopkins University Press, 1991), 12, §1.12.

  2. Geoffrey Ernest Richard Lloyd, Science, Folklore and Ideology: Studies in the Life Sciences in Ancient Greece (Cambridge University Press, 1983), 88–94; Lesley Dean-Jones, Women’s Bodies in Classical Greek Science (Clarendon Press, 1996), 149; Phillip de Lacy, ed., Galen: On Semen (Akademic Verla, 1992), 50; § 2.2, 2.4; Margaret Tallmadge May, trans., Galen: On the Usefulness of the Parts of the Body (Cornell Publications on the History of Science, 1968), 2.630.

  3. See e.g. On Generation 4.1–5.1, LVII 474–477.

  4. Treaties On the Generation of Animals 2.716a § 5–7, 2.4.738b § 20–23. A. L. Peck, trans., Aristotle: Generation of Animals (Harvard University Press, 1942). Editors note: See Marianne Grohmann, “Biblically, How Are Babies Conceived?” TheTorah (2024).

  5. Other texts, however, indicate a different position. In his paraphrase of Gen. 1:28, Ben Sirah omits any reference to women, procreation, or the divine command פְּרוּ וּרְבוּ, “be fruitful and multiply” (Gen 1:28),:

    Sir 17:1 The Lord created humans out of earth and makes them return to it again. 17:2 He gave them a fixed number of days but granted them authority over everything on the earth. 17:3 He endowed them with strength like his own and made them in his own image.

    Jeremy Cohen, “Be Fertile and Increase, Fill the Earth and Master It”: The Ancient and Medieval Career of a Biblical Text (Cornell University Press, 1989), 70. Jubilees (6:7) likewise relocates the blessing of procreation from Creation to Noah alone (Gen. 2:14; 6:1-11). Cohen, Be Fertile and Increase, 71–72.

  6. Peter W. Van der Horst, “Sarah’s Seminal Emission: Hebrews 11:11 in the Light of Ancient Embryology,” in Hellenism—Judaism—Christianity: Essays on Their Interaction (Kok Pharos, 1994), 203–223 (at 217–218). This passage may even reflect a one-seed theory in which Abraham plays no role. See Rafael Rachel Neis, When a Human Gives Birth to a Raven: Rabbis and the Reproduction of Species, Rabbis and the Reproduction of Species (University of California Press, 2023), 154–94., on the generative multiplicity in late antiquity. For Second Temple texts that appear to reflect a two-seed theory, see also 1 Enoch 15. Michael Satlow, “‘Wasted Seed,’ The History of a Rabbinic Idea,” Hebrew Union College Annual 65 (1994): 157–58.

  7. Baruch A. Levine, The JPS Torah Commentary: Leviticus (The Jewish Publication Society, 1989), 73.

  8. Other biblical terms such as וַתַּהַר וַתֵּלֶד, “she became pregnant and gave birth,” (Genesis 4:1, Leviticus 12:2) similarly convey woman’s active role in pregnancy and delivery. See Gwynn Kessler, Conceiving Israel: The Fetus in Rabbinic Narratives (University of Pennsylvania Press, 2009), 113.

  9. LXX Lev 12:2 Λάλησον τοῖς υἱοῖς Ισραηλ καὶ ἐρεῖς πρὸς αὐτούς Γυνή, ἥτις ἐὰν σπερματισθῇ καὶ τέκῃ ἄρσεν...

  10. On the origins and challenges of dating the targumim, see Ze’ev Safrai, “The Targums as Part of Rabbinic Literature,” in The Literature of the Sages: Second Part: Midrash and Targum, Liturgy, Poetry, Mysticism, Contracts, Inscriptions, Ancient Science and the Languages of Rabbinic Literature, ed. Shmuel Safrai Z"l et al., 1st ed. (Royal Van Gorcum Fortress Press, 2006), 107–132. Regarding Targum Neofiti, there is no evidence for a date earlier than the fourth century. Scholars continue to debate whether Targum Onqeles originated in the Land of Israel; in any case, it exhibits clear signs of Babylonian influence (ibid., 265).

  11. Translation of rabbinic texts are the author’s and/or the editors’.

  12. Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, par. Be-Shalakh, mas. de-Shira 8 (ed. Horotvitz-Rabin, 144); Mekhilta de-Rabbi Shimon b Yohai, par. Be-Shalakh, 15:11 (ed. Epstein-Melamed, 94).

  13. Mordecai Margulies, Midrash Vayyikra Rabbah, 3rd ed. (Jewish Theological Seminary, 1993); Burton L. Visotzky, Golden Bells and Pomegranates: Studies in Midrash Leviticus Rabbah (Mohr Siebeck, 2003), 6. While the distinction is not absolute, exegetical midrash expands the biblical text verse by verse or word by word, whereas homiletic midrash presents sustained discussions centered on a single verse or theme from the Torah reading. Herman L. Strack and Gunter Stemberger, Introduction to the Talmud and Midrash, trans. Markus Bockmuehl (Fortress, 1996), 240.

  14. Michael Sokoloff, A Dictionary of Jewish Palestinian Aramaic, second. (Bar Ilan University Press, 1992), 281–82, s.v. ליטרה.

  15. See Genesis Rabbah 17:7, where a similar analogy is employed regarding the creation of the first woman.

  16. The Tosefta here parallels a shorter ruling in the Mishnah:

    משנה נדב ב:א כל היד המרבה לבדוק בנשים משובחת ובאנשים תקצץ
    m. Niddah 2:1 Any hand which makes many examinations: In the case of women is to be praised; in the case of men, is to be cut off.
  17. This is not intended as a literal requirement but a rhetoric. The text is partially cited in b. Niddah 13a–b.

  18. Another occurrence of this analogy is invoked in regard to females, for a rather different purpose; m. Nid. 5:4 compares the regenerative quality of the hymen of a girl that is younger than three years of age to “one who sticks a finger in an eye.” In other words, just like an eye that tears returns to its original state and is capable of tearing again, so too will the hymen regenerate in a girl younger than three.

  19. See discussion in Michael L. Satlow, “Does the Torah Prohibit Male Masturbation?” TheTorah (2024); Satlow, “‘Wasted Seed,’ The History of a Rabbinic Idea,” 142–43..

  20. In his talmudic commentary to b. Niddah 13a, R. Moses Nahmanides argues that women are in principle subject to a prohibition against wasting seed, but may nonetheless perform genital examinations because they are less likely to become aroused in the process. In contrast, Rabbeinu Tam (R. Jacob b. Meir, 1100–1171) explains the Mishnah’s encouragement of women’s genital examinations as a purely legal issue: לאו בנות הרגשה “they do not feel anything [sexual when checking]” is interpreted as דלאו בנות איסור הרגשה “they are not subject to a prohibition” women are not subject to a prohibition against wasting seed, just as they do not have an obligation to procreate. See commentary of Tosafot to b. Nid. 13a, b. Yeb. 12b.

  21. David Brodsky, A Bride Without a Blessing: A Study in the Redaction and Content of Massekhet Kallah and Its Gemara, Texts and Studies in Ancient Judaism 118 (Mohr Siebeck, 2006), 160, n. 104; Kessler, Conceiving Israel, 108; Reuven Kiperwasser, “‘Three Partners in a Person’: The Genesis and Development of Embryological Theory in Biblical and Rabbinic Judaism,” Lectio Difficilior 10 (2009).

  22. Although this tradition is introduced with the formula תנו רבנן (tanu rabbanan), “our rabbis taught” (its later parallel in Kohelet Rabbah 5:10 reads “tanni”), implying it is a Tannatic tradition, this attribution has been questioned by scholars. See Michael Higger, Ozar Ha-Baraitot in Ten Volumes (NY, 1942), 5:57; Michael Higger, Ozar Ha-Baraitot (NY, 1943), 6:448; Reuven Kiperwasser, “‘Three Partners in a Person’ The Genesis and Development of Embryological Theory in Biblical and Rabbinic Judaism,” Lectio Difficilior 10 (2009).” The Yerushalmi parallel (y. Kil’aim 8:4 [31c]) is not presented as a baraita, and lacks explicit reference to seed. Kiperwasser, “Three Partners in a Person,” n. 15, argues that this tradition was originally about respect for parents and God (see b. Kiddushin 30b) and later applied to conception.

  23. The description of the mother’s contribution “red substance” resonates particularly with the Aristotelian model, in which women’s menstrual blood is shaped by the male seed. It also parallels Hippocratic pangenesis, since each parent transmits material derived from all parts of the body. Thomas Laqueur, Making Sex: Body and Gender from the Greeks to Freud (Harvard University Press, 1990), 39.

  24. The text in both Berachot and Niddah has variants, and I’ve chosen one that appears in Munich 95 as well as other manuscripts in both. Alternatively, some texts read Rabbi Isaac in the name of Rabbi Ami, both Babylonian sages who immigrated to Israel and appear together in both Talmuds. Michael Satlow prefers this reading and concludes that the view that a woman’s emission of seed first results in a male child is attributed only to Land of Israel sages. Michael L. Satlow, Tasting the Dish: Rabbinic Rhetorics of Sexuality (Society of Biblical Literature, 1995), 304. Other manuscripts have Rabbi Isaac the son of Rabbi Ami, which Joshua Levinson prefers. See Joshua Levinson, “Cultural Androgyny in Rabbinic Literature,” in From Athens to Jerusalem: Medicine in Hellenized Jewish Lore and in Early Christian Literature, ed. Samuel Kottek and Manfred Horstmanshoff (Erasmus, 2000), 124 n. 32. Irrespective of which version is correct, the view that the mother emits seed appears only in the Bavli. A similar statement is cited in b. Niddah 71a in the name of R. Hama b. R. Ḥaninah, a Land of Israel sage.

  25. This tradition clearly assumes the literal meaning of the phrase. A related (purported) baraita immediately follows, similarly asserting that both parents emit seed and that the sex of the child depends on whose emission occurs first and bringing biblical prooftexts for support. See also b. Niddah 25b, 70b–71a; b. Bava Kamma 92a; b. Berakhot 54a, 60a where R. Isaac’s dictum challenges a baraita that links gender selection to prayer and hence divine intervention. A similar assumption underlies b. Ḥulin 69a regarding animals. That female seed can determine the sex of the child further parallels Hippocratic texts, although Hippocrates maintains that the resulting sex depends on which seed is stronger. See Hippocrates, On the Generating Seed and the Nature of the Child, 6–7, see “On Generation” 4:1, “if her desire for intercourse is excited, she emits semen before the man” (Paul Potter, ed., Hippocrates, vol. X of Loeb Classical Library (Harvard University Press, 2012), 12–13; Van der Horst, “Sarah’s Seminal Emission: Hebrews 11:11 in the Light of Ancient Embryology,” 210.)

  26. Here Nahmanides interprets the Sages along the lines of Aristotle, and not Hippocrates and Galen. That said, he continues by ascribing a somewhat different view to “the Greeks”:

    ועל דעת פילוסופי היונים: כל גוף העובר מדם האשה, אין בו לאיש אלא הכח הידוע בלשונם היולי, שהוא נותן צורה בחומר...
    But according to the Greek philosophers, the embryo’s entire body is from the blood of a woman, and that the male only has the power known in their language as hū́lē (ῡ̔́λη), which gives form to matter….

    This is also how R. Abraham Ibn Ezra understands the Greek science:

    אבן עזרא ויקרא יב:ב ועל דעת חכמי יון: שהזרע לאשה, וזרע הזכר מקפיא, וכל הבן מדם האשה.
    Ibn Ezra, Lev 12:2 And according to the Greek sages, that the seed is the woman’s, and the male see only contributes the form (lit. “congeals”), the son is formed entirely by the blood of the woman.

    R. Elazar ben Matatya, in his commentary on Ibn Ezra (ad loc.), notes that Ibn Ezra gets his term for “form” from Job:

    איוב י:י הֲלֹא כֶחָלָב תַּתִּיכֵנִי וְכַגְּבִנָּה תַּקְפִּיאֵנִי.
    Job 10:10 You poured me out like milk, congealed me like cheese.

    He then continues by trying to explain how this mechanism works for determining gender:

    ר' אלעזר בן מתתיה על אבן עזרא ויקרא יב:ב ואם ישאל השואל: הלא כל דבר מוליד בדומה, ואיך תוליד האשה זכר והאיש נקבה אם הוא כדברי רבותינו? התשובה "אשה מזרעת תחלה" זרעה הוא החומר וזרע האיש המקפיא הוא הצורה, והוא נותן צורה (בראשית ה:ב) "בדמותו כצלמו". ומוליד בדומה לו זכר. וכן בהפך: "איש מזריע תחלה" זרעו הוא החומר, וזרע האשה נותן צורת נקבה בדומה לה.
    R. Elazar ben Matatya on Ibn Ezra Lev 12:2 And if one were to ask: Doesn’t everything reproduce according to its own appearance? So how can a woman cause the birth of a male or a man cause the birth of a female, if the rabbis are correct? The answer: “If a woman ejaculates first” her seed is the substance, and the male seed is the congealer, i.e., the form, and it gives a form (Gen 5:2) “according to its likeness, its image,” so it produces a male like him. And the same goes for the inverse: “If a man ejaculates first,” his seed is the substance, and the woman’s seed gives the form of a woman in her likeness.

    It is doubtful, however, that this creative interpretation is in line with what Ibn Ezra and Nahmanides understood as the Greek theory. See also Ibn Ezra to Genesis 17:17 where he states that embryos are formed from the woman’s blood. On scientific discourse in Ibn Ezra’s commentary, see David Biale, “Philosophy and Exegesis in the Writings of Abraham Ibn Ezra,” Comitatus: A Journal of Medieval and Renaissance Studies 5 (1974): 43–62.

  27. He is correct but the rabbis did not know that.

  28. This was due to the influx of Nestorian refugees from Edessa in the Byzantine Empire in 431, which included many physicians. By the sixth century, Sasanian medical knowledge was thoroughly Hellenized. Andrea Pfister and David Bellamy, World Medicine: Plants, Patients and People (Blackwell Pub, 1992), 90.

  29. In recent years, scholarship championed by Yaakov Elman has demonstrated many affinities, shared institutions, and theologies common to the Babylonian Talmud and Middle Persian texts. See Shai Secunda, The Iranian Talmud: Reading the Bavli in Its Sasanian Context (University of Pennsylvania Press, 2014), for an introduction to the field of Talmudo-Iranica.

  30. See Kiperwasser, “Three Partners in a Person.”

  31. See Susruta-Samhita, ed. and trans. Priya Vrat Sharma (Varanasi, Chaukhambha Visvabharati, 2001), vol. 2, part 2, Sarirasthana (section on human body): 3 (On the descent of the embryo).

  32. All citations from the Bundahišn are from the Middle Persian Dictionary Project, English translation by Domenico Agostini.

  33. The Avesta was transmitted orally for almost two millennia and was only written down after Zoroastrian priests created an alphabet in the mid-sixth century. For other instances in which Bavli formulations parallel those found in the Bundahišn, see Reuven Kiperwasser and Dan Shapira, “Irano-Talmudica I: The Three-Legged Ass and Ridya in B. Taanith—Some Observations about Mythic Hydrology in the Babylonian Talmud and in Ancient Iran,” AJS Review 32 (2008): 101–16.

  34. Treatise on the Generation of Animals, Peck, Aristotle, 726b–272a..

  35. Aristotle repeatedly equates menstrual blood with semen in this way. See Sophia M. Connell, Aristotle on Female Animals: A Study of the Generation of Animals (Cambridge University Press, 2016), 103–4 for a list of references. Historia Animalium (634b29–39; 636a4–8).

  36. The Bavli (b. Niddah 20a) also introduces the concept of dam ḥimud, “blood of desire”: uterine bleeding triggered by sexual arousal. In this conception, male and female bodies mirror one another, each possessing a generative substance whose emission carries both biological and halakhic significance. See b. Niddah 20b. Aristotle’s History of Animals book VII, part 2, likewise describes the appearance of extra “katamenia” or menstrual blood reappearing multiple times in a month due to “excessive desire.” (D’arcy Wentworth Thompson, ed., History of Animals (Aeterna Press, 2015), bk. VII, p. 3.)

  37. E.g. m. Niddah 1:1,2; 2:2; 8:3; 9:1,2; 10:1.

  38. While the second half, introducing the notion of sensation, is presented as part of Shmuel’s statement, some have argued that it is a later addition and Shmuel’s actual ruling is concerned with the location of where the bloodstain is found; Ayelet Hoffman Libson, Law and Self-Knowledge in the Talmud (Cambridge University Press, 2018), 81–88; Adiel Cohen, “The Law of Menstrual Sensation: A Re-examination,” Netuim 10 (2003): 41–47. As Cohen notes, the dissonance between the two halves of Shmuel’s statement was already observed by the 18th-century Rabbi Ezekiel Landau (Noda be’Yehuda, Yoreh De’ah I:55). The precise author of this rule is secondary for my discussion.

  39. See e.g. Maimonides Mishneh Torah: Isuri Biah 5:17; Tosafot b. Nid. 3a s.v. margasha; Tosafot HaRid b. Nid. 57b s.v. amar; Terumat Hadeshen 246; Aruh Hashulhan Yoreh De’ah 183: 47–48; Responsa of R. Moshe Schick Maharam Schick: Yoreh De’ah, 177; R. Eliezer Waldenberg, Ziz Eliezer 6:21.

  40. Lit. amah, (forearm, cubit) referring to the shaft of the penis.

  41. Tirzah Meacham, “Women Are Not Susceptible to Arousal,” in To Be a Jewish Woman, ed. Tova Cohen (Kolech, 2013), 153–68.

  42. Leviticus structures male ejaculation and female menstruation as parallel impurities (ch. 15), just as it pairs zav and zava (men and women experiencing abnormal genital emissions). Menstrual blood is thus construed as the female analogue to semen. Meacham, “Women Are Not Susceptible to Arousal.” See also b. Niddah 13a, where an explicit connection is made between רגש and arousal, though the anonymous redactors seem to draw a different conclusion than that of Shmuel’s dictum.