Why Deuteronomy Matters to Jews Today

Viewing the Divine as transcendent and without a physical presence in the world, the authors of Deuteronomy recast earlier stories to show that the Torah—and by extension God—is nonetheless “very close to you.”

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Why Deuteronomy Matters to Jews Today." TheTorah.com, July 27, 2014. https://www.thetorah.com/article/why-deuteronomy-matters-to-jews-today.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Why Deuteronomy Matters to Jews Today" (2014, July 27). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/why-deuteronomy-matters-to-jews-today

Why Deuteronomy Matters to Jews Today

Law concept. Sebastian Duda - 123rf

Categories:

Devarim

Published: July 27, 2014

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. [1] For this phrase, see Deuteronomy 17:18 and Joshua 8:32. In both of these contexts, however, it most likely means “a copy of the torah,” and the referent of torah is not clear.

  2. [2] Translations that are not my own are taken from Robert Alter’s The Five Books of Moses (with slight adjustments).

  3. [3] Jeffrey Tigay also analyses this passage in, “Preserving Multiple Opinions,” TheTorah (2014). Tigay emphasizes the differences in the characteristics ascribed to the judges in each of the sources as I have done here. He points out the Deuteronomic emphasis on Wisdom and explains that even when we assume that the sources are in fact the work of different authors, it still may be a matter of emphasis, “This aspect of Deuteronomy reflects a viewpoint that places a premium on cultivating the intellect, whereas the E source emphasizes qualities of character. This is a matter of emphasis; there is no reason to believe that either source would wish to negate the other.” Tigay further describes the strong Jewish religious traditions of preserving partial truths. I very much agree with Tigay on this last point and find the idea spiritually meaningful. However, in the spirit of my own teacher Israel Knohl, I would like to take this analysis a few steps further. First, I believe that some inconsistencies may not be only a matter of emphasis but rather reflect deeper conflicting ideas about what is important and what is true. Second I have tried to take the theological conversation a step beyond. In quoting Rosensweig, Tigay lays out the theological significance of the preservation of partial truths, the conversation there seems located on the level of redaction. Like Knohl in his book The Divine Symphony, I attempted to also consider the theology that may lie behind the worldview of the biblical writers themselves, not just the redactor.

  4. [4]This passage in chapter 12 contains the famous “centralization of worship” that is a central part of the Deuteronomic religious reform. This phrase לשכן שמו שם appears many times throughout the book, including 17:2, 11. The analysis of this particular idea of the divine is subject of the scholarly debate around “name theology.” Many scholars including Gerhard von Rad in his Studies in Deuteronomy (1947), and Moshe Weinfeld in Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomic School (1972) maintained that this view presented a radical shift in belief in the notion of the divine. Early proponents of this theory tended to point to a “progression” from a more “primitive” notion of the divine to a more “advanced” conception. In Von Rad this is explicit, in Weinfeld it is implied. Contemporary scholars have questioned this somewhat judgmental categorization and tend to present the Deuteronomic view simply as one of several different ideas of the divine that existed in ancient Israel.

  5. [5] The blessings and curses at the end of the book (citation) are important to consider here, for there are clear divine consequences for disobeying the law. I am not, therefore, maintaining that God is not present in the Deuteronomic world view, such an assertion would be absurd. What I would like to say is that here divine will is not particularly mysterious or cult related rather it has often to do with “doing the right thing” like not accepting bribes, not cursing one’s parents, not subverting the rights of the stranger etc., as stipulated in chapter 27. The blessings and curses in chapter 28 are definitely concrete. For not obeying one will suffer a lack of food, health, offspring, independence and more. However, a careful look at this list reveals that many of these bad things are a result not of God’s presence entering and actively enacting punishment but rather they are the result of the withdrawal of God from the place where God is supposed to be – as the driving force behind natural and political dynamics.