Islam

Ishmael: Prophet in the Quran, Outcast in the Bible?

Ishmael: Prophet in the Quran, Outcast in the Bible?

The Quran presents Ishmael as a prophet who helped Abraham raise the foundations of the Kaʿba in Mecca. In the Bible, God blesses him to become a great nation, and it is clear that Abraham loves him. Yet, at Sarah’s demand, he is banished to the wilderness. Some midrashim explain this by portraying Ishmael as an idol worshiper or imagining him trying to shoot Isaac with an arrow. But do these interpretations reflect a straightforward reading of Ishmael’s character? And after the expulsion, does he remain an outcast from his family?

The Role of Angels in the Creation of Humankind

The Role of Angels in the Creation of Humankind

“Let us make humankind” (Genesis 1:26)—whom is God addressing? Across Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, some interpreters have identified God’s audience as the angels but have assigned them strikingly different roles in humanity’s creation: collaborators, creators, or critics who question the wisdom of bringing humans and their corruption into existence.

The Trinity: Medieval Jewish and Muslim Critiques

The Trinity: Medieval Jewish and Muslim Critiques

Muslim scholars like Qadi Abd al-Jabbar, Ibn Hazm (11th c.), and Salih b. al-Husayn al-Gafari (13th c.), and Jewish scholars like Ibn Ezra, Joseph Kimchi (12th c.), Hasdai Crescas, and Profiat Duran (14th c.) viewed the Trinity as a troubling departure from pure monotheism. Spurred by religious competition that was often intertwined with political competition or coercion, they sought to refute it, drawing on philosophy, the Hebrew Bible, and even the New Testament.

The Queen of Sheba’s Hairy Legs

The Queen of Sheba’s Hairy Legs

In the Bible, the Queen of Sheba is an unnamed foreign visitor to Solomon’s court. How did she later become a paradigmatic religious convert, Solomon’s wife, and the mother of Nebuchadnezzar and Menelik I, the founding figure of the Ethiopian royal court? The answer begins in the Qur’an.

The Covenant of the Pieces: A Promise for All Generations?

The Covenant of the Pieces: A Promise for All Generations?

After Abram expresses doubt that Sarai will have children and questions how he can be sure his descendants will inherit the land, YHWH establishes the Covenant of the Pieces, lasting 400 years, extending through Israel’s time in Egypt up to their entry into the land. Does this covenant hold lasting significance for later generations, or is it replaced by God’s “everlasting” Covenant of Circumcision?

Ahad Ha’am’s Cultural Zionism: Moses in the Shadow of Jeremiah and Muhammad

Ahad Ha’am’s Cultural Zionism: Moses in the Shadow of Jeremiah and Muhammad

In his famous essay on Moses, Asher Ginsberg (Ahad Ha’am 1856–1927), an influential Zionist thinker, recasts the revelation at the burning bush as Moses encountering his internal voice. His heroic Moses is shadowed by other, more melancholic figures, such as Jeremiah, and even Muhammad, as imagined by Thomas Carlyle. Rather than a figure of strength and power, Ahad Ha’am’s Moses comes to express the anxieties and ambivalences of early Zionism.

Nimrod: The Making of a Nemesis

Nimrod: The Making of a Nemesis

Genesis describes Nimrod as a great hunter before YHWH and a powerful king. In late Second Temple writings, Nimrod is connected to the Tower of Babel and seen as a rebel against God. This negative view of Nimrod persisted through the centuries in the writings of the Church Fathers, and was further expanded in rabbinic midrash and medieval Islamic literature.