Photo by TheTorah ©
A Faith that Includes Doubt – Psalm 27
The psalm of the High Holiday season begins with the words “God is my light and my salvation,” moves to expressions of distress about God’s absence, and ends with a statement of hope. The psalm’s unexpected direction models the maturing of an authentic relationship with God.
Published: January 4, 2017
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
[1] Psalm 27 was added to the liturgy for the months of Elul and Tishrei in the Middle Ages. Not all rites have it, and variations exist not simply between the five main liturgical rites of the Jewish people (Ashkenazic, Eidot Hamizraḥ/Sephardic, Italian, Yemenite, and Romani) but within these rites. Thus most Ashkenazim recite it every morning and every evening during this period, but in the western Ashkenazic rite it is recited only in the mornings, and it is omitted entirely in the rite of the Vilna Gaon. In the Italian rite it varies: in the Roman sub-rite, it is recited once a day during these months, but in the Milanese sub-rite, it is not recited at all. It is not recited in most versions of the Yemenite rite. In some Eidot Hamizraḥ rites one recites it after Shaḥarit and before Arvit all year long, not just in Elul-Tishrei; but Spanish-Portuguese Jews never recite it as part of their regular liturgy, whether in Elul-Tishrei or the rest of the year. For a much more detailed treatment of the recitation of Psalm 27, see Moshe Hallamish, Studies in Kabbalah and Prayer (Beer Sheva: Ben Gurion University Press, 2012), 175–185 [Hebrew].
[2] I translate that way because קוה means “to await expectantly,” “to wait for,” and I worry that English “hope” loses the sense of waiting expectantly for something or someone. In English we often say, “I hope that XYZ.” In biblical Hebrew, the object of קוה is not a clause (and thus an idea of its own) but usually a situation (like ישועה) or person (and that person is usually God). So my freer translation, “Hope that YHWH will come,” tries to recapture that a little.
[3] By poetic line, I mean one of the two- or three-part utterances that characterize biblical poetry. In my linear presentation of the psalm above, the second part of the line and third (if there is a third) are indented. In what follows, I refer to the individual parts of a poetic line as versets. Most ancient Hebrew poetic lines consist of two versets, but some consist of three versets. In our poem, three-verset lines are used to mark off the ends of the stanzas; we find the same use of three-verset lines in a poem that otherwise consists of two-verset lines at the end of the two stanzas of Psalm 19; see Benjamin Sommer, “Nature, Revelation, and Grace in Psalm 19: Toward a Theological Reading of Scripture,” Harvard Theological Review 108 (2015), 380.
[4] Both Rashi and ibn Ezra see the then-clause as appearing in the middle of the previous verse (vv. 12b-13a):
…כִּ֥י קָֽמוּ־בִ֥י עֵֽדֵי־שֶׁ֗֜קֶר וִיפֵ֥חַ חָמָֽס לוּלֵ֗א הֶ֭אֱמַנְתִּי לִרְא֥וֹת בְּֽטוּב־יְ-הוָ֗ה…
…False witnesses would have risen against me with unfair, violent testimony if I had not been confident that I would see YHWH’s goodness…
But this means that the then-clause would begin with כי, which seems unlikely, since כי can mean “if.” Granted, we could sensibly translate כי here as the adverb “indeed,” a meaning it can have in biblical Hebrew. But beginning a then-clause with a word that typically introduces an if-clause would have invited confusion. Further, the clause at the end of the previous verse is the second verset of one poetic line, while our if-clause in verse 13 is the first verse of a new poetic line. A single compound sentence spread over the last verset of one line and the first verset of another would be highly irregular for biblical poetry, which by and large shuns enjambment and overwhelmingly prefers end-stopping. (On the rarity of enjambment in biblical poetry, see F.W. Dobbs-Allsopp, On Biblical Poetry [New York: Oxford University Press, 2015], 44–8, 135–9; Yaakov Kaduri, “Biblical Poetry: How Can It Be?” [in Hebrew] in The Literature of the Hebrew Bible: Introductions and Studies, [ed., Zipora Talshir; Jerusalem: Yad Ben-Zvi Press, 2011], 297–98.)
[5] Sigmund Mowinckel, followed by various commentators such as Peter Craigie and Marvin Tate (in Psalms 1–50, 2d. ed. [N.p.: Thomas Nelson, 2004], 234) , argues that this line was uttered by a prophet, a priest, or a Levite at the Temple. See Sigmund Mowinckel, The Psalms in Israel’s Worship, 2 vols., trans. D.R. Ap-Thomas (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1962), 2:59. Both Mowinckel and Joachim Begrich argue that Temple functionaries would regularly issue responses on God’s behalf to the entreaties of worshipers, though in most cases these responses are not preserved in the psalms themselves. See Joachim Begrich, “Das Priesterliche Heilsorakel,” Zeitschrift für die alttestamentliche Wissenschaft 52 (1934): 81–92. A whole literature has developed around this issue; of particular import for confirming Begrich’s original insight is Jonas Greenfield, “The Zakir Inscription and the Danklied,” in Al Kanfei Yonah: Collected Studies of Jonas C. Greenfield on Semitic Philology, ed. Shalom Paul, Michael Stone, and Avital Pinnick (Jerusalem: Magnes Press, 2001) 1:75–92. Our verse at the end of this psalm may be one of the rarer cases where a prophetic or priestly oracle is in fact preserved in the biblical text.
[6] For a similar case, see the beginning and ending of Psalms 103 and 104, where the worshiper addresses the worshiper’s own soul.
[7] Robert Alter, The Book of Psalms: A Translation with Commentary [New York: W. W. Norton, 2007], 94
[8] John Goldingay, Psalms 1–41 [Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker Academic, 2006], 400.
[9] On this extreme nature of this contrast at verse 7, see Jacob (Gerald) Blidstein, “T’hillim 27,” Yavneh Review, Spring 1965, 21–23; Ellen Charry, Psalms 1–50 (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Publishing Group, 2015), 139–41.
[10] For this response, see Hermann Gunkel, Die Psalmen (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1968), 112–18.
[11] See Craigie and Tate, Psalms 1–50, pp. 230-31.
[12] Rolf Jacobson captures something crucial about the alleged gulf between the two parts of the psalm when he writes that the psalm “speaks words of fear. And words of trust. The two are not as far removed from one another as one might imagine.” See Nancy deClaissé-Walford, Rolf Jacobson, and Beth LaNeel Tanner, The Book of Psalms (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2014), 242.
[13] Blidstein, “T’hillim 27,” 22.
[14] Goldingay, Psalms 1–41, 392. He further points out (391) that the first stanza’s “appearance of confidence is compromised by the fact that most of its lines have the short second cola more characteristic of a lament.” Indeed, the second verset of the first five lines of the poem are all quite negative.
[15] Harris Birkeland, “Die Einheitlichkeit von Ps 27,” Zeitschrift für die alttestamentliche Wissenschaft 51 (1933): 218.
[16] On this term, see endnote 3.
[17] Gunkel further points out that v. 6 contains a vow, which is a standard way of ending a complaint song, while v. 7 begins like a classic psalm of complaint and plea. All this, he argues, shows that one poem ends in 6 while another begins in 7; see Gunkel, Psalmen, 114 and 116, and cf. Hermann Gunkel, Introduction to Psalms: The Genres of the Religious Lyric of Israel, completed by Joachim Begrich, trans. James D. Nogalski (Macon, Ga.: Mercer University Press, 1998), 177, 184. But Birkeland, “Einheitlichkeit,” 219, points out that to define v. 6 as an ending and v. 7 as a beginning on the basis of this formal criterion puts the cart before the horse. We can agree that v. 7 must be a new beginning and cannot be a middle, or that 6 must be an ending, only if we put the psalm into a procrustean form-critical bed. Indeed, Birkeland points out (220), this is not the only psalm where vows or pleas appear in unexpected places: in Ps 9:15 we have a vow in the middle of a psalm, while in Psalm 42–43 (a song) the plea begins at 43:1, well into the poem. (Indeed, Gunkel himself noted that the vocative and plea that typically begin a complaint/plea do occur, albeit “far less frequently in other positions,” a circumstance that vitiates his claim in his commentary, p. 116; see Gunkel, Introduction, 152, and see esp. n. 13 there, in which Gunkel himself refers to Psalm 42–43.) Sigmund Mowinckel, Psalmenstudien (Amsterdam: P. Schippers, 1966), 1:148, points out that the first we can simply regard Psalm 27 as an individual complaint/plea that has an unusually long statement of trust in its first six verses. Such an overdevelopment of statement of trust is atypical of biblical psalms but hardly impossible, as the similar case of Psalm 42–43 shows. Such a development is quite typical of Akkadian psalms of plea: they often begin with invocations and statements of trust that could have been psalms of praise on their own. Thus the first nine lines (out of a total of eighteen) of the plea to Shamash in Alan Lenzi, ed., Reading Akkadian Prayers and Hymns: An Introduction (Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2011), 197–216, read like a hymn to Shamash, but this does not mean that they are a different prayer from what follows; the hymn is a lengthy first element of the plea, at once acting as an extended vocative and an explanation for why the worshiper turns to Shamash. Similarly, the first nine lines (out of twenty-five) in the prayer to Marduk found in Lenzi, 313-25, are a well-structured hymn to Marduk (as demonstrated by Tzvi Abusch, “The Form and Meaning of a Babylonian Prayer to Marduk,” Journal of the American Oriental Society 103 [1983]), but that hymn is but a section of the longer plea psalm into which it is (Abusch shows) very well integrated at a literary-rhetorical level.
[18] It is not outside the realm of possibility that each of the two sections once existed on its own, and that an editor, noticing the elements that link them, deliberately put them together to form the single composition that is now Psalm 27. Even in that case, however, it behooves us to ask what the editor was attempting to accomplish by putting them together, and especially by putting them together in the order they now have.
[19] Alter, The Book of Psalms: A Translation with Commentary, 91.
[20] Blidstein, “T’hillim 27,” 23.
[21] Charry, Psalms 1–50, 139.
[22] In ancient Hebrew, the verb ב.ק.ר does not mean to visit or to come regularly to a particular place; that meaning of the verb develops only in modern Hebrew. Rather, in biblical, Qumran, and rabbinic Hebrew, this verb has a range of meanings relating to “carrying out important tasks.” It can mean “to examine, to check,” especially to examine sacrificial offerings so as to ensure that they are ritually appropriate. It can also mean “to be in charge, to take care of.” Thus in the Dead Sea Scrolls the מבקר is the official in charge of the community. In rabbinic Hebrew, the sense of “take care of” appears in reference to the sick in the well-known phrase, ביקור חולים. In modern Jewish parlance, this phrase is used to refer to visiting the sick, an ethically commendable action that generally involves dropping by to cheer up a sick person. But in ancient times, when there were no hospitals and few physicians, ביקור חולים had a different meaning: it denoted examining and taking of sick people, attending to their needs in the ways that medical professionals (especially nurses) and hospital staff members do today. Neighbors and relatives who performed the act of ביקור חולים in antiquity were not just coming over to chat. They fed and bathed the patient, applied ointments and salves to their sores, or prepared medicinal herbs for them. In modern Hebrew, the meaning of the verb לבקר extends much further, to include social visits, tourism, and vacations (one can מבקר Disney World, for example, without providing medicine for Micky Mouse or drugs for Donald Duck). This broader sense of the verb developed out of the much more specific meaning of the phrase in older forms of Hebrew. Thus, contrary to the NJPS translation (which renders our phrase, “to frequent His temple”), the worshiper in our verse is not asking to be able to stop in at the temple on frequent occasions. The worshiper wants to some responsibility that will keep him there permanently.
[23] Editor’s note: For an exploration of a similar theme in Jeremiah, see Andrea Weiss, “Jeremiah’s Teaching of the Trees,” TheTorah.com (2018).
[24] Charry, Psalms 1–50, 141.
[25] On the importance of this theme, see James Sanders, Torah and Canon (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1972), 50-51, 91-92.