Abraham Sends His Servant to Find a Wife for Isaac, then Disappears

Abraham tells his servant to go to his hometown to find a wife for Isaac. When the servant returns, he never reports back to him or introduces Rebecca to him. Why does Abraham disappear from the narrative? And, as Rebecca is his great-niece, why not send the servant to her father’s home directly?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Abraham Sends His Servant to Find a Wife for Isaac, then Disappears." TheTorah.com, November 17, 2022. https://www.thetorah.com/article/abraham-sends-his-servant-to-find-a-wife-for-isaac-then-disappears.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Abraham Sends His Servant to Find a Wife for Isaac, then Disappears" (2022, November 17). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/abraham-sends-his-servant-to-find-a-wife-for-isaac-then-disappears

Abraham Sends His Servant to Find a Wife for Isaac, then Disappears

Rebekah, Ernani Costantini, 1988. Wikimedia

Categories:

Chayei Sarah

Published: November 17, 2022

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. One of the story’s most obvious and problematic features is the tedious repetition of the events at the well in the servant’s plea to Rebecca’s family (vv. 34–49). Focus on this glaring problem has the effect of deflecting attention from the missing Abraham problem. See, for example, Nehama Leibowitz, Studies in the Book of Genesis in the Context of Ancient and Modern Jewish Bible Commentary, trans. Aryeh Newman (Jerusalem: Alpha Press, 1972) 230–238; George W. Savran, Telling and Retelling: Quotation in Biblical Narrative, Indiana Studies in Biblical Literature (Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 1988), 46–48.

  2. Indeed Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael says that we learn from Moses that a messenger should always return to the one who sent him to report (BaChodesh, Yitro 2). See also Rashi, Lekah Tov, and Sekhel Tov (Exod 19:8).

  3. According to Gen 21:5, Abraham was one hundred years old when Isaac was born, and according to Gen 25:20, Isaac was forty years old when he married Rebecca, making him only one hundred and forty years old when Isaac married Rebecca. As according to Gen 25:7, Abraham died at the age of one hundred and seventy-five, he would have lived another 35 years after this story’s conclusion. Indeed, the Abraham story continues after chapter 24. The Torah’s next chapter talks about how Abraham marries a woman named Keturah after Sarah’s death and fathers multiple children, but leaves his inheritance to Isaac, so his disappearance in chapter 24 is not a sign that the Torah is finished with his narrative.

  4. The quote is a translation from David Zvi Hoffmann, ספר בראשית [The Book of Genesis], trans. Asher Wasserteil (Bnei Brak: Netzah, 1971), 382; trans. from an unpublished German MS.

  5. Hermann Gunkel, Genesis, trans. Mark E. Biddle, Mercer Library of Biblical Studies (Macon: Mercer University Press, 1997 [repr. from 1977]), 244; trans. from German, Genesis, 3rd ed. (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht, 1910 [orig. 1901]).

  6. Ibid.

  7. Claus Westermann, Genesis 12-36: A Commentary, trans. John J. Scullion S.J. (Minneapolis: Augsburg, 1985), 391; translated from German, Genesis: Kapitel 12–36, Biblischer Kommentar (Neukirchen-Vluyn: Neukirchener Verlag, 1981).

  8. Gunkel, Genesis, 244-45.

  9. While early material from this version may well be included throughout the story, it is difficult to isolate this material with confidence. For example, the name “Abraham” may have been added (twice) in verse 12 to what was once earlier material. Accordingly, the references to “my master” would refer to Isaac, as indeed implied by the parallel between “my master” and “your servant Isaac” in verse 14. The words “whose daughter are you” in verse 23a, together with the response to this question in v. 24, and the reference to it in v. 27, might also be secondary, with the surrounding elements of vv. 23, 25, 26, as part of the earlier source, which did not at all deal with Rebecca’s genealogy. Significantly, in the servant’s retelling of the events in vv. 47, it is solely the question and answer concerning Rebecca’s identity and genealogy that appears. It also seems extremely likely that verse 30 is secondary. There is little need for a second reference to Laban’s approach to the servant and arrival at the well after it was reported in verse 29. The purpose of the addition is to insist that Laban was not genuinely hospitable, but was only acting out of greed. The effect of this addition is to harmonize the originally positive presentation of Laban in the story with the negative one in the further chapters of Genesis.

  10. The one exception is v. 59b, which appears to be redactional on independent grounds. The verse mentions how Rebecca brought along her wet-nurse. There seems little reason for a marriage age girl/woman to bring her former wet-nurse with her, and the reference seems to be a late addition, to prepare the reader for Gen 35:8, which speaks of the death and burial of Rebecca’s wet-nurse in Canaan. (If Rebecca didn’t bring her from Haran, how did she get there?) As this was a late gloss, the redactor used the preferred term of the chapter, “Abraham’s servant.”

  11. There are some other somewhat incongruous aspects of this final section of the narrative that are worth noting. For example, aside from the cryptic reference to Rebecca’s “mother’s house” in verse 28, it is only in verses 53 and 55 that Rebecca’s mother actually appears and speaks, though she remains nameless. And Laban is no longer referred to by name, but only as “her brother.” Again, only in verse 61 do we hear that Rebecca was an aristocratic lady with a full entourage of “maidens.” It is at least a bit surprising that such a highbred lady would go, unaccompanied, to the common well of the city, and personally draw water and provide drink to a stranger and his camels. Finally, verses 59–60 reads, “So they sent their sister Rebecca on her way, along with her nurse… And they blessed Rebecca and said to her, “Our sister, may you increase to thousands upon thousands; may your offspring possess the cities of their enemies.” This gives the impression that several anonymous brothers or kinsmen were involved in the marriage negotiations, though we hear nothing of them until this point. At least some of these distinctive features may be rooted in the assumed early tradition. (It may be noted, however, that verse 61a, which presents Rebecca’s maidens as traveling on the [ten] camels [cf. v. 10], coincides poorly with the idea that the servant was accompanied by an entourage of “men” (cf. vv. 32, 54, 59). How did these men travel back to Canaan if Rebecca’s maidens traveled on the camels? Perhaps v. 61b, “the servant took Rebecca and went” is a parallel to v. 61a, and derives from the earlier version.)

  12. This essay deals mostly with the independence of Isaac from Abraham as seen through a critical analysis of Gen 26. I believe that the same situation adheres to the story of the “binding of Isaac” of Gen 22. Interpreters have long grappled with the strange fact that God’s demand that Abraham sacrifice Isaac contradicts his own promise that he would make of Isaac, the son of Sarah, a great nation. In my view, the original narrative spoke of an anonymous beloved son of an unknown mother, who was indeed sacrificed. There was nothing paradoxical about this demand, since this only son was never destined to be more than Abraham’s heir. Only at a secondary stage was this son identified with Sarah’s son, Isaac, the son of the covenant, and, accordingly, saved at the last moment. Similarly, the original covenant of circumcision in Genesis 17 did not include verses 15—21, which stipulate that the covenant would continue exclusively through Sarah and her son, Isaac. It conceived of Abraham as the father of a multitude of circumcised peoples rather than just one exclusive nation. I hope to expand on these ideas elsewhere in the future. For the independence of Abraham from the Isaac tradition note also the references to Abraham alone at, inter alia, Psalm 47:10; Isa. 51:2; Ezek. 33:23.

  13. We shall not consider here the question of whether or not Isaac and Jacob were once completely independent of one another. The figures are linked together, outside of Genesis, in Amos 7:9, 16, though they are not necessarily thought of there as father and son.

  14. Moreover, the final editor of Genesis 24 sought to present Abraham not only as Isaac’s father, but also as the source of all that was his (vv. 34–36), which is the same kind of editing we see in Genesis 26, which recasts Isaac’s success in digging wells as an act of re-digging his father, Abraham’s wells. In the original tradition of Genesis 24, the riches lavished upon Rebecca presumably derived from Isaac’s own, independent wealth.

  15. We first learn of Abram and Nahor as brothers in Genesis 11:26–27, where we also learn of Nahor’s marriage to Milkah (v. 29). Notably, when Terah heads out to Canaan, he brings Abram and Lot, but there is no mention of Nahor, even though in our chapter, Haran is described as Nahor’s city (Gen 24:10). (Presumably, this refers to the city of Abraham’s brother, Nahor, though it is strange that the city is not referred to as חרן, as it is in Genesis 27:43; 28:10; 29:4.)

  16. This does not necessarily mean that the content of the genealogy is a late invention. What is late, rather, is its presentation as a report that someone related to Abraham sometime after he buried his wife. On the other hand, the reference to the birth of Rebecca in verse 23a seems disruptive and may well belong to the hand of the editor.

  17. For another discussion of this problematic gloss, with a different solution to how it came about, see Zev Farber, “Who Was Rebecca’s Father?” TheTorah (2017).

  18. The servant’s repetition of this message later (v. 47) is also awkward.

  19. See Alexander Rofé, “An Enquiry into the Betrothal of Rebecca,” Die Hebraische Bibel und ihre zweifache Nachgeschichte: Festschrift Für Rolf Rendtorff Zum 65. Geburtstag, ed. Erhard Blum, Christian Macholz and Ekkehard Stegemann (Neukirchen-Vluyn: Neukirchener Verlag, 1990), 27–40.

  20. Indeed, we can see a difference between the opening of the story, in which Abraham sends his servant to his land and place of birth (vv. 4, 7), but not specifically to his father’s house. It was YHWH who led the servant to the house of Abraham’s kin (v. 27). Later, however, the servant presents Abraham as having instructed him to go specifically to his family and his father’s house (vv. 38, 40, 41). See discussion in Marty Lockshin, “A Wife for Isaac: From Abraham’s Hometown or Family?” TheTorah (2015). Of course, in the Priestly story of Jacob's marriage, he is sent specifically to marry a daughter of Laban. The importance of marrying into Abraham’s family only grew over time.

  21. This theme is especially dominant in Ezra-Nehemiah. Editor’s note: For some discussions of the intermarriage issue in the Second Temple period, see Jacob L. Wright and Tamara Cohn Eskenazi, “Contrasting Pictures of Intermarriage in Ruth and Nehemiah,” TheTorah (2015); David Glatt-Gilad, “The Prohibition of Joining the Assembly of the Lord,” TheTorah (2015); Laurie Pearce, “Jews Intermarried Not Only in Judea but Also in Babylonia,” TheTorah (2022).

  22. See Joseph Blenkinsopp, “Abraham as Paradigm in the Priestly History of Genesis,” JBL 128 (2009): 225–241; idem., Abraham: The Story of a Life, 7-11.

  23. Commentators have long wondered about where the father is in this story, and why he appears once and disappears again. For some discussion, see Zev Farber and Daniel M. Zucker, “Rebecca Ran to Her Mother’s Household - Where Was Her Father?” TheTorah (2017).

  24. This corresponds to what we find in the story of Jacob in the house of Rebecca’s brother, Laban (Gen 28-31). Though Laban is referred to in two Priestly verses as the son of Betuel (28:2, 5), the character Betuel never plays any active role in the narrative as a whole. Since Priestly literature is generally regarded as exilic or post-exilic, it seems probable that Betuel was chosen at a late stage to serve as the father of Rebecca and Laban in order to include them in the family of Abraham. See Westermann, Genesis 12-36, 386, who, on the basis of a literal understanding of Genesis 24:48 and 29:5, suggests that Laban and Rebecca were originally depicted as the direct son and daughter of Nahor. Farber (“Who Was Rebecca’s Father?”) adopts this same view. I am suggesting that this may well be the case, but that in the earlier layer, Nahor was not yet identified as Abraham’s brother.