The Revelation and Authority of a Participatory Torah

Symposium

The Revelation and Authority of a Participatory Torah

Authority Needs Language

By erasing the boundaries between Written and Oral Torah, and removing any clear content from God’s revelation of law, Sommer undermines the concept of authoritative halakha that he wishes to refine.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Authority Needs Language." TheTorah.com, January 4, 2017. https://www.thetorah.com/article/authority-needs-language.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Authority Needs Language" (2017, January 4). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/authority-needs-language

Published: January 4, 2017

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. And, I would add, commands that seem to be riddled with superstition, sexism, and ethnic pride will certainly not be regarded, by most modern individuals, as an expression of their autonomy. 

  2. See Rosenzweig, The Star of Redemption, trans. B. Galli, (Madison:  University of Wisconsin Press, 2005), pp. 190-2 and On Jewish Learning, ed. N. Glatzer, (Madison:  University of Wisconsin Press, 1955), pp. 83-4, 112-3, 122-4.

  3. Ibid, p.114.  Buber, criticizing Rosenzweig’s initially uses “command” for what Rosenzweig had called “law,” then sees that he has misunderstood Rosenzweig and amends his position (to something close to what Rosenzweig himself held).

  4. To be clear, a linguistic command need not be verbalized – we all know what a finger across the neck conveys, but a gesture like that bears meaning only among creatures who also use words, into which they can translate the physical act.

  5. For more on this, see my critique of nonverbal revelation on Alan Brill’s Kavvanah website.

  6. How to deal with unethical laws in the Torah—how can they be deserving of deference or embody what God has said?—is a problem that would require its own essay. I deal with this in Part IV (chapter 6, “Receiving Revelation”) of Samuel Fleischacker, Divine Teaching & the Way of the World: A Defense of Revealed Religion (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011), 374-400.