The Epistemic Standards of Biblical Scholarship
Sommer asks, “Can observant Judaism and modern biblical scholarship happily and honestly co-exist?” I’m concerned only with honesty, and will argue that Sommer’s theology fails to give an account of authoritativeness consistent with a commitment to biblical scholarship.
Published: January 4, 2017
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
This formulation is based on the account of Sommer’s theology in Jerome Yehuda Gellman’s This Was From God: A Contemporary Theology of Torah and History (Boston: Academic Studies Press, 2016) p. 160.
Sommer is clearly committed to the veridicality of the putative Israelite experience of revelation, but I am interested only in the historical implication, which does not include the claim of veridicality.
Gellman raised a version of this question in “Conservative Judaism and Biblical Criticism,” Conservative Judaism 59 (2007): 50-67.
p. 258, note 18
I am doubtful that sources as historically flawed as the biblical ones provide any evidence on their own for an historical claim, but if they do, it is “slight” and thus insufficient to warrant belief.
I wish to thank Yehuda Gellman for extensive discussion of my argument. His resistance to it has helped me sharpen it considerably.