Circumcision Set, Netherlands, ca. 1809-1814. Jewish Museum
Circumcision: Is the Foreskin a Defect?
Circumcision seemingly maims the body, yet ancient Jewish and rabbinic interpretation present it as actually perfecting the body.
Published: November 1, 2017
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
This is the 2nd installment in a series that looks at the evolution of circumcision from its biblical origins to early Jewish exegetical writings. The first piece is, David Bernat, “Circumcision as Purification,” TheTorah.com (2015).
These two terms, מום and תמים, are pivotal to much of our discussion herein. מום can connote a visible blemish or wound, a physical deformity or disability such as a gnarled hand or a limp, a sensory disability such as blindness or deafness, or even a character flaw, and it stands in binary opposition to תמים. Lev 22:21 best articulates the principle that any person, animal or object free of מום is by definition תמים:
תָּמִ֤ים יִֽהְיֶה֙ לְרָצ֔וֹן כָּל־מ֖וּם לֹ֥א יִֽהְיֶה־בּֽוֹ
To be acceptable, it must be תמים; there must be no defect in it.
The Torah’s locus classicus regarding human disability is Leviticus 21:16-24, which highlights the conditions that render a Priest ineligible for service or access to sacred space. (Note how the regulations regarding animals suitable for offering in Lev 22:17-25, Deut 15:19-23, and Mal 1:6-8 emphasize the same language and ideological framework; cf Num 19:2.) Similar usages in ancient Jewish texts include Rule of the Congregation 4QSa 2:5-9, Sifra Emor 3:1, and bSanhedrin 36b. Thus, תמים can refer to wholeness or integrity, physical moral or otherwise (See e.g. Josh 10:13 י֥וֹם תָּמִֽים, “a complete day.”) Note also that throughout Job and Psalms תם is used with the same meaning.
Cf. Gen. Rab. 46:5 and the clever pun on וּנְמַלְתֶּ֕ם “you shall circumcise” (Gen 17:11), in which the foreskin is called a נומי, a Greek term (νομή) meaning “body sore.”
This version, ascribed in the scholarship to the Priestly tradent (P), is a doublet of the Exod 3:1-4:17 burning bush pericope, credited to the JE or the pre-Priestly strand. Both narratives have Moses initially demurring. Editor’s note: For more discussion of this text, see David Frankel, “The Priestly Moses,” TheTorah.com (2015).
כבד similarly connotes physical disability in Gen 48:10 and Is 59:1.
See, Exodus Rabbah 1:26, Midrash Vayosha (Otzar HaMidrashim, p. 146), and TheArmeniam Apocrypha – History of Moses (J. Issaverdens ed., pp. 167-168).
See also, Deut 30:6; Jub 1:22; הבינינו in b. Berachot 29a
See also Ezek 16:30.
J. Hartley, Leviticus (Word Biblical Commentary 4: Waco, 1992), 469.
Note that Rashi, in his gloss on Exod 6:12 (s.v. arel sephatayim), offers a holistic interpretive framework for the foreskin metaphor that picks up where the LXX left off and anticipates Hartley’s explanation:
אטום שפתים. וכן כל לשון ערלה אני אומר שהוא אטום (ירמיה ו י) ערלה אזנם, אטומה משמוע, (ירמיה ט כה) ערלי לב, אטומים מהבין… ערלת בשר, שהגיד אטום ומכוסה בה….
Blocked (אטום) lips. So I understand all usages of ערלה as blockage. ‘Their ears are uncircumcised’ (Jer 6:10), blocked from hearing; uncircumcised of heart, blocked from understanding… uncircumcised of flesh—because the penis is blocked and covered by it {the foreskin]…
The figures appear in canonical order with the exception of Job. The list begins with Job because he had been the previous topic of conversation. The Rabbis here seem to make a stream of consciousness shift from a discussion of Job’s moral merits to the fact that he was born circumcised, leading to a digression about all the Biblical characters who were also born circumcised. See also, Isaac Kalimi, “‘He was Born Circumcised’: Some Midrashic Sources, Their Concept, Roots and Presumably Historical Context,” Zeitschrift für die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft 93 (2002), 1-12.
Our Jubilees passage shows some conceptual and ideological affinity to a section in the Qumran text referred to as the War Scroll (4QM 7:4-6) that delineates strict eligibility criteria for those who will join the ranks of the Sons of Light in the great eschatological battle. Those permitted in the muster must be תמימי רוח ובשר (perfect in spirit and body) due to the presence of Holy Angels within their forces.
See my entry “Circumcision” in the Dictionary of Early Judaism (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2009) for a discussion of this issue and a review of the relevant ancient sources and modern scholarship.
In the spirit of “plus ça change,” it is worth noting that the modern Anti-Circ movement borrowed from the Hellenistic playbook and has branded circumcision an act of violence perpetrated upon innocent infants. While many have pushed back by insisting on religious freedom, some in the Jewish and medical community have made the case for circumcision’s health benefits, echoing the ancient Jewish position articulated here, that circumcision corrects a defect.