Ruth in Boaz’s Field, Julius Schnorr von Carolsfeld (1794–1872).
Contrasting Pictures of Intermarriage in Ruth and Nehemiah
By comparing the aggressive approach of Nehemiah towards the foreign wives of the Judahites with the positive role of Ruth as a Moabite woman who married into an Israelite family, we can attempt to uncover the core messages about Jewish identity that the two texts have in common.
Published: May 21, 2015
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
In fact, it occurs on the fifteenth of the month in book Jubilees, similar to so many other biblical holidays. See the discussion in Jacob Wright’s TABS article, “Shabbat of the Full Moon.” See also Michael Segal’s TABS essay, “The Festival of Covenants,” for a discussion of Shavuot in Jubilees.
For more on this, see Evan Hoffman’s TABS essay, “Ezekiel’s Failure to Mention Shavuot.”
See Norman Solomon’s TABS essay, “Shavuot: How the Festival Grew,” as well as Michael Segal’s (op cit.).
Bible translations NRSV with minor adjustments.
David dying on Atzeret (=Shavuot) appears in j. Chagigah 2:3, and Ruth Rabbah 3:2.
In his David, King of Israel, and Caleb in Biblical Memory (New York: Cambridge Univ. Press, 2014), Wright shows how biblical author used war commemoration as a means of negotiating these issues of belonging, and how biblical narratives often provide readers with a basis for complicating simplistic application of the law. This idea is in line with current trends in Bavli studies with regard to about how the stam (unnamed editors) organized material, and specifically, the interplay between halacha and aggada. See, for example, Barry Scott Wimpfheimer, Narrating the Law: A Poetics of Talmudic Legal Stories (Divinations: Rereading Late Ancient Religion; Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2011).
See Pesikta de Rav Kahana “Nachamu” 16.1. Perhaps even more radical is the story in the Bavli about Amasa ben Yeter, who is purported to have threatened to stab anybody who did not accept that the court of Samuel the Prophet already decided that the law does not apply to Ammonite or Moabite women (b. Yebamot 77a). For more on this, see Tamara Cohn Eskanazi’s TABS essay, “Megillat Ruth: When Kindness Conflicts with Torah.”
For a nuanced example of this kind of comparison, focusing on the philosophical differences between the two works with regard to the nature of Israel, see Menachem Kellner’s TABS essay, “Ralbag’s Surprising Take on Ruth’s Conversion.”
Tamara Cohn Eskenazi and Tikva Frymer-Kensky, JPS Bible Commentary: Ruth (Philadelphia: JPS), 2012.
See discussion in Yonina Dor, Have the “Foreign Women” Really been Expelled? Separation and Exclusion in the Restoration Period (Jerusalem: Magness, 2002) [Hebrew].
See, Neil Glover, “Your People, My People: An Exploration of Ethnicity in Ruth,” JSOT 33 (2009): 293-313. Glover helpfully identifies stages in the construction of religious identity. Ruth herself expresses her commitment to Naomi with threefold categories: “Wherever you go, I go, . . . your people – my people; your God- my God.” (Ruth 1:16). Her journey begins with a unilateral commitment by her. But to be effective, it requires responses from Naomi, the people, and God. As the book of Ruth unfolds, the responses gradually emerge: Naomi comes to treat her as a daughter whose welfare she seeks (Ruth 3:1). The community as a whole (“and all the people” in Ruth 4:11) welcomes her with a blessing (Ruth 4:11-12), and God’s approval is signaled when with a unique phrasing in the Bible “God gave her pregnancy and she bore a son” (4:13). Although she was called a Moabite still in 4:10, the Moabite label drops in 4:13.
In truth, the issues in Ezra and Nehemiah are themselves different from each other—Ezra is concerned with זרע הקדש (holy seed)—but this is not the place to parse that out.
Neh 13:24.
See Shaye J. D. Cohen, The Beginnings of Jewishness: Boundaries, Varieties, Uncertainties (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1999).
For another example of this kind of thinking in biblical texts, see Jacob Wright’s TABS essay, “Redacting the Relationship to the Transjordanian Tribes: Kinship versus Commandment.”
See Menachem Kellner, op cit.