Esau and Jacob reconcile, Francesco Hayez, 1844. Wikimedia
Did Esau Marry 3, 4, 5, or 6 Women?
In the biblical narrative (Genesis 26, 28), Esau marries Judith, Basemath, and Mahalath. A later genealogical list of Edomite clans (Genesis 36) says that he married Adah, Aholibamah, and Basemath. To make sense of this contradiction, medieval commentaries offer creative backstories, yielding different tallies for the total number of Esau’s wives.
Published: December 3, 2025
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Bible translations are from NJPS with adjustments. The translations of commentators are a combination of mine and the editors, unless otherwise specified.
This article is a revised version of my more extensive paper, Reuven Chaim Klein, “The Wives of Esau,” Jewish Bible Quarterly 42:4 (2014): 211–220 and also includes some supplementary materials.
For more on him, see Avraham Grossman, חכמי צרפת הראשונים: קורותיהם, דרכם בהנהגת הציבור, יצירתם הרוחנית [The Early Sages of France: Their Lives, Leadership and Works] (Magnes, 1995), 347–411.
Rashi explains the unusual reference to Judith’s two fathers—Rashi is not open to Anah being a woman’s name in this verse—by suggesting that her paternity was in question due to incest:
רש"י בראשית לו:ב "בת ענה בת צבעון" – אם בת ענה לא בת צבעון, ענה בנו של צבעון, שנ' (בראשית לו:כד) "ואלה בני צבעון ואיה וענה." אלא בא צבעון על כלתו אשת ענה ויצאת אהליבמה מבין שניהם, והודיעך הכת' שכלם בני ממזרות היו.
Rashi Gen 36:2 “Daughter of Anah daughter of Zibeon”—If she is the daughter of Anah, she’s not the daughter of Zibeon. Anah is the son of Zibeon, as it says (Gen 36:24): “And these are the sons of Zibeon: Aya and Anah.” Rather, Zibeon slept with his daughter-in-law, the wife of Anah, and Aholibamah was born, daughter of one of them. And scripture is informing us that they are all mamzerim (bastard/illegitimate children).
Yet a third solution to the Beeri/Anah problem was suggested by Maharshal (Rabbi Shlomo Luria, 1510–1573) in his super-commentary to Rashi’s commentary called Yeriot Shlomo “The Curtains of Solomon.” He first attacks the Chizkuni’s problem that she is both a Hivite and a Hittite:
יריעות שלמה בראשית לו:ב - בא"ד לחתי ולחוי - נ"ב ומה שמקשין העולם, וגם רא"ם, למה כתב כאן "החוי" ולעיל "החתי"? י"ל לפי שאפשר ש"החוי" היה יותר אדוק בע"ז משאר בני אדם, ולעיל שינה שמה יהודית, כלומר שהיא כופרת בע"ז, וכאלו היא בתו של חתי, ודוק.
Yeriot Shlomo [“The Curtains of Solomon”] Gen 36:2 – Gloss: As to what the “world” asks, and R. Eliyahu Mizrahi [also asks] why here [Gen 36:2] is it written “the Hivvite” and above [Gen 26:34] “the Hittite”? There is room to answer that it is possible that this is because the “Hivvites” were more attached to idolatry than other peoples, and earlier [Esau] changed her name to Judith as if to say that she denies idolatry, [he also changed her national identity] as if she were a Hittite daughter [which implies less serious devotion to idolatry than if she were a Hivvite daughter].
He continues by saying that just as Esau pretended she was a Hittite, since it sounded better, he also gave her father a fake name, to avoid Isaac and Rebecca realizing that this was the infamous Anah:
ומה שמקשין העולם דהכא כתיב "בת ענה" ושם כתיב "בת בארי" י"ל נמי שאותה [אולי צ"ל שאותו] רשע כינה שמה "בת בארי" כלומר "בת ‘בְּאֵר לַחַי רֹאִי' (בראשית טז:יד, כד:סב, כה:יא)" לשבח, ולא בת ענה שהוא פסול והביא פסולים לעולם. מהרש"ל.
And as to what the “world” asks that it says here “Daughter of Ana” [Gen 36:2] and it says there [Gen 26:34) “Daughter of Beeri,” one may also answer that that that wicked man dubbed her name “daughter of Beeri” as if to say “daughter of Beer-Lehai-Roee” [an allusion to the placename of Hagar’s divine revelation, Gen 16:14, 24:62, 25:11] to praise her [for feigned righteousness deserving of divine revelation] and not “daughter of Ana” who was himself a bastard and brought bastards to the world. Maharshal.
The midrash itself reads:
מדרש שמואל יז רבי זעירא בעון ממנייא יתיה, ולא קבל עלוי. כיון דשמע כדא מתניתא חכם וחתן ונשיא הגדולה מכפרת, קיבל עליו.
Midrash Shmuel §17 Rabbi Zeira, when they wished to appoint him [head of the court], he refused. When he heard that which was taught “A sage, a groom, and a prince, their greatness atones for them,” he accepted.
חכם—"מפני שיבה תקום וגו'" (ויקרא יט:לב), וכתוב בתריה "וכי יגור איתך גר" (ויקרא יט:לג)—מה גר נמחל לו על כל עונותיו, אף זה נמחל לא על כל עונותיו.
Sage—“Rise before the gray-haired” (Lev 19:32), and it says afterwards, “if a ger (sojourner) live among you (Lev 19:33)—just as for a ger (convert), all their sins are forgiven, so too [the “gray haired” sage], all his sins are forgiven.
חתן—"וילך עשו אל ישמעאל ויקח את מחלת" (בראשית כח:ט). וכי מחלת שמה? והלא בשמת שמה?! אלא מלמד שמחלה לו על כל עונותיו.
Groom—“Esau went to Ishmael and took Mahalath” (Gen 28:9). Was her name Mahalath? Was it not Basemath?! Rather it teaches that [the marriage] made all of his sins forgiven (mahalah).
נשיא—"בן שנה שאול במלכו" (שמואל א יג:א). וכי בן שנה היה שאול כשמלך? אלא מלמד שמחלה לו על כל עונותיו ונעשה כתינוק בן שנה שלא טעם טעם חטא.
Prince—“Saul was one year old when he became king” (1Sam 13:1). Was Saul really one year old when he became king?! Rather this teaches that all his sins were forgiven, and he became like a one-year old child, who has never tasted the taste of sin.
Hebrew text from Berachyahu Lifshitz, מדרש שמואל [Midrash Shmuel] (Schechter Institute, 2009), 57–58 [in the main text]. For a brief overview of this work, see Anat Reizel, מבוא למדרשים [Introduction to the Midrashic Literature], 2nd ed., ed. Amnon Bazak (Tevunot Press-Herzog College, 5773 [2012/2013]; repr. of 5771 [2010/2011]), 271–280.
The glosses appear in his commentary on the verses in Toledot:
אבן עזרא בראשית כו:לד יהודית – שם, ולא הוליד ממנה.
Ibn Ezra Gen 26:34 “Judith”—a name, but he had not children with her.
ובשמת – היא עדה (בראשית ל"ו:ב'), והיו לה ב' שמות. ובמקרא נמצאים מהם למאות כזה הטעם.
“And Basemath”—this is Adah (Gen 36:2), and she had two names. In scripture there are hundreds like this.
אבן עזרא בראשית כח:ו ושמה בשמת (בראשית לו:ג) גם מחלת – כמו: יתרו שהוא, על דעתי, חובב (במדבר י:כט).
Ibn Ezra Gen 28:6 “And her name was Basemath” (Gen 36:3) and also Mahalath, like Jethro who is, in my opinion, Hobab (Num 10:29).
Translation (with adjustments) from Edward B.M. Browne (New York, 1876), available on Sefaria.
For other examples, see Editors, “What Do Genealogies Teach Us About Torah?” TheTorah (2013). The problem also exists between versions of the Torah. See, e.g., Itamar Kislev, “Jacob’s Descendants Who Go to Egypt: MT Versus LXX,” TheTorah (2015).