Two wooden cases containing the Torah scroll. Wikimedia
Do Biblical Laws Reflect a Tribal Society?
Was Israel ever a tribal society? Although some scholars accept the Bible’s depiction of Israel’s pre-monarchic society as a confederation of tribes, others have dismissed this as ahistorical. Can a study of biblical law help us resolve this question?
Published: September 12, 2019
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
Yohanan Aharoni suggested Tel Obeidiyeh south of the Sea of Galilee, while Nadav Na’aman has proposed Tel Shihab in Southern Syria. See Yohanan Aharoni, The Land of Israel in Biblical Times, A Historical Geography (Jerusalem: Bialik Institute, 1962), 162–163, 349 [Hebrew] and Nadav Na’aman, “Yano’am,” Tel Aviv 4 (1977): 166–177. Anson Rainey and William G. Dever agree with Na’aman. See, Anson F. Rainey and R. Steven Notley, The Sacred Bridge, Carta’s Atlas of the Biblical World (Jerusalem: Carta, 2006), 99; William G. Dever, Beyond the Texts, An Archaeological Portrait of Ancient Israel and Judah (Atlanta: SBL, 2017), 90. Both of these suggestions are for an area northeast of Gezer, showing Merneptah’s trajectory.
Similar to English where capital initials indicate a name, and in German capital initials indicate nouns. Meaning, read it as a name (English) or read it as a noun (German).
Most scholars locate Israel in the hundred small rural settlement in the Cisjordanian highlands, meaning between Gezer and Yano’am. An alternative suggestion has been put forth by Anson Rainey, locating them in the Transjordan, based on the assumption that the stele follows a geographical order. See Rainey and Notley, The Sacred Bridge, 99, but archaeologically speaking, this is difficult to justify.
Dever, Beyond the Texts, 119–247. Rainey has suggested a route that avoids the Israelites in the central highlands. Rainey and Notley, The Sacred Bridge, 99–100.
See Rainer Kessler, The Social History of Ancient Israel, an Introduction, trans., Linda M. Maloney (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2008), 40–62.
The classic approach has been to see the rise of the United Monarchy under David and Solomon as the beginning of Israelite statehood. See Dever, Beyond the Texts, 259–382. Others suggest that only with Omri in the 9th century did something like statehood emerge in the north (Israel), with the south (Judah) reaching this level of complexity even later. see Israel Finkelstein and Neil Asher Silberman, The Bible Unearthed, Archaeology’s New Vision of Ancient Israel and the Origin of Its Sacred Texts (New York: The Free Press, 2001), 142–145; Israel Finkelstein, The Forgotten Kingdom: The Archaeology and History of Northern Israel, Ancient Near Eastern Monographs 5 (Atlanta: SBL, 2013).
Scholars assume these were Israelites since their material culture differs from that of neighboring groups (Philistine and Canaanite) and is continuous with what eventually becomes the states of Israel and Judah. For a discussion of the material culture of this period, see Avraham Faust, Israel’s Ethnogenesis: Settlement, Interaction, Expansion and Resistance, Approaches to Anthropological Archaeology (London: Equinox, 2006).
To buttress the claim that the overall historical arc of clan to tribe to chiefdom to state is accurate, Abraham Malamat presented Mesopotamian cases in which the kings of Babylon and Assyria claimed tribal origin to their dynasties similar to the biblical account. It is noteworthy that similar to the Bible, some are fiction and some are geographical regions. See Abraham Malamat, ישראל בתקופת המקרא [Israel in Biblical Times] (Jerusalem: Bialik Institute, 1983), 24–45 [Hebrew].
More accurately, two of the tribes are sons of Joseph and the number of tribes is actually 13 when we include the Levites.
The natural growth of a population in the pre-industrial era is about 3%, thus the population of 70 people should have been about 150,000. The rabbis already noted that to produce two million would require women having constant sextuplets (Rashi on Exodus 1:7, based on the Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael).
The text does offer a list of tribal leaders that are not necessarily legendary war heroes, the so-called “minor judges” Tola, Yair, Ibzan, Elon, and Abdon, but no classical tribal leader activity is attributed to them either.
Max Gluckman, Politics, Law and Ritual in Tribal Society (Chicago: Aldine, 1965).
Ada Pecos Melton, “Indigenous Justice Systems and Tribal Society,” Judicature 79.3 (1995): 126–133.
Melton expands on this, arguing that state laws are “vertical,” meaning
[T]he power structure is upward, with decision making limited to a few. The retributive philosophy holds that because the victim has suffered, the criminal should suffer as well. It is premised on the notion that criminals are wicked people who are responsible for their actions and deserve to be punished.
She further writes that in state laws,
[P]unishment is used to appease the victim, to satisfy society’s desire for revenge, and to reconcile the offender to the community by paying a debt to society. It does not offer a reduction in future crime or reparation to victims.
Regarding restorative justice, Pecos Melton writes,
Restorative principles refer to the mending process for renewal of damaged personal and communal relationships. The victim is the focal point, and the goal is to heal and renew the victim’s physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual well-being. It also involves deliberate acts by the offender to regain dignity and trust, and to return to a healthy physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual state. These are necessary for the offender and victim to save face and to restore personal and communal harmony.
See, for example, Shabtai Levi, הבדוים במדבר סיני: דגם של חברה מדברית [The Bedouin in the Sinai Desert: Patterns of Desert Society] (Tel Aviv: Schocken, 1987); Sasson Bar-Zvi, מסורת השיפוט של בדווי הנגב: עיונים מבוססים על מגעים עם זקני הבדווים [The Judicial Tradition of the Negev Bedouins: Studies Based on Contact with the Bedouin Elders] (Tel Aviv: Israel Dept. of Security, 1991); Aref al-Aref, שבטי הבדואים במחוז באר-שבע [The Bedouin Tribes of the Beersheba District], trans. from Arabic by Menachem Kapeliouk (Boustenai Press, 1935). [This last book was written by the District Officer of the Beersheba region in Mandatory Palestine.]
For a look at this principle in comparison with Bedouin tribal law, see Yael Shemesh, “מידה כנגד מידה בחוק המקראי, בהשוואה לחוקי המזרח הקדום ולחוקי הבדווים” [Measure for Measure in Biblical Law, compared to the Laws of the Ancient Near East and Bedouin Law], Beit Mikra 60.2 (2015): 146–167. For a look at the pervasiveness of this concept in the Bible, see Yael Shemesh, “Punishment of the Offending Organ in Biblical Literature,” Vetus Testamentum 55.3 (2005): 343–365. Admittedly, David Wright argues that in the Torah, in contrast to the Laws of Hammurabi, the meaning of the law is not a literal cutting off of hand or gouging out of eye, but a monetary payment. See, David P. Wright, Inventing God’s Law: How the Covenant Code of the Bible Used and Revised the Laws of Hammurabi (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009), 182. Nevertheless, as Wright also believes the biblical law comes from the Laws of Hammurabi, even he would admit that this is not a natural development from tribal law but an adaptation of state law by scribes working for another state.
Editor’s note: For a discussion of how the laws of the Covenant Collection relate to the Laws of Hammurabi, see David P. Wright, “How Exodus Revised the Laws of Hammurabi,” TheTorah.com (2019).
Many scholars understand this punishment as a divine punishment, removal from the community by premature death. See, Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1-16, Anchor Bible (New York: Doubleday, 1991), 457-61; Donald J. Wold, The Biblical Penalty of Kareth (University of California at Berkeley dissertation, 1978). If so, then kareth is yet another death penalty, but with God as the executioner.
Editor’s note: For more on the polemic against vicarious punishment in the Bible, see Zev Farber, “Punishing Children for the Sins of their Parents,” TheTorah.com (2015).
Shemesh “Measure for Measure in Biblical Law,” 151
Shemesh, “Measure for Measure in Biblical Law,” 146, 151.
After the birth, the woman may stay in the offender’s house, but then the husband should pay a dowry.
We see a similar struggle in Islam, trying to negotiate tribal laws with the Shari’ah laws; see Norman Calder and Michael B. Hooker, “S̲h̲arīʿa”, in, Encyclopaedia of Islam, Second Edition, ed. P. Bearman, Th. Bianquis, C.E. Bosworth, E. van Donzel, W.P. Heinrichs (Leiden: Brill, 2012), 321–326.
For a broader discussion how biblical laws may be polemicizing with a more ancient system, see Bernard S. Jackson, “Reflections on Biblical Criminal Laws,” in Essays in Jewish and Comparative Legal History (Leiden: Brill, 1975), 25–63.