Ironing Out Israel’s Itinerary Through the Transjordan

The itinerary notes in Numbers 21 is a hodgepodge of styles and directions. Nevertheless, once we isolate each style, we find three separate itinerary lists, each from one of the standard Pentateuchal sources.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Ironing Out Israel’s Itinerary Through the Transjordan." TheTorah.com, July 12, 2016. https://www.thetorah.com/article/ironing-out-israels-itinerary-through-the-transjordan.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Ironing Out Israel’s Itinerary Through the Transjordan" (2016, July 12). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/ironing-out-israels-itinerary-through-the-transjordan

Ironing Out Israel’s Itinerary Through the Transjordan

The March of the Israelites through the wilderness. Foster Bible, Wikimedia

Categories:

ChukatMasei

Published: July 12, 2016

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Exod 12:37, 13:18, 20, 14:2, 15:22–23, 27, 16:1, 17:1, 19:1–2; Num 10:12, 33, 11:35, 12:16, 20:1, 22, 21:4, 10–13, 16,18b–20, 22:1.

  2. Bible scholars differ in their analysis of the literary connection between the itinerary list and the itinerary notes. Martin Noth suggested that the itinerary list is built from stations that appear in the itinerary notes in Exodus and Numbers, which he added to the itinerary of a single specific route. See Martin Noth, “Der Wallfahrtsweg zum Sinai,” PJB 36 (1940), 5–28; idem, Numbers: A Commentary (trans. J.D. Martin; OTL; Philadelphia: Westminster, 1968), 242–243. Other scholars, in contrast, regard the itinerary notes and associated events to be a literary expansion of the itinerary list. See Frank Moore Cross, Canaanite Myth and Hebrew Epic: Essays in the History of the Religion of Israel (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1973), 301–321, esp. 308–309; Graham I. Davies, The Way of the Wilderness: A Geographical Study of the Wilderness Itineraries in the Old Testament (SOTSMS 5; Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979), 59–60. For an additional list of scholars who held this view before the 1970s, see idem, “The Wilderness Itineraries and the Composition of the Pentateuch,” VT 33/1 (1983):1–13, esp. 8 n. 13.

  3. Kadesh, Mt. Hor, Oboth, Iye-abarim, the steppes of Moab (קדש, הר ההר, אבת, עיי העברים, ערבות מואב).

  4. Itinerary Notes

    Itinerary List

    1. דרך ים סוף
    2. אדום/הר שעיר (דברים ב)
    3. דרך מדבר מואב/במדבר אשר על פני מואב ממזרח השמש
    4. נחל זרד
    5. עבר ארנון
    6. באר
    7. מדבר
    8. מתנה
    9. נחליאל
    10. במות
    11. הגיא

    א. צלמונה
    ב. פונן
    ג. דיבון גד
    ד. עלמון דבלתימה
    ה. הרי העברים
    ו. על הירדן

  5. See Amitai Baruchi-Unna, Genres Meet: Itineraries, Prayers and Divine Messages in Assyrian Royal Inscriptions (Ph.D. diss., Hebrew University, 2009), 55, ll. 4–9; 60, ll. 13–16 [Hebrew].

  6. Angela R. Roskop, The Wilderness Itineraries: Genre, Geography, and the Growth of Torah (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 2011), 204–215. The original Priestly route, she maintains, led to the war with Arad (Num 21:1–3) and to the conquest of the Land of Israel from the south (193–203). This route underwent two redactions, the first to incorporate the war with Sihon and the second to incorporate the Balaam narrative. These redactions divert the journey route from the Negev to the heart of the kingdoms of Edom and Moab in the Transjordan (206–208). The third redaction was intended to give the impression that the route passed through the wilderness to the east of Moab (209–214).

  7. This supposition does not explain the sites: Dophkah and Alush (Num 33:12–14), Rithmah, Rimmon-perez, Libnah, Rissah, Kehelath, Mount Shepher, Haradah, Makheloth, Tahath, Terah, Mithkah, and Hashmonah (Num 33:18–30), and Zalmonah (41–42), that appear only in the itinerary list. Nor does it explain why the sites: the wilderness of Paran (Num 10:12; 12:16; 13:3, 26), wadi Zered (Num 21:12), the Arnon (v. 13), Beer (v. 16), Mattanah, Nahaliel, Bamoth, “the valley that is in the territory of Moab,” “the peak of Pisgah” (vv. 18–20), and Jahaz (v. 23), that appear in the itinerary notes, are not included in the itinerary list.

  8. This narrative continuity speaks against the viability of the supplementary approach here. For more on using narrative continuity to uncover the contours of the Pentateuch's sources, see, Baruch J. Schwartz, “The Torah – Its Five Books and Four Documents,” in The Literature of the Hebrew Bible: Introductions and Studies (ed. Z. Talshir; Jerusalem: Yad Ben-Zvi, 2011), 161–226, esp. 193, 213 (Hebrew) and Joel S. Baden, The Composition of the Pentateuch. Renewing the Documentary Hypothesis (New Haven/London: Yale University Press, 2012). Notably, two verses do not fit any of the above styles (Num 21:4, 11), but are a mixed style. These verses were composed when the compiler combined data from two different lists.

  9. Noting the literary connection between the three descriptions, and the linkage between the delegation to Sihon and that to the king of Edom (Num 20:14–21; Judg 11:17), many scholars sought to isolate directions of influence and the inner chronology between the descriptions. See W. A. Sumner, “Israel’s Encounters with Edom, Moab, Ammon, Sihon, and Og according to the Deuteronomist,” VT 18 (1968), 216–28; John van Seters, “The Conquest of Sihon’s Kingdom: A Literary Examination,” JBL 91 (1972): 182–97; John Raymond Bartless, Edom and the Edomites (JSOPSup 77; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 1989), 180–81. Nevertheless, their inquiries were generally limited to the historical and literary data, ignoring the list of sites and the geography—an oversight I wish to rectify here.

  10. The close similarity between the three versions of the Sihon narrative shows that they are based on a written document, the original E text, which was altered by various writers, but whose traces can be discerned by a comparison of the three portrayals. The lost opening verse to this account, which records the Israelites’ arrival in Kadesh, can be found in Jephthah’s speech (Judg 11:16b).

  11. See Roskop, Wilderness Itineraries, 144–149. She also takes pains to indicate all the verses that describe the Israelites who left Egypt as an army (150–152).

  12. Bacon identifies “Beer” in Numbers with “Beer-elim” in the Moab Pronouncement (Isa 15:8); see Benjamin Wisner Bacon, The Triple Tradition of the Exodus (Hartford, Conn.: The Students Publishing Company, 1894), 160; Jan Jozef Simons, The Geographical and Topographical Texts of the Old Testament (Leiden: Brill, 1959), 262, 436; John D. W. Watts,Isaiah 1–33 (WBC 24; Waco, Tex.: Word, 1985), 231. The attribution of both toponyms to Moab is not baseless. Likewise, the adjectival “elim” meant rulers/chieftains in Moab (Exod 15:15); and it was “chieftains” who dug the well (Num 21:18).

  13. LXX reads “and from the well (kαι ἀπὸ Φρέατος)” instead of “and from the wilderness,” and seems to be the more original in this case.

  14. במדבר כג:יג וַיֹּ֨אמֶר אֵ֜לָיו בָּלָ֗ק לך־לְכָה־נָּ֨א אִתִּ֜י אֶל־מָק֤וֹם אַחֵר֙ אֲשֶׁ֣ר תִּרְאֶ֣נּוּ מִשָּׁ֔ם אֶ֚פֶס קָצֵ֣הוּ תִרְאֶ֔ה וְכֻלּ֖וֹ לֹ֣א תִרְאֶ֑ה וְקָבְנוֹ־לִ֖י מִשָּֽׁם: כג:יד וַיִּקָּחֵ֙הוּ֙ שְׂדֵ֣ה צֹפִ֔ים אֶל־רֹ֖אשׁ הַפִּסְגָּ֑ה וַיִּ֙בֶן֙ שִׁבְעָ֣ה מִזְבְּחֹ֔ת וַיַּ֛עַל פָּ֥ר וָאַ֖יִל בַּמִּזְבֵּֽחַ:
    Num 23:13 Then Balak said to him, “Come with me to another place from which you can see them – you will see only a portion of them; you will not see all of them – and damn them for me from there.” 23:14 With that, he took him to Sedeh-zophim, on the summit of Pisgah.
  15. Deut 3:17

    וְעַד יָם הָעֲרָבָה יָם הַמֶּלַח תַּחַת אַשְׁדֹּת הַפִּסְגָּה מִזְרָחָה.
    …down to the sea of the Arabah, the Dead Sea, from the foot of the slopes of Pisgah on the east.

    Deut 4:49

    וְעַד יָם הָעֲרָבָה תַּחַת אַשְׁדֹּת הַפִּסְגָּה.
    …down to the sea of the Arabah from the foot of the slopes of Pisgah on the east.

    Josh 12:3

    וְעַד יָם הָעֲרָבָה יָם־הַמֶּלַח מִזְרָחָה דֶּרֶךְ בֵּית הַיְשִׁמוֹת וּמִתֵּימָן תַּחַת אַשְׁדּוֹת הַפִּסְגָּה:
    …down to the Sea of the Arabah, that is, the Dead Sea, on the east, by way of Beth-jeshimoth southward, at the foot of the slopes of Pisgah.

    Josh 13:20

    וּבֵ֥ית פְּע֛וֹר וְאַשְׁדּ֥וֹת הַפִּסְגָּ֖ה וּבֵ֥ית הַיְשִׁמֽוֹת:
    Beth-peor, the slopes of Pisgah, and Beth-jeshimoth—
  16. See Eusebius, Φασγα “Pisgah” = E. Klostermann, Eusebius Onomastikon der Biblischen Ortsnamen (Leipzig: J. C. Hinrichs, 1904), 16 ll. 22–24; R. Steven Notley and Zeev Safrai,Eusebius, Onomasticon: The Place Names of Divine Scripture (Boston and Leiden: Brill, 2005), 158.

  17. Haran, as well, formulates this similarly. See Menahem Haran, “The Exodus Routes in the Pentateuchal Sources,” Tarbiz 40 (1971): 113–43, esp. 138 (Hebrew). Scholars generally agree that “the steppes of Moab” is a region northeast of the Dead Sea. See Burton MacDonald, “East of the Jordan”: Territories and Sites of the Hebrew Scriptures (ASOR 6; Boston: 2000), 87; Ze’ev Meshel, “Defining the Biblical ‘Araba,'” in “Up to the Gates of Ekron”: Essays on the Archaeology and History of the Eastern Mediterranean in Honor of Seymour Gitin (eds. W. S. Crawford et al.; Albright Institute of Archaeological Research and Israel Exploration Society, 2007), 423–35, n. 6. See the extensive bibliographies in both articles. P and E explicitly mention the Israelite encampment in the steppes of Moab (E – Num 22:1; P – Num 26:3, 63; 31:12, and more). However, according to J, that has the Israelites enter Canaan in the vicinity of Jericho, the journey route also passed to the northeast of the Dead Sea, which is the region that is to be identified with P and E’s “steppes of Moab.”

  18. For more on the battle at Yahatz, see my TABS essay, “War at Yahatz: The Torah Versus the Mesha Stela.” The various references to Yahatz place it to the north of the Arnon, and to the east of the settled region, on the border of the wilderness.

  19. [19] See Martin Noth, ‘Num. 21 als Glied der ‘Hexateuch’ – Erzählung’, ZAW 58 (1940), pp. 161–189, esp. p. 178; Julius Wellhausen, Die Composition des Hexateuchs und der historischen Bucher des Alten Testaments (Berlin: G. Reimer, 1889), 111.

  20. The LXX reading, which is preferable in this case.

  21. Roskop did not examine this possibility, since she maintains that the Documentary Hypothesis cannot be used for the journey route in Transjordan, because the criterion of the name of God is hardly applicable in those chapters. See Roskop, Wilderness Itineraries, 204. But this is a limited and incomplete conceptualization about how the Documentary Hypotheses works. Documentarians do not distinguish between the various documents solely on the basis of differences in divine names; many other factors come into play.

  22. E’s itinerary in Num 20–21 is shorter than the itinerary in the original document. Most of E’s journey in the Araba valley, including Aaron’s death at Moserah was omitted to create the impression that the journey took place on the Jordanian plateau. See my TABS essay,“Why Deuteronomy Has an Account of Aaron’s Death in the Wrong Place,” for details.

  23. [23] See Exod 13:20, 16:1, 17:1, 19:2; Num 10:12, 20:22, 21:11a

  24. [24] Despite, and in opposition to, the proofs that she brought, Roskop states that Num 33 is not Priestly, but rather is a collection of all the itinerary notes, with the addition of sites from the books of Deuteronomy and Joshua that were reformulated in a style imitative of the annals style. See Roskop, Wilderness Itineraries 223–232.

  25. Noth already attributed Kadesh, Mount Hor, Oboth, and Iye-abarim to P. See Noth, “Wallfahrtsweg,” 171; idem, Numbers, 159). Davies argued that Num 33 is an independent source. In order to negate its attribution to P, he asserted, without substantiation, that Mount Hor was copied here from Num 21:4b, which he ascribes to a non-Priestly tradition. See Graham I. Davies, “Wilderness Itineraries” (see n. 1), 1–8, esp. 8, 11.

  26. For more on the different traditions of where Moses is buried in P, J, and E, see my TABS essay, “The Unknown, Yet Known Place of Moses’ Burial.”

  27. I proposed elsewhere viewing the opening verse of Deuteronomy (Deut 1:1) as a journey route leading from the Edomite plateau to north of the Arnon. The Pisgah itinerary of J is the only route that could be the continuation of this journey. See David Ben-Gad HaCohen,Kadesh in the Pentateuchal Narratives (PhD diss., Hebrew University, 2010), 143–145 [Hebrew].

  28. For a reconstruction of the missing first part of J’s itinerary, see my “Where in the Transjordan Did Moses Deliver His Opening Address?” TheTorah (2018). For the reconstruction of some missing parts of E, see my, “Why Deuteronomy Has an Account of the Aaron’s Death in the Wrong Place,” TheTorah (2015); “Jephthah’s Wandering Biblical Message to the King of Ammon,” TheTorah (2017).

  29. Many scholars, like Julius Wellhausen and August Dillmann, divide the Balaam story into two sources. See Julius Wellhausen, Die Composition des Hexateuchs und der historischen Bucher des Alten Testaments (Berlin: Reimer, 1899), 110–111; August Dillman, Die Bücher Numeri, Deuteronomium, Josua (KEHAT2; Leipzig, 1886), ad loc. Of all the various criteria for division suggested, in my view, only the geographical argument has withstood criticism. The parallel account, which calls the same mountain Peor, would be from the E source. Since a single author would not have used the same characterization for different peaks, or use different names for the same mountain, we may reasonably assume that the author who used the toponym “the summit of Pisgah” is not the same author who preferred the toponym “the peak of Peor,” after the name of the adjoining settlement: Beth-peor. For a summation of the objection to the method of Wellhausen and his school regarding the Balaam narrative, see Alexander Rofé, The Book of Balaam: Numbers 22.2–24.25: A Study in Methods of Criticism and the History of Biblical Literature and Religion(Jerusalem: Simor, 1979), 13–26 [Hebrew].

  30. I used to think that both roads ascend to Aroer. Yet, Chaim Ben-David pointed out that there is a Roman road ascending towards Dibon which was inhabited in the Iron age. It means that, there is a possibility of a biblical road which is now covered by the Roman road and the modern road. This is the route of P.

  31. See again my TABS essay, “The Unknown, Yet Known Place of Moses’ Burial.”

  32. Another modern road, Route 65, known as the Dead Sea Highway, also had an ancient parallel, but it is not referenced as one of the itineraries in any source.

  33. For more on this see, David Ben-Gad HaCohen, “Waheb in Suphah: The Forgotten Town in the Stream,” (TheTorah 2020).

  34. For a description of this road, see Amos Kloner and Chaim Ben David, “Mesillot on the Arnon: An Iron Age (Pre-Roman) Road in Moab,” BASOR 330 (2003): 65–81. This road, which had originally been photographed by Nelson Glueck, was unknown to scholars until recently, since Glueck marked the place of the road incorrectly. It was luckily rediscovered decades afterward by Kloner and Ben David, who recognized the spot from the picture as they were exploring the wadi. Yet a fourth crossing point is at Lahun, about halfway between Aroer and the Wilderness Highway crossing. This does not have its own road, but was likely used by people heading east from the Central Moabite Road or west from the Wilderness Highway.

  35. As stated above, I do not think that Numbers 20–21 can be explained well with a supplementary approach, which posits that an original list grew in stages, with different scribes utilizing their own styles. Rather, the documentary approach is best here, according to which the chapter contains three separate itineraries spliced together, each written in its own style and which belong to separate narratives.