Does God Have Halakhic Authority?

In the famous story of the Oven of Akhnai, Rabbi Eliezer makes recourse to divine revelation to defend his legal ruling. Rabbi Joshua responds that “the Torah is not in heaven” and God has no say. Elsewhere in the Talmud, however, heavenly voices are considered authoritative, a view which aligns with that of the Qumran sect, which believed God continues to reveal secret details of Torah laws.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Does God Have Halakhic Authority?." TheTorah.com, August 31, 2021. https://www.thetorah.com/article/does-god-have-halakhic-authority.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Does God Have Halakhic Authority?" (2021, August 31). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/does-god-have-halakhic-authority

Does God Have Halakhic Authority?

The Talmud Lesson, H. Werner, ca. 1900. Wikimedia

Categories:

Nitzavim

Published: August 31, 2021

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Jeffrey Tigay, Deuteronomy, JPS Commentary (Philadelphia: JPS, 1996), 286

  2. In its original context, this likely referred exclusively to the laws of Deuteronomy. See discussion in, David Glatt-Gilad, “Deuteronomy: The First Torah,” TheTorah (2015).

  3. Richard Elliott Friedman, Commentary on the Torah: With a New English Translation and the Hebrew Text (San Francisco: HarperCollins, 2001), 657. 

  4. The tale is part of a larger literary unit incorporating at least the following tale about Rabbi Eliezer’s banishment and the reaction of his wife, and possibly, according to Tova Hartman, the previous tale about how men should treat their wives. A lot has been written on the story, see, e.g., Jeffrey Rubenstein, Talmudic Stories (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins, 1999) 34–63; Tova Hartman with Charlie Buckholtz, Are You Not a Man of God?: Devotion, Betrayal, and Social Criticism in Jewish Tradition (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014), 46–81.  

  5. The dispute originally appears in Tannaitic literature (2nd cent. C.E.), m. Keilim 5:10; t. Eduyot 2:1, upon which the 6th century C.E. Bavli builds its tale.

  6. The Vilna text erroneously reads יצאתה but in all other printings and MSS it is without the aleph.

  7. MSS Vatican 115 (13th cent. Ashkenaz) and Escorial (15th/16th cent. Provence) both add the word בני “my son” here, a term of endearment, which strengthens the claim that R. Eliezer is always right but also highlights how the Heavenly Voice’s argument is not legal in nature, but personal.

  8. Editor’s note: For the question of Deuteronomy’s stance about post-Mosaic divine revelation of law, see Jonathan Stökl, “Can There Be Another Prophet Like Moses?” TheTorah (2017).

  9. R. Jeremiah also brings another prooftext to his argument: אחרי רבים להטות “after the majority should one incline” (Exod 23:2). This is a standard rabbinic principle, derived from this verse, that even if God were to get a vote, it would only be God and Rabbi Eliezer against the majority, and majority rules. The phrase as quoted, however, omits the negative particle לֹא that appears at the beginning of the verse: ‏לֹא...אַחֲרֵי רַבִּים לְהַטֹּת. In context, the verse actually means that one should not follow a majority if that majority is doing something wrong. The rabbis thus employ the passage to claim the opposite of what it actually says.

  10. The Jerusalem Talmud tends to cut and paste entire passages in multiple places. These are often called סוגיות מועברות, “passages that have been brought over.”

  11. The text then describes where this announcement took place:

    ואיכן יצאת בת קול. רבי ביבי בשם ר' יוחנן ביבנה יצאת בת קול.
    And where did this heavenly voice make its announcement? Rabbi Bibi [said] in the name of R. Yohanan: “The heavenly voice made its announcement in Yavneh.”
  12. Text here follows the 14th cent. Oxford 366 MS, which differs slightly from the Vilna text. In any event, no version here has significant variants relative to the point being made above.

  13. The Talmud continues with a third answer, but it is not relevant to our discussion here.

  14. The tale of the Oven of Akhnai is a 6th century C.E. text that presents a story about a 2nd century C.E. legal dispute.

  15. For more on divine secrets in the Bible, see the overview on Bible Odyssey by Alan Lenzi, “Divine Secrets.” For a detailed discussion of divine secrets in the ANE in general, see idem, Secrecy and the Gods: Secret Knowledge in Ancient Mesopotamia and Biblical Israel, SAA 19 (Helsinki: The Neo-Assyrian Text Corpus Project, 2008).

  16. Richard Elliott Friedman highlights the connection between this verse and the speech about the Torah not difficult or far way, noting that in Deuteronomy 30:11–14 “Moses finishes what he started” in 29:28. See Friedman, Commentary on the Torah, 659. See also the discussion of this verse in David Levin-Kruss, “Is Judaism Meant to Have Exclusive Religious Secrets?” TheTorah (2013).

  17. For example, the text talks about ובעוברם בברית “And when they enter the covenant” (1:18) which is reminiscent of לעברך בברית “to enter into the covenant” in Deuteronomy 29:11. Its admonishment of sect members, ולוא ללכת עוד בשרירות לב אשמה “And to no longer walk in the stubbornness of a guilty heart” (1:6), is reminiscent of Deuteronomy 29:18: כי בשרירות לבי אלך “though I walk in the stubbornness of my heart.” The sect’s theological language of law also occurs in the preamble when it states: ולהתהלך לפניו תמים כול הנגלות למועדי תעודותם “and they should walk before him in perfection (according to) all the revealed things concerning the appointed times of their stipulations.”

  18. This is an unusual spelling, but it means to say לאשמה.

  19. Many questions have been raised about the relationship between the Damascus Covenant and the rest of the Qumran sectarian writings. Because of certain differences between them, some have argued that the Damascus Covenant represents an earlier stage in the sect’s development, while others have argued that it was written by a different sect. 

  20. CD 3:12–16

  21. One distinctive feature of Qumran Hebrew is to spell third-person pronouns and pronominal suffixes with an extra vowel at the end.

  22. Here and elsewhere in the Rule of the Community, the text notes that revelation is unfurled over time and that different legal interpretations prevailed at different times. The text also refers in other places to the תכון העת “the regulation of the time” and the חוק העת “the decree of the time.”

  23. See also b. Megillah 2b.

  24. The rabbinic view is later codified and expanded upon in Maimonides and other codes. See discussion in Kenneth Seeskin, “Prophecy and Legislation after Moses,” TheTorah (2020).

  25. Ancient scribes typically used such dots to indicate to later scribes that the marked letters should not be copied, either because they are a scribal error or due to some other problem with the words.

  26. Editor’s note: For more on Proto-MT, see Emanuel Tov, “The (Proto-)Masoretic Text: A Ten-Part Series,” TheTorah (2017).

  27. Albert I. Baumgarten (“Dots on Deuteronomy 29:28: A Polemical Response to Qumran’s Secret Laws,” TheTorah [2020]) argues that the dots were intentionally placed on the wrong spot, and that the Masoretes wished to erase the words לי־הוה אלהינו, yielding a verse that reads “the secret and the revealed our for us and our children.” The scribes did not put them over these words directly, to avoid the sin of erasing God’s name, but their point was polemical. Thus, Baumgarten concludes, “the dots were added as a polemical device, to undercut the Qumran group and its analogs, who claimed the benefit of special revelation…by having the verse state explicitly that all Jews were subject to and had access to the same divine revelation.”

Related Topics:Halacha