Maimonides’ Mishneh Torah. Illuminator: Attributed to Master of the Barbo Missal (Italian) Date: ca. 1457. Jointly owned by The Israel Museum, Jerusalem, and The Metropolitan Museum of Art.
On the Problem of Sacrifices: Maimonides’ Ladder of Enlightenment
Maimonides, in his Guide of the Perplexed, portrays sacrifices as a ruse to repudiate idolatrous practices prevalent at the time. In Mishneh Torah, however, Maimonides states that the messiah will rebuild the Temple and restore sacrifices just as they once were. How are Maimonides’ two works reconcilable?
Published: March 20, 2018
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
[1] iii. 32 (pp. 525-31). References to the Guide of the Perplexed (henceforth Guide) are to the English translation by Shlomo Pines (Chicago 1974).
[2] The idea that sacrifices represent an immature phase of worship, the fully developed phase being pure meditation, is reinforced by the comparison Maimonides draws in Guide iii. 32 to the weaning of an infant and its gradual introduction to adult food.
[3] The laws of purity are ancillary to sacrifices in that Maimonides explains them as designed to make visits to the Temple infrequent and thus preserve the awe that the place and its rituals are meant to inspire – see Guide iii. 47 (pp. 592-7).
[4] See his commentary on Lev. 1: 9, where he instead proposes a two-tiered explanation: sacrifices as vicarious suffering for the penitent, and as a theurgic mystery; see Dov Schwartz, “From Theurgy to Magic: The Evolution of the Magical-Talismanic Justification of Sacrifice in the Circle of Nahmanides and his Interpreters,” Aleph: Historical Studies in Science and Judaism, 1 (2001): 165-213.
[5] Joseph B. Soloveitchik, The Halakhic Mind (New York, 1986), 131 n. 108. I hope to demonstrate that Maimonides’ explanation is at least as philosophically penetrating as that of Nahmanides.
[6] See Russell Jay Hendel, “Maimonides’ Attitude Towards Sacrifices”, Tradition: A Journal of Orthodox Jewish Thought, 13/14 (1973): 163-79. http://www.jstor.org/stable/23257287.
[7] See George Y. Kohler, Reading Maimonides’ Philosophy in 19th Century Germany(Amsterdam Studies in Jewish Philosophy 15; Dordrecht: Springer, 2012), 193-209. Editor’s note: One medieval sage who really does seem to see sacrifices as a negative was R. Joseph ibn Kaspi, who writes, in his Gevia’ ha-Kesef,
…[M]ost people strive to imitate their forefathers. For this reason, Moses in the Torah told us to offer sacrifices, even though in truth they are an abomination.
See: Basil Herring, Joseph Ibn Kaspi’s Gevia’ Ha-Kesef (New York: Ktav, 1982), 159.
[8] See his Mitpahat sefarim (Lvov, 1870), 61. For more on Emden and others who found theMishneh Torah and the Guide incompatible, see Herbert A. Davidson, Moses Maimonides, the Man and His Works (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005), 418-25.
[9] See David Henshke, “On the Question of Unity in Maimonides’ Thought,” Da’at, 37 (1996): 37-52 [Heb]. The idea that sacrifices fulfill God’s will is expressed by Rashi on Lev. 1:9.
[10] See Guide iii. 26-27 (pp. 502-510) and iii. 31 (pp. 523-4). Maimonides does acknowledge that the details of some commandments may be arbitrary.
[11] “this legislation is not a vain matter without a useful end, and… if it seems to you that this is the case with regard to some of the commandments, the deficiency lies in your apprehension” – Guide iii. 26 (p. 507).
[12] See “Laws Concerning Trespass” (Hilkhot me’ilah), 8: 8. Maimonides states there that all the sacrifices are statutes (‘hukim’) and defines a statute as a commandment the reason for which is not obvious. It is argued in chapter 8 of Menachem Kellner and David Gillis,Maimonides the Universalist: The Ethical Horizons of Mishneh Torah (Littman Library of Jewish Civilization, forthcoming), that Maimonides did not consider “statute” to be a fixed attribute of any commandment, but a function of knowledge, which may vary from person to person and from time to time. This halakhah will be discussed further in a follow-up essay. See also Josef Stern, “The Idea of a Hoq in Maimonides’ Explanation of the Law,”Maimonides and Philosophy – Papers Presented at the Sixth Jerusalem Philosophical Encounter (Dordrecht, 1986), 92-130; reproduced in idem, Problems and Parables of Law: Maimonides and Nahmanides on Reasons for the Commandments (Albany: State University of New York Press, 1998), 15-48.
[13] See Guide iii. 24 (pp. 497-502).
[14] By “Aristotelians” is meant the ideas and doctrines of Aristotle’s interpreters and continuers, particularly the Islamic philosophers Alfarabi and Avicenna (both of whom Maimonides admired – see his “Letter to Ibn Tibbon Concerning the Translation of the Guide”) with their amalgam of Aristotle and Neoplatonism.
[15] See the introduction to part iii of the Guide, where Maimonides states that in the ensuing interpretation of the vision in Ezek. 1 (“ma’aseh hamerkavah”):
I followed conjecture and supposition; no divine revelation has come to me to teach me that the intention in the matter in question was such and such, nor did I receive what I believe in these matters from a teacher (p. 416).
The interpretation itself, if read, as Maimonides advises it should be, in the context of the Guide as whole, turns out to construe the vision as a representation (and in fact an imperfect one) of the Aristotelian model of the universe. In other words, Maimonides interprets the central mystery of Judaism, which he himself describes as “a stake upon which everything hangs and a pillar upon which everything is supported” (ibid.), in terms of the cosmology of the philosophers. See Daniel Davies, “The Secret of the Ma’aseh Merkava,” TheTorah.com(2015). This cannot be dismissed as a sop to Jews whose faith has been adulterated by philosophy, since Maimonides makes the identification of ma’aseh bereshit (the act of creation) and ma’aseh merkavah (“the act of [Ezekiel’s] chariot”) with the philosophers’ physics and metaphysics in his early rabbinic work the Commentary on the Mishnah (see on Mishnah Hag., 2:1), and maintains it in the Mishneh Torah (see, “Laws Concerning the Foundations of the Torah” (Hilkhot yesodei hatorah), 4:13.
[16] See Guide iii. 27 (pp. 510-512), and Kellner, Maimonides on Human Perfection, Atlanta, 1989.
[17] See “Laws Concerning Moral Qualities” (Hilkhot de’ot), 1: 5. Where possible, references for Maimonides’ philosophical concepts are given to the Mishneh Torah, to demonstrate how thoroughly philosophy is integrated into that work.
[18] “Laws Concerning the Foundations of the Torah”, 2: 2, trans. Hyamson.
[19] See Guide i. 54 (p. 125).
[20] Guide ii. 5 (p. 259). See also ‘Laws Concerning the Foundations of the Torah’, 3: 9.
[21] Maimonides compares the process of emanation to a flow of water from a spring – seeGuide 2: 12 (pp. 279-80).
[22] It should be made clear that as far as Maimonides is concerned, angels are part of nature, not God’s entourage. In Guide ii. 6 (pp. 261-5) he practically identifies them with natural forces.
[23] “Similarly the causes of every motion belonging to the sphere are four: namely the shape of the sphere – I mean its sphericity; its soul; and its intellect through which it has conceptions, as we have explained; and the separate intellect, which is its beloved.” – Guideii. 10 (p. 271).
[24] Love of its governing angel makes the sphere desire to unite with it, but since (a) as non-physical entities, angels have no location and (b) spheres are round, each sphere moves with constant circular motion, but at a speed peculiar to it – hence the differing motions of the planets. All this is explained in Guide ii. 3-10. The system is further complicated by epicycles, like gear wheels on the spheres, to account for apparent regression of the planets, but that is not our concern here.
[25] Although the names of the orders of angels are plural in Hebrew, Maimonides treats them as single entities, each equivalent to one of the “separate intellects” of the philosophers.
[26] See “Laws Concerning the Foundations of the Torah,” 4: 5-6. The spheres and stars themselves are made of a different, more refined substance that does not change or decay. See “Laws Concerning the Foundations of the Torah,” 3: 3 and 3: 10.
[27] See “Laws Concerning the Foundations of the Torah,” 4: 6.
[28] See “Laws Concerning the Foundations of the Torah,” 7: 3.
[29] See Guide i. 72. The idea is also implicit in certain structural patterns in the Book of Knowledge, the first book of the Mishneh Torah, but space does not permit a detailed treatment of that here. See Gillis, Reading Maimonides’ Mishneh Torah (Oxford: Littman Library of Jewish Civilization, 2015), 82-97 [henceforth Reading)].
[30] See “Laws Concerning the Foundations of the Torah,” 4: 8.
[31] This ideal is expressed in “Laws Concerning Repentance” (Hilkhot teshuvah), 10: 3.
[32] See the brief descriptions of the fourteen books in the introduction to the Mishneh Torah, and Guide iii. 35 (p. 538). For detailed discussion of this division within the Mishneh Torah and of apparent anomalies in it, see Reading, 158-162. The question of the structure of the Mishneh Torah is debated between the present writer and Prof. Lawrence Kaplan inHakirah, the Flatbush Journal of Jewish Law and Thought, Vol. 21 (Summer 2016): 41-59.
[33] See “Laws Concerning the Foundations of the Torah,”, 2: 5-6.
[34] That discussion can be found in Reading, 208-39.
[35] Maimonides’ final move in the bein adam lamakom division of the Mishneh Torah is to stand this on its head and to turn mikveh into a metaphor for intellect – ‘Laws Concerning Immersion Pools’ (Hilkhot mikva’ot), 13: 12. This will be revisited in part two of this essay.
[36] Guide iii. 32 (p. 527).
[37] Guide iii. 32 (p. 529).
[38] See “Laws Concerning the Foundations of the Torah,” 2:1.
[39] See “Laws Concerning Repentance,” 10: 1.
[40] See “Laws Concerning the Temple” (Hilkhot beit habehirah), 7: 1.
[41] “According to the knowledge shall be the love” – ‘Laws Concerning Repentance’, 10: 6.
[42] For a fuller account of the order of the books of the Mishneh Torah, see Reading, 208-68.
[43] See “Laws Concerning Repentance,” 9: 2. On this proposal for the future value of sacrifices according to Maimonides, see Kenneth Seeskin, No Other Gods: The Modern Struggle Against Idolatry (West Orange, NJ: Behrman House, 1995).
[44] The above is an interim suggestion. In a follow-up essay, we shall see what more the Mishneh Torah’s microcosmic form can tell us about the meaning of sacrifices and their enduring worth.