Ezra stands on a wooden tower near the water gate and reads the laws of Moses (adapted). Jan Luyken, after Bernard Picart, 1700 rijksmuseum.nl
Historical Hakhel Ceremonies and the Origin of Public Torah Reading
Deuteronomy’s command to publicly read the Torah on Sukkot every seven years appears in stories about King Josiah, King Agrippa, and Ezra the Scribe. The latter’s innovative ceremony served as the model for what became synagogue Torah-reading.
Published: September 15, 2017
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
Editor’s note: For another discussion of this text, Marc Z. Brettler, “The Hakhel Ceremony: Who, What, When, and Where?” TheTorah.com(2014).
In the standard printing, between this passage and the blessings and curses, appears the “passage about the king” (פרשת המלך), ostensibly a reference to 17:14-20. This passage would then appear out of order. R. Ovadiah of Bartanura (ad loc.), who has this text, suggests that this reading out of sequence is in order to avoid interrupting between the two passages about tithing. In his commentary on the Mishnah (ad loc.), Maimonides seems to have a third text altogether, without the reference to the second tithing passage (26:12-29) and according to which the king would read straight from 14:22 until the end of the curses in 28:69, a much longer text than the other options.
See my, Literacy in Ancient Israel (Jerusalem: Mossad Bialik, 2012): 246-247 [Hebrew].
See Hayim Tadmor, “Treaty and Oath in the Ancient Near East: A Historian’s Approach,” in Humanizing America’s Iconic Book: Society of Biblical Literature, Centennial Addresses 1980 (eds. Gene M. Tucker and Douglas A. Knight; Chico: Scholars Press, 1982), 127-152; ibid., “With my Many Chariots I Have Gone up the Heights of Mountains”: Historical and Literary Studies on Ancient Mesopotamia and Israel (ed. Mordechai Cogan; Jerusalem: Israel Exploration Society, 2011): 205-236. Tadmor identifies these later Assyrian texts as loyalty oaths rather than vassal treaties. Editor’s note: See also, Pamela Barmash, “The Introduction of Blessings into our Treaty with God” TheTorah.com (2015); Deena Grant, “Loving God Beyond the Way You Love Ashurbanipal,” TheTorah.com (2016); Jon Levenson, “The Shema and the Commandment to Love God in Its Ancient Near Eastern Context” TheTorah.com (2016).
See Amnon Altman, The Historical Prologue of the Hittite Vassal Treaties (Bar-Ilan University Press, Ramat-Gan, 2004)
Moshe Weinfeld, Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomic School (Oxford, 1972): 59-157. See also, Tadmor, “Treaty and Oath” and ibid., With Many Chariots.
Gary Beckman, Hittite Diplomatic Texts 2nd ed. (Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1999), 91.
Fortuitously, that year seems to be the turning point in the 50 year Jubilee cycle that may have been perpetuated in Priestly circles (see Radaq on Ezek 1:1; and Ezek 40:1 in light of Lev 25:9). If so, then the ceremonial reading ordered by Josiah might be related to the completion of the Jubilee cycle at this time. See Aaron Demsky, “Who Came First, Ezra or Nehemiah? The Synchronistic Approach,” Hebrew Union College Annual65 (1994): 12.
See discussion in R. Joseph Babad, Minchat Chinuch, 612:2.
This is based on Ezra’s Torah reading, see later.
Josephus makes no reference to Agrippa performing Hakhel or reading the Torah publicly, though he does describe him as exceedingly pious (Ant. 19.331):
He scrupulously observed the traditions of his people. He neglected no rite of purification, and no day passed for him without the prescribed sacrifice.
Agrippa ruled Judea between 41 and 44 CE, during which time there was a sabbatical year.
Another version of this story is found in Midrash Tannaim to Deut 17:15:
מעשה באגריפס שמשחוהו ישראל מלך עליהן וכיון שהגיע מוצאי שביעית לקרות המלך בספר תורה עמד הוא וקרא…
It happened with Agrippa, whom the Israelites anointed as king over themselves, that when the end of the Sabbatical year came and the king was supposed to read from the Torah scroll he stood up and read and the Sages praised him….
Editor’s note: For other discussions of this text, see Jacob L. Wright,“The Origins of Torah Study,” TheTorah.com (2015); Marc Z. Brettler, “The Hakhel Ceremony: Who, What, When, and Where?” TheTorah.com(2014).
See Richard Steiner, “The meaning of lbqr’ in Ez:14: on the Relation of Ezra’s Mission to the Persian Legal Project,” JBL 120 (2001): 623-646
Demsky, “Who Came First, Ezra or Nehemiah?”: 1-19. For a fuller treatment of this event see Aaron Demsky, Literacy in Ancient Israel: 335-340.
In Herodian times this area would be enclosed and become the Ezrat Nashim; see the Mishnah quoted above.
For autumn as the beginning of the natural year in ancient Israel, see my “The Essence of the Hebrew Calendar,” TheTorah.com (2016).
Y. Kutscher, Words and their History (Kiryath Sepher: Jerusalem, 1965), 10 [Hebrew].
Compare the synagogue custom of hagbahah, i.e. lifting the torahscroll, either after the reading, or following Ezra’s lead, before the reading.
This passage (Neh 8:3, 7) includes two usages of this hiphel form: the intransitive, i.e., “people who understand” and the transitive/causative: “giving understanding” or “making known,” i.e., to teach.
This was pointed out to me in the 1960s by my late teacher Prof. Gerson D. Cohen. Moreover, it seems that Ezra had in mind the term מקרא(י) קדש (Lev. 23; Numb. 29) “Sacred convocation(s)”, i.e., holidays that are so-called in the festival calendars in Leviticus and Numbers.
With this chapter in mind, Yehezkel Kaufmann called Tishrei, the month in which these festivals fall, the “month of Torah.” See Yehezkel Kaufmann, Toldot Ha’emunah Hayisraelit vol. 8 (Mossad Bialik: Jerusalem,1957): 324f [Hebrew].
Perhaps this is because he is reading the entire Pentateuch, which would take much more time than reading only Deuteronomy (or select parts of Deuteronomy, as the Rabbis define the mitzvah).
See m. Yoma 7:1; b. Yoma 68b-69b
It is noteworthy that in the Septuagint to Neh. 8:1, the word ויאספו is translated συνήχθησαν, the aorist passive of the verb συνάγω, “I assemble,” from which “synagogue” is derived.