How Jewish Was Herod?

Despite the negative evaluations of Herod found in traditional Jewish sources, archaeological evidence suggests that, with some notable exceptions, Herod viewed himself as connected to the Jewish religion and made efforts to adhere to its laws, even in his personal lifestyle.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"How Jewish Was Herod?." TheTorah.com, September 22, 2019. https://www.thetorah.com/article/how-jewish-was-herod.

APA Style

Click to copy

"How Jewish Was Herod?" (2019, September 22). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/how-jewish-was-herod

How Jewish Was Herod?

Herod (adapted), 1886-1894 James Tissot. Brooklynmuseum.org

Published: September 22, 2019

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. Idumeans, the Hellenistic name for Edomites, were the dominant population in the Negev in the Second Temple period, but were integrated into Judea once they were conquered by John Hyrcanus, and forced to adopt Judaism.

  2. Asher Altshul, “כלי אבן, גלוסקמאות והורדוס המלך: תמורות בתרבות החומרית בשלהי ימי הבית השני” [Stone Vessels, Ossuaries, and King Herod: Changes in Material Culture at the End of the Second Temple Period], in Eretz Israel 32: Ehud Netzer Volume (2015): 1–5 [p.3].

  3. The fact that Herod preferred the Sadducees, the religious rivals of the Pharisees whom the rabbis see as their spiritual ancestors, certainly did not help his image among the rabbis, and likely contributed to their general dislike of him, which they inherited.

  4. We do not know in this period if Judaism was determined patrilineally or matrilineally, or whether multiple approaches to the question existed. (In Rabbinic Judaism, Jewish identity is matrilineal.) Nor do we know if Herod’s mother identified Jewish or underwent any conversion process upon marrying Antipater.

  5. Although purification with water already appears in the biblical text, ritual baths only began to appear in Judea in the 3rd century B.C.E., probably under the influence of Hellenistic bathhouses, and became common only in the Hasmonean period. See discussion in Hayah Katz, “Biblical Purification: Was It Immersion?” TheTorah.com (2014); Yonatan Adler, “On the Origins of Tevilah (Ritual Immersion),” TheTorah.com (2017).

  6. Amnon Ben-Tor, בחזרה למצדה [Back to Masada] (Jerusalem: Ben-Zvi, 2009), 33–34.

  7. Rachel Bar-Nathan and Judit Gärtner, “The Stone Artefacts from the Hasmonean and Herodian Palaces at Jericho and Cyprus,” in Hasmonean and Herodian Palaces vol. 5 Final Reports of the 1973-1987 Excavations, ed. Rachel Bar-Nathan (Jerusalem: Israel Exploration Society, 2013), 206.

  8. Editor’s note: That Idumean converts would have kept purity laws fits with the findings in Hebron, a city of Idumean converts, which had a number of mikvaot. See the addendum to, David Ben-Shlomo, “The Ancient City of Hebron,” TheTorah.com (2018).

  9. See discussion in Gabriel Barkay and Zachi Dvira, “What We Learned from Sifting the Earth of the Temple Mount,” TheTorah.com (2018).

  10. Silvia Rozenberg, “עיטורי הפנים בארמונות הורדוס” [The Interior Design in Herod’s Palaces], in הורדוס: מסעו האחרון של מלך יהודה [Herod The Great: The King’s Final Journey], ed. Silvia Rozenberg and David Mevorah (Jerusalem: The Israel Museum, 2013), 174–190.

  11. The reasons why Herod violated this ban with this particular image in this particular place are too complex to be discussed here and require a separate treatment.

  12. Apparently bothered by the idea that the hated Herod renovated the Temple, the rabbis retell the story to cast themselves or their predecessors as the real heroes of that story. See discussion in, Jeffrey Rubenstein, “Herod’s Renovation of the Temple: The Talmudic Version,” TheGemara.com (2017); ibid., “Herod’s Renovation of the Temple: Uncovering the Talmud’s Persian Influences,” TheGemara.com (2017).

  13. Ehud Netzer, “התפתחות מפעלי הבנייה של הורדוס” [The Development of Herod’s Building Projects], in Ariel 201–202 (2012): 63–70 [p.67]. Several suggestions have been made as to the function of the Royal Portico, but most tend to agree that it may have served for commercial activities connected and conducted around the ritual in the Temple.

  14. The quip was only preserved in Latin, but it was almost certainly delivered in Greek because of the wordplay. See discussion in, Raymond Brown,The Birth of the Messiah. A Commentary on the Infancy Narratives in the Gospels of Matthew and Luke (New York: Doubleday, 1993), 226. Editor’s note: For more on the insults traded between Jews and Romans about pig consumption, see Malka Simkovich, “Why Rome Is Likened to a Boar,” TheTorah.com (2019).

  15. See Hannah Cotton, Omri Lernau, and Yuval Gadot, “Fish Sauces from Herodian Masada,” Journal of Roman Archaeology 9 (1996): 223–238.

  16. Avner Ecker, “לסעוד על שולחן המלך” [Dining at the King’s Table], in הורדוס: מסעו האחרון של מלך יהודה [Herod The Great: The King’s Final Journey], ed. Silvia Rozenberg and David Mevorah (Jerusalem: The Israel Museum, 2013), 66-73.

  17. As Herod did not take a clear stand during the Battle of Actium, opting to wait it out and see who comes out victorious instead, he needed to beg for Octavian’s forgiveness for not supporting him outright. To the surprise of everyone, including Herod himself, he received the pardon, the kingdom and some additional “gifts.”

  18. Elaborated constructed monuments that provided water to the city. In Hellenistic times, such monuments once had religious connotations, but by the Roman period they had become purely recreational.

  19. Aryeh Kasher and Eliezer Witztum, הורדוס מלך רודף ורדוף [King Herod: A Persecuted Persecutor] (Haifa: Haifa University Press, 2007), 339–342.

Related Topics:HerodRomeKingship